Clinical Description
Developmental delay, cognitive dysfunction, and intellectual disability are common to all three creatine deficiency disorders (CDDs). See Table 2 for comparison of the three deficiencies; further details follow the table.
Table 2.
Creatine Deficiency Disorders: Comparison of Phenotypes by Select Features
View in own window
Feature | GAMT Deficiency 1 | AGAT Deficiency 2 | CRTR Deficiency 3 |
---|
DD & cognitive dysfunction 4
| ●●● | ●●● | ●●● |
Speech-language disorder
| ●● | ●● | ●● |
Seizure
| ●● | ● | ●● |
Epilepsy
| ●● | NR | ●● |
Behavior problems
| ●● | ● | ●● |
Muscle weakness /
Myopathy
| NR | ●● | NR |
Hypotonia
| ● | ● | ●● |
Movement disorder
| ● | NR | ● |
●●● = all; ●● = common; ● = infrequent; AGAT = L-arginine:glycine amidinotransferase; CRTR = creatine transporter; DD = developmental delay; GAMT = guanidinoacetate methyltransferase; NR = not reported
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
Note that individuals diagnosed and treated from the newborn period or infancy with good treatment compliance may have normal developmental milestones, cognitive functions, and IQ.
GAMT Deficiency
To date, about 130 individuals have been identified with biallelic pathogenic variants in GAMT [Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2014, Khaikin et al 2018]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports.
Onset of the first clinical manifestations ranges from early infancy (age 3-6 months) to age two years [Khaikin et al 2018]. The age of diagnosis ranges from neonatal to 34 years [Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2014, Khaikin et al 2018].
Developmental delay (DD) and cognitive dysfunction or intellectual disability (ID), the most consistent clinical manifestation, is present in all affected individuals. The severity ranges from mild to severe. About 50%-75% of individuals with GAMT deficiency have severe DD or ID [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2014, Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2014, Khaikin et al 2018].
Speech-language disorder. Variable expressive language defects were reported in two sibs with GAMT deficiency: the proband spoke fewer than ten words, whereas her younger sister spoke in short sentences at age 13 years [O'Rourke et al 2009].
A behavior disorder (e.g., hyperactivity, autism, or self-injurious behavior) is reported in more than 75% of affected individuals [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2014, Khaikin et al 2018].
Seizures, the third most consistent manifestation in GAMT deficiency, are observed in more than 70% of affected individuals. Seizure types include myoclonic, generalized tonic-clonic, partial complex, head nodding, and atonic seizures. Seizure severity ranges from occasional seizures to seizures that are non-responsive to various anti-seizure medications [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2014, Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2014, Khaikin et al 2018].
Movement disorders, observed in about 30% of individuals, are mainly chorea, athetosis, dystonia, or ataxia [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2014, Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2014, Khaikin et al 2018]. Pathologic signal intensities in the basal ganglia in brain MRI are observed in individuals with or without a movement disorder [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2014, Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2014, Khaikin et al 2018]. The onset is usually before age 12 years; however, a young woman with GAMT deficiency was reported to have onset of a movement disorder (including ballistic and dystonic movements) at age 17 years [O'Rourke et al 2009].
AGAT Deficiency
To date, 16 individuals have been identified with biallelic pathogenic variants in GATM [Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2015]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports.
DD and cognitive dysfunction or ID, the most consistent clinical manifestation, is present in all affected individuals. The severity of intellectual disability ranges from mild to severe, although more than 80% of the individuals have mild-to-moderate intellectual disability.
A single seizure, observed in about 10% of affected individuals, was reported to occur with or without fever.
Movement disorders were not reported in any affected individuals.
A behavior disorder was present in 25% of affected individuals.
Muscle weakness / myopathy was observed in 50% of affected individuals.
CRTR Deficiency ‒ Affected Males
To date, about 130 individuals have been identified with a pathogenic variant in SLC6A8 [van de Kamp et al 2013a, Bruun et al 2018, Bahl et al 2020]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports.
Onset of the first clinical manifestations ranges from four to 54 months [Bruun et al 2018]. The age at diagnosis ranges from one to 66 years, indicating that life expectancy can be normal. Now that the disorder is reasonably well described and diagnostic testing is more widely available, it is anticipated that diagnosis will mainly occur within the first three years of life.
DD and cognitive dysfunction or ID was present in all affected male individuals ranging from mild to severe: 85% of affected males had mild-to-moderate ID up to age four years; 75% of affected males older than age 18 years had severe ID [van de Kamp et al 2013a]. One adult had progressive cognitive dysfunction [Kleefstra et al 2005].
Speech-language disorder. Speech development was delayed in all affected males. First words were at a mean age of 3.1 years (age range: 9 months to 10 years). In affected males older than age ten years, 14% had no speech development, 55% were able to speak single words, and 31% were able to speak in sentences [van de Kamp et al 2013a].
A neuropsychological profile in four affected boys from two unrelated families from the Netherlands revealed a semantic-pragmatic language disorder (difficulty in understanding the meaning of words) with oral dyspraxia [Mancini et al 2005].
Seizures were present in 59% of affected male individuals. The most common seizure types were generalized tonic-clonic and simple or complex partial seizures with or without secondary generalization. Absence and myoclonic seizures were rare. Seizure onset was between ages one and 21 years [van de Kamp et al 2013b]. Intractable epilepsy has been reported in fewer than ten individuals [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2010, van de Kamp et al 2013a].
Movement disorder. Wide-based gait or ataxia and dystonia or athetosis were reported in 29% and 11% of affected males, respectively [van de Kamp et al 2013a].
Behavior disorder. Behavior disorder was reported in 85% of affected males. The most common behavior disorders were attention deficit and/or hyperactivity (55%) and autistic features (41%). Other behavior disorders reported in affected males include social anxiety or shyness (20%), stereotypic behavior (20%), impulsive behavior (27%), aggressive behavior (19%), self-injurious behavior (10%), and obsessive-compulsive behavior (8%) [van de Kamp et al 2013a].
Other neurologic clinical features. Hypotonia was present in 40% of affected males. Spasticity was reported in 26% of affected males. Four individuals had mild (sensorineural) hearing loss. Nine affected males were reported with strabismus or bilateral abducens nerve palsy. Myopathic face, ptosis, joint laxity (likely secondary to the hypotonia), and decreased muscle bulk were also reported [van de Kamp et al 2013a].
Other non-neurologic clinical features
Dysmorphic features including microcephaly, broad forehead, midface retrusion, high palate, short nose, prominent nasal bridge, ear differences (underfolded helices, large ears, and/or cupped ears), deeply set eyes, fifth finger clinodactyly, and slender body build were reported in 45% of affected males [
van de Kamp et al 2013a,
van de Kamp et al 2013b].
Gastrointestinal
findings, including poor weight gain, vomiting, constipation, ileus (likely secondary to constipation), hepatitis, gastric and duodenal ulcers, and hiatal hernia (which may or may not be related to CRTR deficiency) were reported in 35% of affected males [
van de Kamp et al 2013a].
Cardiac features. One affected male had long QT disorder [
van de Kamp et al 2013a]. Seven males with CRTR deficiency (39%) had prolonged QTc on EKG. These individuals also showed increased left ventricular internal dimension (diastole) and diminished left ventricular posterior wall dimension (diastole) in echocardiography [
Levin et al 2021].
Medical concerns in adulthood. Twenty-one of 101 affected males were adults (age >18 years). They presented with myopathic face, ptosis, external ophthalmoplegia, or parkinsonism. Chronic constipation leading to megacolon, ileus, or bowel perforation and/or gastric or duodenal ulcer disease have been reported in some adults [
van de Kamp et al 2013a].
CRTR Deficiency ‒ Heterozygous Females
Females heterozygous for their family-specific SLC6A8 pathogenic variant are typically either asymptomatic or have mild ID [van de Kamp et al 2011]. There was no clinical correlation between skewed X-chromosome inactivation in favor of the pathogenic variant allele and severity of clinical phenotype. There was no significant statistical correlation between intellectual ability and cerebral creatine level on brain 1H-MRS [van de Kamp et al 2011]. A female with mild ID, intractable epilepsy, and behavior problems (a phenotype similar to affected males) did not have evidence of skewed X-chromosome inactivation in peripheral blood cells; tissue-specific skewed X-chromosome inactivation in the brain could explain her severe neurologic findings [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2010].
Prevalence
GAMT deficiency. About 130 individuals with GAMT deficiency have been diagnosed worldwide.
The estimated incidence of GAMT deficiency in the general population ranges from 1:2,640,000 to 1:250,000 [Desroches et al 2015, Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2016]. This is in agreement with information from pilot newborn screening programs for GAMT deficiency, which screened more than 1,500,000 newborns; to date two of the newborns have a confirmed diagnosis of GAMT deficiency [Mercimek-Mahmutoglu et al 2012, Pasquali et al 2014, Pitt et al 2014, Stockler-Ipsiroglu et al 2014, Sinclair et al 2016, Hart et al 2021].
The estimated incidence of GAMT deficiency in the Utah and New York newborn population was 1:405,655 [Hart et al 2021].
Smaller studies of individuals with neurologic disease or severe intellectual disability found GAMT deficiency present in 1.1% [Cheillan et al 2012].
AGAT deficiency. The estimated carrier frequency of AGAT deficiency was one in 1,292 (0.077%; CI=0.06%-0.10%) in the general population using the ExAC Browser Beta database [DesRoches et al 2016].
CRTR deficiency. CRTR deficiency has been studied in many cohorts ranging from 49 to 4,426 individuals with familial or nonfamilial ID. These studies were summarized by van de Kamp et al [2014]; the prevalence in males with ID was estimated between 0.4% and 1.4%. In a recent study, the prevalence of creatine transporter deficiency was 2.64% in individuals with neurodevelopmental disorders [Bahl et al 2020].