Table D6cMixed head and neck cancer, comparative study quality items

StudyRec#No. PtsSelect Pro/RetroIncl/Excl ClearRep SelectInitl Grps CompBal by Design (Mtch)BL Chars Clr CompTxs Same Time PerUnbiased AllocOther Txs EqualMaint Comp GrpsOverall Attr <20%Non-diffl Attr <15%Outcomes Val, Rel, =Assessors BlindTxs ClrAdequate F/UAnalysis: Adj for ConfsUSPSTF
1° RT
IMRT vs 3DCRT
Golen, 20071420040RN??N?YRYNANANAYNY?NPoor
Mixed Settings
IMRT vs 3DCRT
Marchal, 2004558087PN??N?Y?????Y?N?NPoor
Chao, 20011047041PN??N?Y??YYYY?Y?Y/?Poor
Gomez, 20081339032RYY?N?N??NANANAYNYmd 71Y/?Poor
Palazzi, 200813850116PY??N?NE????Y?Y?Y/?Poor
Vergeer, 200838540141PYYNNNNENNA??Y?Y?Y/?Poor
Langendijk, 200939950529PYN?N???????Y?Y6Y/NPoor
3DCRT vs 2DRT
Kuhnt, 2005484033PYY?N?Y???YYY?Y?NPoor
Rades, 200813180345RYYYNYY?YNANANAYNY?Y/NPoor
Gomez, 20081339042RYY?N?N??NANANAYNYmd 71Y/?Poor
Palazzi, 200813850137PY??N?NE????Y?Y?Y/?Poor
IMRT vs 2DRT
Sanguineti, 2007174066RYN?N????NANANAYNYmd 17Y/NPoor
Daly, 2007247069RN?YNY??YNANANAYNYmd 25NPoor
Jabbari, 20054480106PN??YYYRiskYNN?Y?N?NPoor
Pacholke, 20054830210RYY?N????NANANAYNN?Y/?Poor
Kent, 20081330040RYN?N????NANANAYNN?NPoor
Gomez, 20081339044RYY?N?N??NANANAYNYmd 71Y/?Poor
Palazzi, 20081385045PY??N?NE????Y?Y?Y/?Poor
van Rij, 200838520162RYY?NNN?NNANANAYNNmd 31Y/?Poor
Caudell, 200939420122RYY?N????NANANAYNYmd 32Y/NPoor
Murphy, 20094043075PYY?N?Y?????Y?N1.4NPoor

From: Appendix D, Comparative Studies: Full Evidence/Data Abstraction Tables

Cover of Comparative Effectiveness and Safety of Radiotherapy Treatments for Head and Neck Cancer
Comparative Effectiveness and Safety of Radiotherapy Treatments for Head and Neck Cancer [Internet].
Comparative Effectiveness Reviews, No. 20.
Samson DJ, Ratko TA, Rothenberg BM, et al.

PubMed Health. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.