Table F40Observational studies of control and systemic outcomes stratified by lumpectomy alone

AuthorProbability or RateLength of FollowupNumber Active
L/breast cancer mortality
Kestin LL, 2000208012031
Lee LA, 20062100.004144496
Vargas C, 20051810.0639654
Meijnen P, 20082110.0329691
Kerlikowske K, 20031660.01 (0.005, 0.018)77.91036
Dimpfl T, 19962180.011 (0.001, 0.149)78.446
Szelei-Stevens KA, 20002240.047 (0.012, 0.168)104.443
Gilleard O, 20082360.009 (0.002, 0.036)53215
L/all cause mortality
Kestin LL, 20002080.41612031
Lee LA, 20062100.11144496
Vargas C, 20051810.2559654
Meijnen P, 20082110.0439691
L/distant metastasis
Lee LA, 20062100.004144496
Vargas C, 20051810.0639654
Meijnen P, 20082110.0439691
Kerlikowske K, 20031660.007 (0.003, 0.014)77.91036
Dimpfl T, 19962180.011 (0.001, 0.149)78.446
Szelei-Stevens KA, 20002240.047 (0.012, 0.168)104.443
Douglas-Jones AG, 20022350.009 (0.001, 0.059)NA115
L/local DCIS or invasive carcinoma recurrence
Rakovitch E, 20072430.28120310
Kestin LL, 20002080.07812031
Adepoju LJ, 20062040.29512092
Omlin A, 20062370.54 (0.33, 0.76)12057
Cutuli B, 20021880.438 (0.3, 0.577)120190
Lee LA, 20062100.31144496
Schouten van der Velden AP, 20062500.16948329
Ringberg A, 20001860.2160121
Wong JS, 20061530.001260158
Takeda A, 20012050.1896066
Vargas C, 20051810.4199654
Meijnen P, 20082110.1569691
Gilleard O, 20082360.1796215
Chan KC, 20011590.186 (0.128, 0.263)47129
Cataliotti L, 19922130.109 (0.046, 0.236)9446
Ciatto S, 19902140.054 (0.014, 0.192)6637
Dimpfl T, 19962180.13 (0.06, 0.261)78.446
Szelei-Stevens KA, 2000, 2240.14 (0.064, 0.278)104.443
Douglas-Jones AG, 20022350.122 (0.073, 0.195)NA115
Ottesen GL, 20002400.321 (0.255, 0.396)120168
Liberman L, 19971840.227 (0.154, 0.321)7597
Warneke J, 19951820.107 (0.035, 0.284)3928
Holland PA, 19982290.103 (0.05, 0.201)3568
Idvall I, 20032320.256 (0.186, 0.341)NA121
Bonnier P, 19991540.119 (0.05, 0.256)5142
Rudloff U, 2009, 2570.279120200
West JG, 20072600.061 (0.026, 0.138)8682
L/true DCIS or invasive carcinoma recurrence
Kestin LL, 20002080.07812031
Ottesen GL, 20002400.304 (0.239, 0.377)120168
L/local DCIS recurrence
Meijnen P, 20082110.0799691
Kerlikowske K, 20031660.108 (0.091, 0.129)77.91036
Chan KC, 20011590.14 (0.09, 0.211)47129
Fish EB, 19981830.193 (0.124, 0.289)6088
Miller NA, 20012030.193 (0.124, 0.289)6088
Kestin LL, 20002080.032 (0.005, 0.196)8431
Lee LA, 20062100.115 (0.09, 0.146)72496
Ciatto S, 19902140.013 (0.001, 0.178)6637
Szelei-Stevens KA, 20002240.047 (0.012, 0.168)104.443
Douglas-Jones AG, 20022350.052 (0.024, 0.111)NA115
Gilleard O, 20082360.037 (0.019, 0.073)53215
Ottesen GL, 20002400.173 (0.123, 0.237)120168
Rakovitch E, 20072430.1 (0.071, 0.139)82.8310
L/true DCIS recurrence
Ottesen GL, 20002400.155 (0.108, 0.218)120168
L/local invasive carcinoma recurrence
Rakovitch E, 20072430.15120310
Kerlikowske K, 20031660.082 (0.066, 0.098)601036
Lee LA, 20062100.12144496
Meijnen P, 20082110.0849691
Gilleard O, 20082360.1396215
Chan KC, 20011590.047 (0.021, 0.1)47129
Fish EB, 19981830.068 (0.031, 0.144)6088
Miller NA, 20012030.068 (0.031, 0.144)6088
Kestin LL, 20002080.032 (0.005, 0.196)8431
Ciatto S, 19902140.054 (0.014, 0.192)6637
Szelei-Stevens KA, 20002240.093 (0.035, 0.223)104.443
Douglas-Jones AG, 20022350.07 (0.035, 0.133)NA115
Ottesen GL, 20002400.149 (0.103, 0.211)120168
L/true invasive carcinoma recurrence
Ottesen GL, 20002400.149 (0.103, 0.211)120168
L/local DCIS or invasive carcinoma recurrence per 100 patient-years at risk
Ciatto S, 19902140.0116637
MacAusland SG, 20072150.086 (0.055, 0.13)55.2222
West JG, 20072600.788682
L/regional invasive carcinoma recurrence
Kerlikowske K, 20031660.018 (0.012, 0.029)77.91036
L/contralateral DCIS or invasive carcinoma
Kestin LL, 20002080.03612031
Adepoju LJ, 20062040.02612092
Meijnen P, 20082110.0459691
Cutuli B, 20021880.07584
Ottesen GL, 20002400.024 (0.009, 0.062)120168
L/contralateral DCIS
Ottesen GL, 20002400.012 (0.003, 0.046)120168
L/contralateral invasive carcinoma
Fish EB, 19981830.057 (0.024, 0.129)6088
Miller NA, 20012030.057 (0.024, 0.129)6088
Ottesen GL, 20002400.012 (0.003, 0.046)120168

From: Appendix F, Evidence Tables

Cover of Diagnosis and Management of Ductal Carcinoma in Situ (DCIS)
Diagnosis and Management of Ductal Carcinoma in Situ (DCIS).
Evidence Reports/Technology Assessments, No. 185.
Virnig BA, Shamliyan T, Tuttle TM, et al.

PubMed Health. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.