Objectives: Reoperations may reflect a suboptimal initial surgical treatment. The study aimed to develop a screening algorithm for those potentially avoidable, using only routinely collected hospital data and a prediction model to adjust rates for case-mix.
Study design and setting: Data of a 3-year random sample of 7,370 therapeutic operations on inpatients, among which 833 were followed-up by a reoperation during the same stay. A review of medical records identified clearly avoidable and other potentially avoidable reoperations to develop and test the screening algorithm. A logistic prediction model of potentially avoidable reoperations was developed on one randomly chosen half of the data (about 9,000 interventions) and tested on the other half (cross-validation).
Results: Two hundred thirty-seven interventions (3%) were followed by a potentially avoidable reoperation, among which 144 were clearly avoidable. The screening algorithm had a sensitivity of 75% and a specificity of 72%. Predictors of potentially avoidable reoperations were surgery categories, diagnosis related conditions, and experiencing prior surgery. The risk score, based on these variables, showed at once a satisfactory discriminative performance (C-statistic=0.76) and goodness-of-fit measure on the validation set.
Conclusion: The adjusted rate of potentially avoidable reoperations should be included in internal reporting of hospital quality indicators, but further validated in various settings.