During chronic viral infections, responses by virus-specific CD8(+) T cells become marginalized by the acquisition of functional defects and reduced cell numbers in a process defined as T cell exhaustion. Similarly, T cell tolerance to self-antigen is also characterized by impaired effector function and eventual deletion of self-reactive T cells. Induction of both tolerance and exhaustion involve many shared inhibitory mechanisms, thus similar therapeutic approaches have proven effective in these distinct environments. We previously demonstrated that tolerant self-reactive CD8(+) T cells expressing dual-T cell receptors (i.e., dual-TCR) could be rescued by immunization through a second TCR specific for a foreign antigen. These data revealed that T cell tolerance was regulated at the level of the self-reactive TCR. Here, dual-TCR CD8(+) T cells were used to examine if exhaustion during persistent viral infection could be rescued by an analogous strategy of immunization through a second TCR not involved in recognition of virus. In direct contrast to the rescue achievable in tolerant CD8(+) T cells, exhausted T cells were equally impaired through both TCR. These findings suggest that exhaustion is maintained by defects downstream of the virus-specific TCR, and establish that exhaustion and tolerance are distinctly regulated states of T cell dysfunction.