Clinical Description
Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (AATD) can present with hepatic dysfunction in individuals from infancy to adulthood and with obstructive lung disease and/or bronchiectasis, characteristically in individuals older than age 30 years. Phenotypic expression varies within and between families.
The severity of AATD depends on the genotype and resultant serum alpha-1 antitrypsin (AAT) level. Individuals homozygous for severe deficiency alleles (i.e., PI*ZZ) have low serum AAT levels, placing them at increased risk for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) (see Table 4). Individuals with alleles associated with intrahepatic inclusions (e.g., Z, Mmalton, Siiyama) are also at increased risk of developing liver disease.
Under-recognition of AATD often causes a long delay between first symptoms and initial diagnosis of AATD (i.e., 5-7 years) and many individuals report seeing multiple physicians before the diagnosis is first established. Diagnostic delay is associated with worsened clinical status at the time of initial diagnosis [Tejwani et al 2019].
To date, approximately 5,000-10,000 individuals in the United States have been identified with a pathogenic variant in SERPINA1 [American Thoracic Society & European Respiratory Society 2003, Strnad et al 2020]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports.
Table 3.
View in own window
Feature | % of Persons w/Feature | Comment |
---|
COPD (emphysema, chronic bronchitis) | 60%-80% | The pattern & distribution of emphysema should not dissuade from considering the diagnosis of AATD. |
Bronchiectasis | ~27% | Bronchiectasis is present on CT chest in ~90% of those w/PI*ZZ & clinically evident in ~27% [Parr et al 2007]. |
Neonatal cholestasis | ~11% | ~65% will go on to have severe liver disease. |
Cirrhosis | 12%-40% | Liver disease may be subclinical. |
Panniculitis | Uncommon | May be present in AATD phenotypes not assoc w/lung disease |
GPA | Uncommon but associated | Odds ratio for having an abnormal AAT gene is ~11 in persons w/GPA [Mahr et al 2010]. |
AAT = alpha-1 antitrypsin; AATD = alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency; COPD = chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; GPA = granulomatosis with polyangiitis
Lung Disease
Adult-onset lung disease. Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), specifically emphysema and/or chronic bronchitis, is the most common clinical manifestation of AATD. Bronchiectasis is also associated with AATD.
In adults, smoking is the major factor in accelerating the development of COPD. Although the natural history of AATD varies, depending in part on what has brought the individual to medical attention (e.g., lung symptoms, liver symptoms, asymptomatic relative of an affected individual), the onset of respiratory disease in smokers with AATD is characteristically between ages 40 and 50 years [Tanash et al 2008]. Nonsmokers may have a normal life span, but can also develop lung and/or liver disease.
Individuals with severe AATD may manifest the usual signs and symptoms of obstructive lung disease, asthma, and chronic bronchitis (e.g., dyspnea, cough, wheezing, and sputum production) [McElvaney et al 1997]. For example, in the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Registry, of 1,129 participants with severe deficiency of AAT, 84% described dyspnea, 76% wheezed with an upper respiratory tract infection, and 50% reported cough and phlegm [McElvaney et al 1997, Eden et al 2003]. Of note, the prevalence of AATD in persons with asthma does not differ from that found in the general population [Wencker et al 2002, Miravitlles et al 2003].
Most individuals (~95%) with severe AATD have evidence of bronchiectasis on chest CT, with 27% demonstrating clinical symptoms of bronchiectasis [Parr et al 2007].
Chest CT shows loss of lung parenchyma and hyperlucency. In contrast to the usual pattern observed in centriacinar emphysema (emphysematous changes more pronounced in the lung apices than bases), the pattern observed in two thirds of individuals with AATD is that of more pronounced emphysematous changes in the bases than apices [
Parr et al 2004].
Lung function tests show decreased expiratory airflow, increased lung volumes, and decreased diffusing capacity. Approximately 60% of individuals with AATD-associated emphysema demonstrate a component of reversible airflow obstruction, defined as a 200-mL and 12% increase in the post-bronchodilator FEV1 and/or FVC.
Childhood-onset lung disease. Although reported, emphysema in children with AATD is extremely rare and may result from the coexistence of other unidentified genetic factors affecting the lung [Cox & Talamo 1979].
Studies that followed newborns with severe AAT deficiency through age 32 years showed that most adults did not smoke and lacked physiologic and CT evidence of emphysema [Mostafavi et al 2018]. Longer-term follow-up studies are not currently available. In most observational studies, the mean age of individuals with lung disease is in the fifth decade [Seersholm et al 1997, Alpha-1 Antitrypsin Deficiency Registry Study Group 1998].
Risk for lung disease in PI*MZ heterozygotes. Approximately 2%-3% of North Americans are PI*MZ heterozygotes. Nonsmoking PI*MZ heterozygotes are generally not considered to be at significantly increased risk for clinical emphysema [Molloy et al 2014]. Specifically, population-based studies show no significant spirometric differences between matched PI*MZ and PI*MM cohorts [Al Ashry & Strange 2017]. However, smoking PI*MZ heterozygotes are at increased risk for COPD [Hersh et al 2004, Sørheim et al 2010, Molloy et al 2014]. Of note, slight abnormalities of lung function can be present without clinical symptoms. Alternatively, spirometry can miss at least 10% of individuals with a clinical diagnosis of COPD and emphysema on CT scan [Smith et al 2014, Lutchmedial et al 2015].
Risk for lung disease in persons with the PI*SZ genotype. Individuals who smoke and have the PI*SZ genotype with serum AAT levels below the protective threshold value have a slightly increased disease risk.
Table 4.
Relationship of AAT Protein Variants to Serum AAT Levels and Emphysema Risk in Adults
View in own window
AAT Protein Variant | Prevalence (%) | Serum AAT Levels | Lifetime Emphysema Risk |
---|
World-wide | NA | Europe | "True level" 1 mean (5th %ile-95th %ile) | Commercial standard 2 median (5th %ile-95th %ile) |
---|
MM
| 96.3 | 93.0 | 91.1 | 33 (20-53) | 147 (102-254) | Background |
MS
| 2.7 | 4.8 | 6.6 | 33 (18-52) | 125 (86-218) | Background |
MZ
| 0.8 | 2.1-3 | 1.9 | 25.4 (15-42) | 90 (62-151) | Background |
SS
| 0.08 | 0.1 | 0.3 | 28 (20-48) | 95 (43-154) | Background |
SZ
| 0.02 | 0.1 | 0.1 | 16.5 (10-23) | 62 (33-108) | 20%-50% |
ZZ
| 0.003 | 0.01 | 0.01 | 5.3 (3.4-7) | ≤29 (≤29-52) | 80%-100% |
Null-Null
| - | - | - | 0 | 0 | 100% |
AAT = alpha-1 antitrypsin; NA = North America
- 1.
- 2.
Note: An attempt to correlate serum AAT levels with protein variants in children showed trends similar to those seen in adults [Donato et al 2012].
Liver Disease
Childhood-onset liver disease. The most common manifestation of AATD-associated liver disease is neonatal cholestasis: jaundice, with hyperbilirubinemia and raised serum aminotransferase levels in the early days and months of life.
Liver abnormalities develop in only a portion of children with AATD. In a study of 200,000 Swedish children who were followed up after newborn screening for AATD, 18% of those with the PI*ZZ genotype developed clinically recognized liver abnormalities and 2.4% developed liver cirrhosis with death in childhood [Sveger 1976, Sveger 1988, Strnad et al 2020]. Liver damage may progress slowly [Volpert et al 2000].
In a follow-up study of 44 children with AATD-associated liver disease initially manifesting as cirrhosis or portal hypertension, outcomes ranged from liver transplantation in two to relatively healthy lives up to 23 years after diagnosis in seven [Migliazza et al 2000].
It is not known why only a small proportion of children with early hyperbilirubinemia have continued liver destruction leading to cirrhosis. The overall risk that an individual with the PI*ZZ genotype will develop severe liver disease in childhood is generally low (~2%); the risk is higher among sibs of a child with the PI*ZZ genotype and liver disease.
The PI*MZ and PI*SZ genotypes are not associated with an increased risk for childhood liver disease; however, on occasion, elevated levels of liver enzymes that resolve have been observed. In a study of 58 children with heterozygous genotypes showing signs of liver involvement during the first six months of life, almost all had normal values of liver enzymes at ages 12 months, five years, and ten years [Pittschieler 2002].
Adult-onset liver disease. Liver disease in adults (manifesting as cirrhosis and fibrosis) may occur in the absence of a history of neonatal or childhood liver disease. Liver disease is more common in men than women.
The risk for liver disease at age 20-40 years is approximately 2% and at age 41-50 years approximately 4% [Cox & Smyth 1983].
Autopsy studies suggest that the prevalence of liver disease may be as high as 40% in older individuals who have never smoked and do not have COPD [Eriksson 1987]. Liver disease was subclinical at death in some of these individuals.
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). The risk for HCC among individuals with AATD and the PI*ZZ genotype is several times that typically associated with liver cirrhosis. This increased risk has been attributed to failure of apoptosis of injured cells with retained Z protein, which sends a chronic regeneration signal to hepatocytes with a lesser load of retained Z protein [Perlmutter 2006].
Liver pathology. AATD liver inclusions are visualized as bright pink globules of various sizes, using periodic acid-Schiff (PAS) stain following diastase treatment (PAS-D). The extent of inclusion formation varies considerably; the number and size of liver inclusions increases with age. Inclusions are not observed before age 12 weeks. Note: Liver biopsy, when indicated in the evaluation of individuals with liver disease, may show PAS positive diastase-resistant inclusion bodies which are suggestive of but not pathognomonic for AATD.
In infants with AATD, inclusions may be fine and granular and difficult to identify in percutaneous liver biopsy specimens. They are also observed in bile duct epithelium [Cutz & Cox 1979].
Liver inclusions indicate the presence of at least one PI*Z allele; histologic examination of the liver cannot confidently distinguish between PI*MZ heterozygotes and PI*ZZ homozygotes, although inclusions are generally more profuse in PI*ZZ homozygotes. Visualization of inclusions may be variable among PI*MZ heterozygotes.
Other Disease Associations
Panniculitis occurs in an estimated one in 1,000 individuals with AATD [Alpha-1 Antitrypsin Deficiency Registry Study Group 1998]. Panniculitis characteristically presents as migratory, inflammatory, tender skin nodules which may ulcerate [Stoller & Piliang 2008]. Sites of trauma (e.g., legs, lower abdomen) are most commonly affected. Presumably like emphysema in the lung, panniculitis in the skin is caused by unopposed proteolytic damage produced by the PI*Z allele.
Individuals with AATD appear to have increased susceptibility to C-ANCA-positive vasculitis (e.g., granulomatosis with polyangiitis [GPA], previously called Wegener granulomatosis) [Hadzik-Blaszczyk et al 2018].
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
The risk for lung disease associated with the following SERPINA1 genotypes is summarized in Table 4.
PI*MM. This genotype is associated with a normal serum concentration of AAT and no increased risk of liver or lung disease.
PI*MZ. In general, nonsmoking individuals with this genotype are not considered to be at increased risk for lung disease; PI*MZ smokers and those with environmental exposures have increased risk of developing COPD [Molloy et al 2014, Al Ashry & Strange 2017].
PI*SS. This genotype does not appear to be associated with an increased risk for clinical disease [Ferrarotti et al 2012]. The S allele is most common among individuals of Iberian descent.
PI*SZ. This genotype is not usually associated with a high risk for liver or lung disease; however, about 11% of individuals with the PI*SZ genotype have serum AAT levels below the protective threshold value (11 μM). Those individuals are at increased risk of developing emphysema with lower zone predominance, as well as chronic bronchitis, especially if they are smokers [Green et al 2015].
PI*ZZ. Individuals with this genotype have a serum concentration of AAT that is approximately 10%-20% of normal (serum levels of 20-35 mg/dL) and are at high risk for both liver and lung disease. This genotype is present in 95% of affected individuals with clinical manifestations of AATD. Variable disease expressivity in individuals with the PI*ZZ genotype – not accounted for by the presence of known risk factors such as cigarette smoking – suggests the existence of other as-yet unidentified genetic disease modifiers.
PI*FF. While rare, the F allele is associated with AAT that is functionally impaired in binding neutrophil elastase but is quantitatively normal. Individuals with the PI*FF or PI*FZ genotype are deemed to be at increased risk of developing emphysema [Sinden et al 2014].
PI*null-null (sometimes designated PI*QO). Individuals with this genotype have no measurable serum AAT secondary to complete lack of synthesis of AAT. Because protein does not accumulate in the liver, these individuals are not at increased risk of developing liver disease; however, they are at high risk of developing lung disease.