We report the discovery of a novel indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase-1 (IDO1) inhibitor class through the affinity selection of a previously unreported indole-based DNA-encoded library (DEL). The DEL exemplar, spiro-chromane 1, had moderate IDO1 potency but high in vivo clearance. Series optimization quickly afforded a potent, low in vivo clearance lead 11. Although amorphous 11 was highly bio-available, crystalline 11 was poorly soluble and suffered disappointingly low bio-availability because of solubility-limited absorption. A prodrug approach was deployed and proved effective in discovering the highly bio-available phosphonooxymethyl 31, which rapidly converted to 11 in vivo. Obtaining crystalline 31 proved problematic, however; thus salt screening was performed in an attempt to circumvent this obstacle and successfully delivered greatly soluble and bio-available crystalline tris-salt 32. IDO1 inhibitor 32 is characterized by a low calculated human dose, best-in-class potential, and an unusual inhibition mode by binding the IDO1 heme-free (apo) form.