Disruption of nhaR of E. coli affects biofilm formation. (A) Cultures were grown in microtiter plates in LB (pH 7.4) for 24 h at 26°C, and biofilm formation was assessed by crystal violet staining (see Materials and Methods). Bars depict the results obtained with a series of isogenic strains: 1, MG1655 (wild type); 2, nhaR::cam; 3, nhaR::cam(pKK223-3); 4, nhaR::cam(pNhaR); 5, csrA::kan; 6, csrA::kan nhaR::cam; 7, csrA::kan nhaR::cam(pKK223-3); 8, csrA::kan nhaR::cam(pNhaR). Error bars indicate standard errors of the means. (B) Time course of adherence to coverslips by isogenic E. coli K-12 MG1655 strains (described in Materials and Methods). Representative fields are shown. wt, wild type. (C) Effect of sodium chloride on biofilm formation. Cultures were grown in L broth (LB without NaCl) supplemented with the indicated concentrations of NaCl. Symbols represent the results obtained with a series of isogenic strains: ▪, MG1655 (wild type); ▴, nhaR::cam; ▾, nhaR::cam(pKK223-3); ⧫, nhaR::cam(pNhaR); •, nhaR::cam(pNhaR-His6). Bars represent the averages for two wells, and error bars correspond to the standard errors of the means. (D) Epistasis analyses of nhaR and pgaABCD on biofilm formation. Biofilm formation in the following isogenic strains was assessed as for panel A: 1, MG1655; 2, ΔpgaABCD; 3, nhaR::cam; 4, MG1655(pUC19); 5, MG1655(pPGA372) (contains pgaABCD); 6, nhaR::cam(pUC19); 7, nhaR::cam(pPGA372); 8, ΔpgaABCD(pUC19); 9, ΔpgaABCD(pPGA372); 10, ΔpgaABCD(pKK223-3); 11, ΔpgaABCD(pNhaR). Bars represent the averages for 16 wells normalized to the biofilm formed by MG1655, and error bars correspond to the standard errors of the means. The asterisks denote significant differences relative to the corresponding parent strain (P < 0.001 [Tukey's multiple-comparison test]).