Validation of a Full-Immersion Simulation Platform for Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy Using Three-Dimensional Printing Technology

J Endourol. 2017 Dec;31(12):1314-1320. doi: 10.1089/end.2017.0366.

Abstract

Introduction and objectives: The restriction of resident hours with an increasing focus on patient safety and a reduced caseload has impacted surgical training. A complex and complication prone procedure such as percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) with a steep learning curve may create an unsafe environment for hands-on resident training. In this study, we validate a high fidelity, inanimate PCNL model within a full-immersion simulation environment.

Methods: Anatomically correct models of the human pelvicaliceal system, kidney, and relevant adjacent structures were created using polyvinyl alcohol hydrogels and three-dimensional-printed injection molds. All steps of a PCNL were simulated including percutaneous renal access, nephroscopy, and lithotripsy. Five experts (>100 caseload) and 10 novices (<20 caseload) from both urology (full procedure) and interventional radiology (access only) departments completed the simulation. Face and content validity were calculated using model ratings for similarity to the real procedure and usefulness as a training tool. Differences in performance among groups with various levels of experience using clinically relevant procedural metrics were used to calculate construct validity.

Results: The model was determined to have an excellent face and content validity with an average score of 4.5/5.0 and 4.6/5.0, respectively. There were significant differences between novice and expert operative metrics including mean fluoroscopy time, the number of percutaneous access attempts, and number of times the needle was repositioned. Experts achieved better stone clearance with fewer procedural complications.

Conclusions: We demonstrated the face, content, and construct validity of an inanimate, full task trainer for PCNL. Construct validity between experts and novices was demonstrated using incorporated procedural metrics, which permitted the accurate assessment of performance. While hands-on training under supervision remains an integral part of any residency, this full-immersion simulation provides a comprehensive tool for surgical skills development and evaluation before hands-on exposure.

Keywords: 3D printing; high fidelity; percutaneous nephrolithotomy; simulation; surgical education; validity.

Publication types

  • Validation Study

MeSH terms

  • Clinical Competence
  • Computer Simulation
  • Endoscopy / education
  • Endoscopy / methods
  • Fluoroscopy
  • Humans
  • Internship and Residency
  • Kidney
  • Kidney Calculi / therapy*
  • Lithotripsy / methods*
  • Models, Anatomic
  • Nephrolithotomy, Percutaneous / education*
  • Nephrolithotomy, Percutaneous / methods
  • Printing, Three-Dimensional*
  • Radiology, Interventional / education*
  • Reproducibility of Results
  • Simulation Training*
  • Staghorn Calculi / therapy
  • Urology / education*