Clinical Description
The two phenotypes observed in SLC25A19-related thiamine metabolism dysfunction (SLC25A19 deficiency) are Amish lethal microcephaly and thiamine metabolism dysfunction syndrome 4 (THMD-4).
Amish Lethal Microcephaly
Amish lethal microcephaly is characterized by severe congenital microcephaly, developmental delay, seizures, 2-oxoglutaric aciduria, and often premature death. The phenotype shows little variability [Kelley et al 2002, Siu et al 2010].
Congenital microcephaly has been reported in all affected infants. Head circumference is typically more than two standard deviations (SD) below the mean and occasionally more than six SD below the mean, with an extremely underdeveloped cranial vault as a result of the small brain size. The anterior and posterior fontanels are closed at birth, and ridging from premature sutural fusion may be evident.
Seizures have occurred in some affected infants. Seizures were generalized tonic-clonic and responded well to phenobarbital.
Developmental delay. All individuals have profound developmental delay, and most died before age one year. The single affected individual described by Siu et al [2010] was started on a high-fat diet and thiamine. At age seven years, he had profound developmental delay, severe microcephaly, and was fed via gastrostomy tube.
Craniofacial features. Apart from the small head size and craniofacial distortions caused by profound microcephaly, moderate micrognathia was noted in most individuals, and one infant had a cleft soft palate.
Metabolic disturbances. 2-ketoglutaric acidosis has been demonstrated in a number of Amish infants with this disorder. Mild hepatomegaly has been observed in several affected individuals, usually during acute illnesses associated with metabolic acidosis.
Other neurologic manifestations. Many affected infants have difficulty maintaining body temperature.
Brain and/or spine imaging has not been done in most affected individuals. In those who underwent head imaging, reported findings include corpus callosum dysgenesis, large cisterna magma, and hypoplastic cerebellar vermis. Spine MRI demonstrated closed spinal dysraphism in one individual [Siu et al 2010].
Prognosis. After the first two or three months of life, increasing irritability of unknown cause commonly develops [Kelley et al 2002]. Although no changes in physical or neurologic examination accompany the irritability, the Lancaster Amish children who show increased irritability are more likely to die within 24-48 hours of developing their next viral illness. The average life span of an affected infant is between ages five and six months among the Lancaster Amish; the affected Amish Mennonite child reported by Siu et al [2010] was alive (albeit with severe developmental delay) at age seven years.
Neuropathology. A partial autopsy of an affected infant age four months showed severity of the malformation was more pronounced in the anterior portion of the brain. Frontal lobes are smooth and rudimentary. Increasing convolution and lamination progress occipitotemporally. Regions that were most hypoplastic were most disorganized histologically [Strauss et al 2002]. No pathology on the individual reported by Siu et al [2010] was available.
Thiamine Metabolism Dysfunction Syndrome 4 (THMD-4)
THMD-4 is characterized by febrile illness-associated episodic encephalopathy, progressive polyneuropathy, and bilateral striatal necrosis.
Acute encephalopathic episodes are triggered by febrile illness. All affected individuals reached normal developmental milestones until their first encephalopathic episode. Triggers for these episodes included trauma and vaccination. Most individuals developed episodes between ages 12 months and six years. Acute encephalopathic episodes were characterized by gait difficulties, dysphagia, dysphonia, seizures, lethargy, and encephalopathy including coma.
Lack of or delayed thiamine treatment following the first acute encephalopathic episode was associated with early death or severe neurologic sequalae including dystonia, hypotonia, and developmental delay. Early supplementation with thiamine was associated with a good prognosis, with full recovery in most individuals; a few individuals had residual deficits.
Development. Typically, all individuals reached normal developmental milestones until their first acute encephalopathic episode. Following the episode, individuals developed neurodevelopmental regression, which was reversible if thiamine treatment was started promptly.
Seizures were usually observed during the acute encephalopathic episodes. They were described as focal or generalized.
Metabolic disturbances. Lactic acidosis is reported during acute encephalopathic episodes.
Progressive axonal motor and/or sensory neuropathy. Affected individuals developed recurrent episodes of acute flaccid paralysis following febrile illness. Usually, the onset is between ages one and two years. Nerve conduction studies demonstrated motor/sensory axonal polyneuropathy. Untreated individuals showed flaccid quadriparesis with absent deep tendon reflexes. Early thiamine treatment was associated with full recovery.
Brain MRI examination showed bilateral symmetrical T2 hyperintensity and necrosis in the caudate and putamen in all individuals. Bilateral T2 hyperintensity and necrosis of the thalamus, cerebellum, cortical, and subcortical regions were also reported. Follow-up brain MRI in older individuals showed volume loss and gliosis of the striatum.
Prognosis is largely related to early supplementation of thiamine. Early thiamine treatment was associated with good outcomes; delayed or no treatment with thiamine was associated with early death or neurologic sequalae including dystonia, spasticity, and cognitive delay.
It is unknown whether life span in individuals with THMD-4 is abnormal. One reported individual is alive at age 18 years [Bottega et al 2019], demonstrating that survival into adulthood is possible. Since many adults with disabilities have not undergone advanced genetic testing, it is likely that adults with this condition are underrecognized and underreported.
Prevalence
Amish lethal microcephaly has been found primarily in the Old Order Amish who have ancestors from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. At least 61 affected infants have been born to 33 nuclear families in the past 40 years. In this population, incidence is approximately one in 500 births.
THMD-4 is a rare disorder, with only 16 individuals reported to date.