Clinical Description
SALL1-related Townes-Brocks syndrome (SALL1-TBS) is characterized by the triad of imperforate anus or anal stenosis, dysplastic ears (frequently associated with hearing impairment), and thumb malformations without hypoplasia of the radius. Impairment of kidney function may occur with or without structural abnormalities. Foot malformations, genitourinary malformations, and congenital heart disease are common. Of 165 affected individuals from 101 families with a SALL1 pathogenic variant, approximately 80% had the three major features or two major plus minor features, whereas 20% had a partial clinical expression [Kohlhase et al 1998, Kohlhase et al 1999, Marlin et al 1999, Kohlhase et al 2003, Borozdin et al 2006, Botzenhart et al 2007, and 30 additional reports]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports. Some features may be underestimated due to later onset (e.g., impaired kidney function) or incomplete physical examination.
Gastrointestinal manifestations include imperforate anus, anal stenosis, anteriorly placed anus, chronic constipation, and gastroesophageal reflux [Engels et al 2000].
Ear anomalies and hearing loss. Dysplastic ears are common, including overfolded superior helices, preauricular tags, and microtia. Congenital sensorineural and/or conductive hearing loss ranges from mild to severe. Hearing loss that is mild can worsen with age [Yan et al 2024].
Thumb malformations include preaxial polydactyly, triphalangeal thumbs, and, rarely, hypoplastic thumbs without hypoplasia of the radius.
Lower extremity findings include flat feet, clubfoot, overlapping toes (second and fourth toes overlapping third toe), syndactyly of the toes, and missing toes (typically third toe) [Surka et al 2001].
Kidney manifestations include mild malrotation, ectopia, or horseshoe kidney, renal agenesis, renal hypoplasia, polycystic kidneys, and vesicoureteral reflux. Functional impairment with or without structural abnormalities is also frequent [Botzenhart et al 2007, Stein et al 2024].
Genitourinary manifestations include hypospadias, vaginal aplasia with bifid uterus, bifid scrotum, and cryptorchidism [Botzenhart et al 2005, Botzenhart et al 2007].
Congenital heart disease is reported in 50% of persons with the common p.Arg276Ter pathogenic variant [Kohlhase et al 2003] and approximately 15% of all persons with SALL1 pathogenic variants [Surka et al 2001, Botzenhart et al 2005, Botzenhart et al 2007]. Defects include atrial septal defect, ventricular septal defect, tetralogy of Fallot, lethal truncus arteriosus, pulmonary valve atresia, and persistent ductus arteriosus.
Developmental delay and learning difficulties are reported in approximately 15% of individuals, but adults do not usually have intellectual disability. If they do, it is mild.
Behavioral problems are observed in some children with SALL1-TBS, especially attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.
Postnatal growth deficiency. This poorly documented feature has been described in fewer than 6% to 29% of persons reported with TBS in the literature [Surka et al 2001]. The occurrence of postnatal growth deficiency among individuals with a confirmed SALL1 pathogenic variant is not known. Growth hormone deficiency was reported in one individual with TBS [Lawrence et al 2013], suggesting this may be the cause for growth deficiency in other individuals with TBS. Growth deficiency may be secondary to chronic kidney insufficiency in some children with SALL1-TBS.
Other skeletal manifestations include rib anomalies (fused ribs, missing ribs, additional cervical ribs) and mild vertebral anomalies reported in 9% of individuals. Painful joints have been observed in several adults with SALL1-TBS [J Kohlhase, unpublished observations].
Ocular manifestations include Duane anomaly, iris coloboma, lamellar cataract, chorioretinal coloboma with loss of vision, and, rarely, microphthalmia [Valikodath et al 2020].
Central nervous system manifestations in individuals with SALL1-TBS include Chiari I malformation [J Kohlhase, unpublished observations], cranial nerve palsy (cranial nerves VI and VII), and hypoplasia of the dorsal part of the corpus callosum.
Hemifacial microsomia has been reported [Kohlhase et al 1999, Keegan et al 2001].
Congenital hypothyroidism is a rare feature of SALL1-TBS [Lawrence et al 2013, Yan et al 2024]. Note: Almost 5% of individuals with a rare disorder have been reported to have more than one molecular diagnosis [Posey et al 2017]. It is possible that rare features associated with SALL1-TBS may have an independent molecular cause.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
No genotype-phenotype correlations have been identified for the majority of pathogenic variants, most of which are private.
The most common pathogenic variant, c.826C>T (p.Arg276Ter), is associated with greater frequency (50%) and severity of congenital heart defects than other SALL1 pathogenic variants. Fifteen of 16 individuals with this pathogenic variant showed the characteristic triad of anal, thumb, and ear malformations (94%), indicating that this pathogenic variant is associated with a more severe phenotype.
In general, pathogenic variants within the hot spot region that is toward the 5' end in exon 2 appear to be associated with a more severe outcome than pathogenic variants towards the 3' end in exon 2. In addition, the phenotype associated with deletions of SALL1 appears to be milder than that associated with pathogenic variants in the hot spot region, based on a limited number of individuals (nine individuals from five distinct families) with large deletions involving only SALL1 [Borozdin et al 2006, Miller et al 2012, Stevens & May 2016, Innoceta et al 2023].