Clinical practices and protocols for typical X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (X-SCID) can vary depending on the center; however, many aspects overlap in an effort to minimize infection and maximize pre-hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) management in infants with abnormal newborn screening results.
The following outlines management based on the Primary Immune Deficiency Treatment Consortium (PIDTC) analysis [Dorsey et al 2021].
Treatment of Manifestations
The current goals of treatment include ensuring the safety of the infant/child, prophylaxis for infections, and preemptive hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) prior to the development of symptoms.
Ensuring the safety of the infant pending HSCT. See Agents/Circumstances to Avoid.
Interim management includes treatment of infections and use of immunoglobulin infusions and antibiotics, particularly prophylaxis against Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia (formerly Pneumocystis carinii) and, in most cases, fungal infections. Prophylaxis against viral infections depends on exposure and frequent surveillance via viral PCR-based testing with appropriate targeted viral-specific therapy if present.
HSCT to establish a functional immune system. Prompt immune reconstitution is required for survival of children with X-SCID [Pai et al 2014, Heimall et al 2017]. HSCT was first successful in 1968 and remains the standard means of immune reconstitution.
The general experience is that HLA-matched HSCT restores T-cell immunity in more than 90% of unconditioned individuals or individuals with SCID, although B-cell reconstitution occurs preferentially in a subset of these individuals who have NK- SCID [Hassan et al 2012, Pai et al 2014].
Although many centers have expertise in performing HSCT in individuals with malignancy, the following special issues arising in HSCT for X-SCID require involvement of immunodeficiency specialists for an optimal outcome. Individuals with X-SCID (who have no immune system or at best an immune system minimally capable of rejecting the graft) do not typically require myeloablative-conditioning regimens. Rather, "reduced-intensity conditioning (RIC)" regimens are preferred as they employ agents at doses that do not result in long-lasting marrow aplasia.
HLA-matched HSCT from a relative is preferred; however, 70% of affected individuals lack a matched related donor [
Gragert et al 2014].
In the 100 transplants performed for individuals with SCID (including 33 with X-SCID) from 2010 to 2014, no statistically significant difference was observed between donor types; therefore, unrelated donors and umbilical cord grafts present viable options [
Heimall et al 2017]. Of note, bone marrow is the preferred graft source.
For infants who do not have a matched related donor, haploidentical parental bone marrow or mobilized peripheral blood that has been depleted of T cells can be used [
Pai et al 2014]. Techniques for
ex vivo T-cell depletion (TCD) have evolved overtime, with CD34
+ selection, TCRαβ/CD19 depletion currently used. TCD aims to remove mismatched alloreactive T cells that could react against the baby's (i.e., the host’s) tissues, and thus cause graft-vs-host disease (GVHD).
In both retrospective and prospective SCID cohorts since 2000, fewer than 30% of individuals received myeloablative-conditioning regimen, with 35%-65% of individuals receiving no conditioning or only immunosuppression (serotherapy). Note that conditioning regimens are typically used when grafts from unrelated donors are used [
Pai et al 2014,
Heimall et al 2017].
The best timing for HSCT is shortly after birth, as young infants are less likely than older infants to have had serious infections or failure to thrive. In 25 centers, the prospective analysis performed by the PIDTC [Pai et al 2014] found the following:
Over the last decade significantly better outcomes (>90% survival) in children without prior infections who received transplantation in early infancy (age <3.5 months) even with use of alternative donor grafts (i.e., donor not a matched sib, but rather a haploidentical individual, mismatched individual, or cord blood).
Presence of active infections was the main factor affecting overall survival, with nine of 11 deaths occurring in children who had infections prior to transplantation.
Younger infants in whom no conditioning is used also have more rapid engraftment, fewer post-transplantation infections, less GVHD with TCD grafts, and shorter hospitalizations. In contrast, in very young infants who require conditioning, there is a fine balance between risk of acquiring infection versus short- and long-term toxicities associated with use of conditioning.
While it is expected that universal newborn screening will lead to a decrease of pre-transplantation infections and even better survival rates, optimal timing of transplantation and intensity of conditioning regimens (when required) still need to be defined in the era of universal newborn screening for SCID.
Complications following HSCT can include GVHD, graft failure, failure to produce adequate antibodies requiring long-term immunoglobulin replacement therapy, inadequate and declining T cells associated with late graft failure (presumably due to declining numbers of engrafted hematopoietic stem cells), chronic warts, lymphocyte dysregulation leading to post-transplant autoimmunity, and (rarely) secondary malignancy.
Post-transplantation all individuals have some degree of immunodeficiency, especially in the first six to 12 months, during which time the following are necessary:
Prophylaxis for pneumocystis jiroveci pneumonia as well as fungal, viral, and encapsulated organisms in individuals who develop post-HSCT chronic GVHD as per transplantation protocols until the immune system is competent
Consideration of IVIG prophylaxis to maintain serum IgG levels above 600 mg/dL
Prompt evaluation of illnesses until immunocompetence is achieved
Individuals with primary immunodeficiency post-transplantation need to meet criteria for immunocompetence (adequate CD4 and CD19 counts, PHA lymphocyte proliferation, and freedom from immunoglobulin supplementation) before starting vaccinations.
Administration of immunoglobulin. Long-term scheduled administration of immunoglobulin may be required in those who fail to develop allogeneic, functional B lymphocytes after transplantation.
Gene therapy. Gene therapy has been evaluated in individuals who are not eligible for HSCT, who have failed HSCT, and/or who have only haploidentical donors.
Gene therapy performed with no conditioning regimen using autologous bone marrow stem/progenitor cells transduced with gamma-retroviral vectors expressing a therapeutic gene resulted in significant T-cell reconstitution in the majority of young infants with X-SCID. B-cell reconstitution was less consistent; only about 50% of infants were able to discontinue gamma-globulin replacement therapy.
Unfortunately, two to 14 years after treatment in two independent trials using gamma-retroviral vectors, six of 20 individuals developed T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia, which was fatal in one. Data revealed that retroviral insertional activation of cellular-growth regulatory genes led to the malignant transformation [Howe et al 2008, Hacein-Bey-Abina et al 2010, Deichmann et al 2011, Fischer & Hacein-Bey-Abina 2020].
A subsequent clinical trial that utilized gamma-retroviral vectors with improved safety design (utilizing self-inactivating [SIN] vectors) demonstrated safety and partial efficacy in nine individuals over three years post transplantation: efficacy in T-cell reconstitution, no adverse events, and significantly fewer insertions in genes implicated in lymphoproliferation [Hacein-Bey-Abina et al 2014].
Due to the risk for insertional mutagenesis inherent with use of gamma-retroviral vectors, investigators developed next-generation lentiviral vectors that can transverse the nuclear membrane and transduce both mitotic and non-mitotic hematopoietic stem cells [Wiznerowicz & Trono 2005]. Results of a Phase I-II trial and subsequent publication of interim results were reported in 2019 [Mamcarz et al 2019a, Mamcarz et al 2019b]. Eleven newly diagnosed individuals with X-SCID were treated with a SIN lentiviral vector encoding for IL2RG-complementary DNA. Transduced autologous bone marrow stem cells were delivered following low-dose busulfan conditioning (22 mg*hr/L). No severe adverse events (other than myelosuppression related to busulfan) were observed. Within three to four months following therapy, normal T-cell and NK-cell development was observed. With a median follow up of two years, 50% of treated individuals were able to discontinue IVIG supplementation, and none had clonal expansion or malignant transformation. (For active trials, see Therapies Under Investigation.)