Implementation of thyroid function tests algorithms by clinical laboratories: A four-year experience of good clinical and diagnostic practice in a tertiary hospital in Greece

Introduction: Thyroid Function Tests (TFTs) are among the most commontly ordered tests. Significant overuse of TFTs can occur when instead of using a single TSH test to screen for thyroid disease a full panel (TSH plus FT4 and FT3) is ordered. The aim of our study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the application of a scientifically-established laboratory-controlled algorithm for TFTs to physician's orders for inpatients and to address potential pitfalls of such an approach.

Materials and methods: We collected and analyzed Laboratory Information System data of the TFTs performed between April 2009 and March 2016 in a 739-bed tertiary teaching hospital. Between April 2013 and March 2016, we applied a laboratory controlled algorithm for inpatient TFT assays after TSH and did not perform further tests, unless a justified bypass was requested by the treating physician.

Results: Algorithm application led to significant reductions of TFTs executed per TSH ordered. Compared to the four years preceding the intervention, executed FT4/TSH tests decreased from 93 to 18%, FT3/TSH from 92 to 18%, anti-TG/TSH from 18 to 4% and anti-TPO/TSH from 11 to 3%. Simultaneously, FT4, FT3, anti-TG, and anti-TPO tests ordered in outpatients also displayed a significant gradual decrease.

Conclusions: Hospital-based laboratories can safely apply a generally accepted TFTs algorithm on physician's orders without any compromise in diagnostic/therapeutic accuracy, thus achieving significant direct cost-reduction and increased physician awareness on current TFT ordering practices. Such an approach, combined with collaboration with ordering physicians, can safeguard patients from the consequences of low-value care practices.