Molecular Pathogenesis
In the initial description of TGFBR2 pathogenic variants causing a phenotype similar to Marfan syndrome [Mizuguchi et al 2004] it was observed that recombinantly expressed mutated receptors in cells that were naïve for TGFβ receptors could not support TGFβ signaling. Furthermore, there was no apparent dominant-negative interference on the function of coexpressed wild type receptor. These data were interpreted to indicate haploinsufficiency and consequent reduced TGFβ signaling as the relevant pathogenic mechanisms.
In keeping with this hypothesis, one of the original individuals with a Marfan syndrome-like phenotype was shown to harbor a translocation breakpoint within TGFBR2. Complicating this hypothesis, however, is the observation of a distinct paucity of pathogenic nonsense or frameshift variants in either of the TGFβ receptor genes in persons with LDS or related phenotypes. The mutated receptor subunits may not traffic to the cell surface or may not cycle, resulting in "functional haploinsufficiency." The only reported nonsense variant occurs at the very distal margin of the penultimate exon. As opposed to more proximal pathogenic nonsense variants, this context is not predicted to induce nonsense-mediated mRNA decay and clearance of the mutated transcripts. As a result, most (if not all) pathogenic variants in the TGFβ receptor genes associated with vascular phenotypes are predicted to give rise to a mutated receptor protein that has the ability to traffic to the cell surface and bind extracellular ligand, but that specifically lacks the ability to propagate the intracellular TGFβ signal. This hypothesis is also consistent with the finding that pathogenic variants cluster in the intracellular part of both TGFBR1 and TGFBR2 (serine-threonine kinase domains), with few pathogenic variants described in the extracellular domain. However, a model that singularly invokes decreased TGFβ signaling would be difficult to reconcile with the substantial evidence that many aspects of Marfan syndrome, including those that overlap with LDS, are caused by too much TGFβ signaling and can be attenuated or prevented by TGFβ antagonism in animal models.
Experiments exploring TGFβ signaling in cells that only express mutated receptors may not be informative for the situation in vivo when affected individuals are heterozygous for these pathogenic variants. Diminished but not absent function of TGFβ receptors may initiate chronic and dysregulated compensatory mechanisms that result in too much TGFβ signaling. Indeed, the study of fibroblasts derived from heterozygous individuals with LDS failed to reveal any defect in the acute phase response to administered ligand and showed an apparent increase in TGFβ signaling after 24 hours of ligand deprivation and a slower decline in the TGFβ signal after restoration of ligand. An even more informative result was the observation of increased nuclear accumulation of pSmad2 in the aortic wall of persons with either Marfan syndrome or LDS, and increased expression of TGFβ-dependent gene products such as collagen and CTGF. Taken together, these data demonstrate increased TGFβ signaling in the vasculature of persons with LDS and in a context that is directly relevant to tissue development and homeostasis in vivo. Although the basis for this observation remains incompletely understood, it also seems possible that dysregulation of signaling requires the cell surface expression of receptors that can bind TGFβ ligands, but that cannot propagate signal because of a deficiency in kinase function. In support of this hypothesis, it was shown that transgenic expression of a mutated, kinase domain-deleted form of TβRII leads to increased TGFβ signaling, including stimulation of the intracellular signaling cascade and increased output of TGFβ-responsive genes, clearly suggesting a gain-of-function mechanism for mutated TGFβ receptors in LDS.
SMAD2
Gene structure.
NM_001003652.3 represents the longest transcript (11 exons, 10 coding) and encodes the longest isoform, NP_001003652.1. For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Pathogenic variants. The currently known pathogenic variants in SMAD2 are predicted to lead to loss of function because they affect the functionally important MH2 domain [Micha et al 2015].
Normal gene product. The reference sequence NP_001003652.1 has 467 amino acids. SMAD proteins are signal transducers and transcriptional modulators that mediate multiple signaling pathways. This protein functions as a transcriptional modulator activated by transforming growth factor-beta (provided by RefSeq, Apr 2009).
Abnormal gene product. No functional studies have been reported to date.
SMAD3
Gene structure.
NM_005902.3 represents the longest transcript (9 exons) and encodes the longest isoform of 425 AA (NP_005893.1). For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Pathogenic variants. Most variants in SMAD3 are predicted to lead to loss of function. This is supported by the fact that about half of the currently reported pathogenic variants lead to nonsense or out-of-frame frameshift variants [Wischmeijer et al 2013]
Normal gene product. The reference sequence NP_005893.1 has 425 amino acids.
SMAD proteins are signal transducers and transcriptional modulators that mediate multiple signaling pathways. This protein functions as a transcriptional modulator activated by transforming growth factor-beta (provided by RefSeq, Apr 2009).
Abnormal gene product. Despite the predicted loss-of-function nature of most SMAD3 pathogenic variants, a paradoxic gain of function on the overall TGFβ signaling pathway in aortic walls of affected individuals has been observed [van de Laar et al 2011].
TGFB2
Gene structure.
TGFB2 consists of eight exons (NM_001135599.2). For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Pathogenic variants. As with SMAD3, loss of function is the predicted mechanism that leads to disease. This hypothesis is supported by the observation of whole-gene deletions, nonsense variants, and pathogenic variants affecting critical sites for the activation of the TGFB2 cytokine from its latent state [Lindsay et al 2012].
Normal gene product. The reference sequence NM_001135599.2 has 442 amino acids. TGFB2 belongs to the superfamily of TGFB ligands and has three isoforms: TGFB1, TGFB2, and TGFB3. The TGF-β family comprises three cytokines that regulate multiple aspects of cellular behavior, including proliferation, differentiation, migration, and specification of synthetic repertoire. Postnatally, TGF-β activity is most closely linked to wound healing, productive modulation of the immune system, and multiple pathologic processes including cancer progression and tissue fibrosis.
Abnormal gene product. Similar to SMAD3, despite the predicted loss of function of TGFB2 protein, increased TGFβ signaling was demonstrated in aortic walls of affected individuals who were heterozygous for a pathogenic variant in TGFB2 [Lindsay et al 2012].
TGFB3
Gene structure. The longest transcript variant of TGFB3 consists of seven exons (NM_003239.4). For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Pathogenic variants. As with TGFB2, loss of function is the predicted mechanism that leads to disease. This hypothesis is supported by the observation of nonsense and out-of-frame splice site variants, and pathogenic variants affecting critical sites for the activation of the TGFB3 cytokine from its latent state [Bertoli-Avella et al 2015].
Normal gene product. The reference sequence NM_003239.4 encodes a protein of 412 amino acids (NP_003230.1). TGFB3 belongs to the superfamily of TGFB ligands and has three isoforms: TGFB1, TGFB2, and TGFB3. The TGF-β family comprises three cytokines that regulate multiple aspects of cellular behavior including proliferation, differentiation, migration, and specification of synthetic repertoire. Postnatally, TGF-β activity is most closely linked to wound healing, productive modulation of the immune system, and multiple pathologic processes including cancer progression and tissue fibrosis.
Abnormal gene product. Similar to TGFB2, despite the predicted loss of function of TGFB3 protein, increased TGFβ signaling was demonstrated in aortic walls of affected individuals who were heterozygous for a pathogenic variant in TGFB3 [Bertoli-Avella et al 2015].
TGFBR1
Gene structure.
TGFBR1 (also referred to as activin receptor like kinase 5, or ALK-5) consists of nine exons. For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Benign variants. Benign variants in the coding region of TGFBR1 are uncommon except for the polymorphic repeats encoding polyalanine in exon 1 (reference sequence NM_004612.2).
Pathogenic variants. The large majority of pathogenic variants identified so far are located in the exons coding for the intracellular serine-threonine kinase domain of both receptors. They most commonly involve pathogenic missense variants; only a few nonsense variants have been described.
Normal gene product.
TGFBR1 encodes a protein of 503 amino acids (reference sequence NP_004603.1). TGFβ binds to three subtypes of cell surface receptors, known as the receptors type I, II, and III. Type I and II receptors are both serine/threonine kinase receptors that differ by the presence in type I of a glycine/serine-rich juxta-membrane domain (GS domain), which is critical for its activation. Upon binding of the ligand to the constitutively active type II receptor, TβRI is recruited and transphosphorylated in the GS domain, thereby stimulating its protein kinase activity. The activated type I receptor propagates the signal inside the cell through phosphorylation of receptor-regulated SMADS (R-SMADS), SMAD2, or SMAD3. Activated or phosphorylated R-SMADS form heteromeric complexes with SMAD4 that translocate to the nucleus, where they control gene expression.
Abnormal gene product. See Molecular Pathogenesis.
TGFBR2
Gene structure.
TGFBR2 consists of seven exons (NM_001024847.2). For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Pathogenic variants. The large majority of pathogenic variants identified so far are located in the exons coding for the intracellular serine-threonine kinase domain of both receptors. They most commonly involve pathogenic missense variants; only a few nonsense variants have been described.
Normal gene product.
TGFBR2 encodes a protein of 567 amino acids (NP_001020018.1).
Abnormal gene product. See Molecular Pathogenesis.