A 40-year-old man presented with a pigmented lesion of the palpebral conjunctiva and margin of the right lower eyelid. Because of suspicion of melanoma, the lesion was resected. Microscopic examination revealed 2 distinct components: a dominant blue nevus in the tarsus consisting of bland pigmented spindle and epithelioid cells that dissected among the orbicularis muscle fibers and meibomian glands, and a small subepithelial nevomelanocytic component with no overlying junctional activity. The diagnosis of a combined nevus was supported by minimal Ki-67 nuclear immunoreactivity. While the current lesion was proved to be an atypical nevus, all palpebral pigmented lesions should be routinely excised because many are melanomas.