We have investigated receptor structural components responsible for ligand-dependent inverse agonism in a constitutively active mutant of the human parathyroid hormone (PTH)/parathyroid hormone-related peptide (PTHrP) receptor type 1 (hP1R). This mutant receptor, hP1R-H223R (hP1R(CAM-HR)), was originally identified in Jansen's chondrodysplasia and is altered in transmembrane domain (TM) 2. We utilized the PTHrP analog, [Bpa(2),Ile(5),Trp(23),Tyr(36)]PTHrP-(1-36)-amide (Bpa(2)-PTHrP-(1-36)), which has valine 2 replaced by p-benzoyl-l-phenylalanine (Bpa); this substitution renders the peptide a photoreactive inverse agonist at hP1R(CAM-HR). This analog cross-linked to hP1R(CAM-HR) at two contiguous receptor regions as follows: the principal cross-link site (site A) was between receptor residues Pro(415)-Met(441), spanning the TM6/extracellular loop three boundary; the second cross-link site (site B) was within the TM4/TM5 region. Within the site A interval, substitution of Met(425) to Leu converted Bpa(2)-PTHrP-(1-36) from an inverse agonist to a weak partial agonist; this conversion was accompanied by a relative shift of cross-linking from site A to site B. The functional effect of the M425L mutation was specific for Bpa(2)-containing analogs, as inverse agonism of Bpa(2)-PTH-(1-34) was similarly eliminated, whereas inverse agonism of [Leu(11),d-Trp(12)]PTHrP-(5-36) was not affected. Overall, our data indicate that interactions between residue 2 of the ligand and the extracellular end of TM6 of the hP1R play an important role in modulating the conversion between active and inactive receptor states.