Mitral valve repair for degenerative mitral regurgitation with Carpentier's functional classification type II in elderly patients: a single center experience

Objective: Mitral valve (MV) repair for Carpentier functional classification Type II (C-II) mitral regurgitation (MR) is widely accepted because of its efficacy. It is unclear whether MV repair has the same benefits in elderly patients as in younger patients because of their lower life expectancy. Herein, we examined the midterm results of MV repair for C-II mitral regurgitation, especially in patients aged ≧70 years.

Method: A retrospective review was performed on 176 patients who underwent MV repair for C-II mitral regurgitation with a median age of 65 years; 55 (31%) patients were ≧70 years, and 124 were male (71%). Lesions of the mitral valve were isolated from the anterior leaflet (48 patients), posterior leaflet (113 patients), and both leaflets (15 patients), and included seven patients with Barlow's disease. We compared the outcomes between patients aged ≧70 years (≧70 years; median age, 76 years) and those aged < 70 years (median age, 60 years).

Results: In terms of the durability of MV repair in elderly patients, there were no significant differences in the rates of freedom from reoperation or MR recurrence at 5 years between patients aged < 70 years and those aged ≧70 years (reoperation:98% in < 70 years versus 89% in ≧70 years; P = 0.4053; MR recurrence:95% in < 70 years versus 81% in ≧70 years; P = 0.095). The mitral valve complexity was divided into two grades: Simple (isolated posterior mitral lesion) and Complex (isolated anterior lesion or both lesions). In patients aged < 70 years, there was no significant difference in the rate of freedom from MR recurrence at 5 years between the Simple and Complex groups (96% vs. 91%; P = 0.1029). In contrast, in patients aged ≧70 years, the MR recurrence rate at 3 years in Complex was significantly higher in the Complex group than in the Simple (100% vs. 80%; P = 0.0265).

Conclusions: We studied the outcomes of MV repair for C-II in MR. In elderly patients, MR recurrence was higher in complex lesions than in simple lesions. MV replacement may be considered for elderly patients with complex mitral valve lesions, if appropriately selected.