Force-Correction Analysis Method for Derivation of Multidimensional Free-Energy Landscapes from Adaptively Biased Replica Simulations

J Chem Theory Comput. 2021 Nov 9;17(11):6775-6788. doi: 10.1021/acs.jctc.1c00586. Epub 2021 Oct 20.

Abstract

A methodology is proposed for the calculation of multidimensional free-energy landscapes of molecular systems, based on analysis of multiple molecular dynamics trajectories wherein adaptive biases have been applied to enhance the sampling of different collective variables. In this approach, which we refer to as the Force-Correction Analysis Method (FCAM), local averages of the total and biasing forces are evaluated post hoc, and the latter are subtracted from the former to obtain unbiased estimates of the mean force across collective-variable space. Multidimensional free-energy surfaces and minimum free-energy pathways are then derived by integrating the mean-force landscape with a kinetic Monte Carlo algorithm. To evaluate the proposed method, a series of numerical tests and comparisons with existing approaches were carried out for small molecules, peptides, and proteins, based on all-atom trajectories generated with standard, concurrent, and replica-exchange metadynamics in collective-variable spaces ranging from one to six dimensional. The tests confirm the correctness of the FCAM formulation and demonstrate that calculated mean forces and free energies converge rapidly and accurately, outperforming other methods used to unbias this kind of simulation data.