Screening methods for thyroid hormone disruptors.

The U.S. Congress has passed legislation requiring the EPA to implement screening tests for identifying endocrine-disrupting chemicals. A series of workshops was sponsored by the EPA, the Chemical Manufacturers Association, and the World Wildlife Fund; one workshop focused on screens for chemicals that alter thyroid hormone function and homeostasis. Participants at this meeting identified and examined methods to detect alterations in thyroid hormone synthesis, transport, and catabolism. In addition, some methods to detect chemicals that bind to the thyroid hormone receptors acting as either agonists or antagonists were also identified. Screening methods used in mammals as well as other vertebrate classes were examined. There was a general consensus that all known chemicals which interfere with thyroid hormone function and homeostasis act by either inhibiting synthesis, altering serum transport proteins, or by increasing catabolism of thyroid hormones. There are no direct data to support the assertion that certain environmental chemicals bind and activate the thyroid hormone receptors; further research is indicated. In light of this, screening methods should reflect known mechanisms of action. Most methods examined, albeit useful for mechanistic studies, were thought to be too specific and therefore would not be applicable for broad-based screening. Determination of serum thyroid hormone concentrations following chemical exposure in rodents was thought to be a reasonable initial screen. Concurrent histologic evaluation of the thyroid would strengthen this screen. Similar methods in teleosts may be useful as screens, but would require indicators of tissue production of thyroid hormones. The use of tadpole metamorphosis as a screen may also be useful; however, this method requires validation and standardization prior to use as a broad-based screen.

The U.S. Congress has passed. legslation requiing the EPA to implement screening tests for identifying endocrine-disrupting chemicals. A series of workshops w snsored by the EPA, the Chenical Manufacturer Association, and the World Wlddlife Fund; one workshop focused on screens for chemicals that alter thyroid hormone function and homeostsuis. Participants at this meeting identified and exmined methods to detect alterations in thyroid hormone synthesis, tansport, and catabolism. In addition, some methods to detect chemicals that bind to the thyroid hormonie receptors acting as either agonists or antnists were identified. Screening methods used in mammals as well as other verte were a d. e was a g l consensus that all known chemicalswhich interfere with thyroid hormmone fuinction and homeostasis act by either inhibiting synthesis, altering serum transport proteins, or by increasing catabolism of thyroid hormones. There are no direct data to support the assertion that certain environmental chemicals bind and activate the thyroid hormone receptors; firther research is indicated. In light of this, screeig methods should reflect known me ms of action. Most metho e , albeit usu fo mechnstic were thouto b 0e too specific d therefore would not be applicable for broad-based; s Dete a of serum tid hormone concentrations following cheniical exposure n rodents wasthought to be a reasobe initial screen. Concurrent histologic evaluation of the thyroid would strengthen this screen.
Similar methods in teleosts may be useful as screens, but would require indicators of tissue production of thyroid hormones. The use of tadpole metamorphosis as a screen may also be useful; however, this method requires validation and standdization prior to use as a broad-based screen. Key work developm entl toxict, endocrie disruptors, ne ioral txi, screens, thyroid hormone, thyroid hormone receptors. Environ Health Psptect 107:407415 (1999). [Online 8 April 1999] bttp//eIbpnetl.niebs.nib.gov/docs/19991 07p407-415devitolabstract./btl Endocrine disruption has emerged as an environmental issue based on the hypothesis that exposure to certain environmental chemicals alters the endocrine system, and increases the incidence of endocrine diseases and disorders and adversely affects development in both humans and wildlife (1)(2)(3). Although research evaluating this hypothesis is ongoing, there are thousands of synthetic and naturally occurring chemicals that must be considered. The development of screening methodology for endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) would enable researchers to narrow the focus of their research efforts (3). In the United States, screening for EDCs was recently mandated by congressional legislation in the Food Quality Protection Act of 1996 (Public Law and the Safe Drinking Water Act of 1996 (Public   (4). A series of workshops sponsored by the Chemical Manufacturers Association, the EPA, and the World Wildlife Fund focused on the development of screens for endocrine-disrupting chemicals for both humans and wildlife (5,6). The following report is a consensus from the workshop entitled Screening Methods for Chemicals That Alter Thyroid Hormone Action, Function, and Homeostasis, held at Duke University, Durham, North Carolina, 20-23 June 1997.
The workshop focused on more than 20 assays or test systems that have been used to examine chemicals which alter synthesis, storage, transport, and catabolism of thyroxine (T4) and 3,5,3'-triiodothyronine (T3), assays that examine ligand binding and activation of the thyroid hormone receptor, and in vivo assays that examine the effects of antithyroid agents and thyromimetics in mammalian and nonmammalian wildlife models. The workshop focused on chemicals that alter thyroid gland function through pharmacodynamic means and did not include chemicals that were directly cytotoxic to the thyroid gland. The purpose of the workshop was not to recommend a screening battery or to deal with policy issues pertaining to the use of such screens; the product of the workshop was intended to describe and evaluate the methods that are currently available or could be developed in the near future for screening and testing.

Thyroid Function and Regulation
The thyroid gland produces T4 and T3. Thyroid hormones (THs) have two predominant functions. The first is a critical role in growth and development. One of the clearest examples of the importance of THs in growth and development is the metamorphosis of amphibians, in particular the metamorphosis of tadpoles into frogs (7)(8)(9). Other examples of the importance of THs in development are the transformation of salmon from freshwater-dwelling par to seawater-dwelling smolts (10,11), flounder metamorphosis (12), and development of the central nervous system in humans and other mammals (13,14). In (15,16). The second major function of THs is to maintain metabolic homeostasis in mammals (17).
The synthesis and storage of TH predominately occurs in the thyroid gland and the synthesis is regulated by the pituitary hormone, thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH). Most of the TH in the thyroid is present as T4. Although a small proportion of thyroid-localized TH is T3, most T3 comes from the deiodination of T4 by tissue specific deiodinases. The processes involved in the synthesis, storage, release, transport, and metabolism of THs are complex and consist of the following: 1) uptake of iodide ion by the thyroid gland; 2) oxidation of iodide and the iodination of tyrosine residues within thyroglobulin; 3) coupling of iodotyrosine residues to produce iodothyronines; 4) proteolysis of thyroglobulin and release of T4 and T3 into the blood; 5) binding to serum transport proteins; 6) target tissue synthesis of T3 from T4; 7) catabolism of T4 and T3 in peripheral tissues; and 8) catabolism and biliary elimination of THs in the liver. There are many examples of pharmaceutical, environmental, and naturally occurring chemicals that alter one or more of these processes in mammals; they have been reviewed by Hill et al. (18), Atterwill and Aylward (19), , and Gaitan (21).
The actions of thyroid hormones are mediated by their interaction with nuclear thyroid hormone receptors (TR). There are four known isoforms of TR that are derived from two genes-c-erb~A beta (TR betal and beta2 ) and c-erb-A alpha (TR alpha, and alpha2) (22). TR alpha2 does not bind TH.
These receptors are part of the steroid receptor super family (23) and are the cellular homologs of the oncogene c-erb-A. These nuclear receptors share a common structure in that they have a ligand-binding domain in the carboxy-terminal region of the receptor protein and a DNA-binding domain in the amino-terminal region (22.23). The TRs can modulate the expression of thyroid-responsive genes by binding to specific base pair sequences, known as thyroid hormone response elements (TREs) in the regulatory region of these genes. TRs form homodimers and heterodimers with other nuclear receptors such as the retinoid X receptor (RXR). In addition, TRs form complexes with a number of additional modulating and accessory proteins involved in gene transcription. The affinity of TRs is 10-20 times greater for T3 than for T4 (24,25).
There are several sites in the synthesis, transport, and metabolism of THs that can be altered by xenobiotics. In addition, it is possible that xenobiotics can alter TH signaling through the TR either by directly binding to TR or indirectly by altering phosphorylation of TR or through interactions with other accessory proteins. Unlike the estrogen receptors, there is little evidence of environmental chemicals binding the TR. However, the hypothesis that some environmental chemicals may bind to TR, resulting in toxicologic responses, has not been adequately tested. Because of the complexity of TH function and regulation, it is unlikely that a single assay will be available to detect chemicals that act on any or all of these pathways. The utility of a screen depends on its specificity (the response pathognomonic for alterations in thyroid function), sensitiviry (the response of the method to low doses or to weak-acting chemicals), test duration, simplicity, and limitations. A number of assays or experimental systems were evaluated for their potential use as screens to detect chemicals that disrupt thyroid hormone catabolism and signaling. The workshop participants acknowledged that several of these methods could be used as screening tools.

Assays for Thyroid System Disruption in Mammals
Thyroid hormone concentrations and thyroid gland histology. In humans, alterations in thyroid function can be initially diagnosed by either physical examination for enlarged thyroid gland, or by measuring serum hormone concentrations. Serum hormone concentrations are such good indicators of thyroid function in humans that in the United States, newborn infants are required to have blood samples collected for TSH and/or T4 determinations prior to leaving the hospital. The American Thyroid Association has recommended determination of serum TSH and free T4 concentrations (26) as the standard measure of thyroid function. Total T4 was not recommended as a measure because false positives can be caused by conditions and pharmaceutical agents that alter thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG), the main serum-binding protein in humans. Changes in TBG concentrations alter total serum T concentrations, but may not necessarily alter free T4 concentrations. It is thought that free T4 is available to enter the cell and that the concentrations of free T4 are proportional to the tissue concentrations of T3 and T4. The American Thyroid Association considers a diagnosis of primary hypothyroidism confirmed if the patient has decreased free T4 serum concentrations accompanied by increased serum TSH concentrations (26). Hyperthyroidism in humans is confirmed if the patient has increased free T4 serum concentrations accompanied by suppressed serum TSH concentrations (26).
The synthesis of THs is tightly regulated. The THs provide the negative feedback on pituitary release of TSH. Therefore, decreases in serum THs due to inhibition of TH synthesis or transport or induction of catabolism leads to increased TSH release from the pituitary. The increased TSH, along with other growth factors, leads to hypertrophy and hyperplasia of the follicular cells of the thyroid, resulting in an increase in thyroid gland weight with a concomitant increase in synthesis and release of THs. If this compensatory mechanism is adequate, it can result in the normalization of serum T4 and T, concentrations. Early in a chemical exposure, the serum concentration of THs will decrease, but eventually a steady-state is reached. Therefore, when examining chemical effects on serum TH concentrations at later time points in exposures, serum TH conIcentrations may have returned to normal because of these compensatory mechanisms (27,28). When designing experiments to examine the effects on serum THs, we must consider this compensatory mechanism and appropriate temporal relationships must be examined.
Another difficulty in determining seruLma concentrations of THs and TSH is their responsiveness to stress and time of day of sampling. For example, transporting animals from one room to another will increase TSH and T3 by approximately two-fold over a 1-hr period, with initial increases occurring within 5 min (29). Circadian rhythms of THs occur in rats with peak serum concentrations occurring at approximately noon (29). In addition, there is some evidence of alterations in TH concentrations associated with stages of the estrous cycle (29). THs also change with age and increase strikingly in male rats from postnatal day 33 to 50 (29). These and several other confounding factors are reviewed by Dohler et al. (29). The determination of serum concentrations of THs requires careful consideration of these factors, particularly for weakly goitrogenic chemicals. Finally, detecting small changes in serum TSH and TH concentrations can be problematic because of the large interanimal variability, whereas small changes in TSH (20-30%) can have significant impact on thyroid gland function (25,26). Statistically significant changes in TSH can be detected if adequate sample sizes are used.
In humans, free T4 and TSH serum concentrations are the preferred assays to assess thyroid function. In experimental animals, researchers have measured both free and total T4 as well as T and TSH serum concentrations (27,(30)(31)(32). Determination of both free and total THs can provide complementary information that would guide further testing of a chemical. For example, Screening for thyroid hormone disruptors~~~f ree T4 is an indicator of the amount of hormone available for tissue uptake and for fetal transfer. It is T4, not T3, that primarily influences thyroid-dependent neurodevelopment. T4 is the major form of TH that is taken up by the fetal or neonatal central nervous system (33). An area that lacks adequate experimental data is the exact time course of the compensatory mechanism for the different classes of chemicals which alter serum TH concentrations. Time-course data for inducers of uridine diphosphate glucuronyltransferase (UDP-GT) indicate that continued dosing with these chemicals for 7, 14, and 25 days produces alterations in serum TH concentrations (27,30,31,34). Histologic changes in the thyroid or changes in thyroid weight occurred following 14 days of dosing (27,28,30,34). There has been no systematic attempt to determine the time course of the compensatory response to decreases in serum TH concentrations following exposure to different classes of chemicals that alter serum TH concentrations through different mechanisms.
The compensatory increases in TSH result in proliferation of the follicular cells in the thyroid gland. These changes can be detected histologically as increased follicular cell numbers and as increases in thyroid gland weight (28,35). These histologic changes appear less sensitive to confounders described previously and may provide a better assessment of thyroid function than serum hormone concentrations. Similar dose-response relationships among decreases in serum hormone concentrations, histologic changes in the thyroid, and increases in thyroid weight were observed in rats administered sulfamethazine for 4 weeks (27). Furthermore, the use of thyroid weights and histology may allow for screening chemicals previously tested in subchronic studies. Caution is required for studies examined during the 1970s, however, because follicular cell hypertrophy indicative of TSH stimulation was not considered pathologic change and may not have been reported. Caution must be used when using histologic changes as a screen; there are examples of chemicals that decrease THs without altering thyroid histology (30).
Section summary. One possible screen for chemicals that alter thyroid function could be the measurement of serum TH concentrations in experimental animals following treatment with a test compound. Methods for determining serum concentrations ofTHs are readily available from commercial suppliers and these assays have been in use for many years. Using determination of serum TH concentrations in animals following chemical exposure provides assessment of thyroid function equivalent to those used clinically in humans. However, because of potential compensatory mechanisms and the sensitivity of TH and TSH concentrations to stress and other factors, determination of serum TH alone has limitations. Histologic assessment of the thyroid gland should be performed in conjunction with the measurement of serum TH concentrations to provide a more complete assessment of thyroid function and TH action (23,35). Future efforts to determine the most appropriate time point and exposure regimen for examining serum TH concentrations are recommended. Again, caution must be used if thyroid histology alone is used as the marker for chemicals that disrupt THs because there is evidence of chemicals altering THs without altering thyroid histology.
Assays for chemicals that alter synthesis, secretion, transport, and catabolism of thyroid hormones. Changes in serum concentrations of THs can be caused by chemicals that inhibit thyroid hormone synthesis, release, and transport, and by chemicals that increase metabolism of THs. If a chemical decreases serum TH concentrations, specific assays can be used to determine the mechanism by which these hormone concentrations are decreased. These assays may be of value in screening for chemicals that act through specific mechanisms. The assays described examine the synthesis and regulation of serum concentrations of THs.
Peroxidase assay. Thyroid peroxidases (TPOs) are the key enzymes in the synthesis of THs. There are a number of classes of synthetic chemicals that inhibit thyroid peroxidase, e.g., thionamides such as propylthiouracil, aromatic amines such as sulfathiazole, and polyhydric phenols such as resorcinol (18)(19)(20)(21). In addition, there are a number of naturally occurring chemicals that inhibit thyroid peroxidase, such as goitrin, which is found in turnips and other cruciferous vegetables (35), and flavonoids, which are found in other plant products (36). TPOs have two functions: first is the iodination of tyrosine residues on thyroglobulin, and second is the coupling of specific di-and triiodotyrosyl residues on thyroglobulin. The iodination reaction can be readily determined using bovine serum albumin or tyrosine as substrates (36). In addition, the oxidation of guaiacol can be used as an indicator of thyroid peroxidase activity (327). All chemicals that inhibit the iodination reaction also inhibit the coupling reaction (38). The coupling reaction can be assayed using either human low iodine thyroglobulin, preiodinated casein, or guaiacol as substrates.
A  (37). Although TPO can be purified from experimental animals, the size of the gland is extremely small in rodents, and purification of rodent TPO would be impractical as a source of enzymes for a widely used screen. One of the advantages of the TPO assay is that the sensitivity to chemical inhibition of thyroid peroxidase from human and experimental animals can be directly examined. In vitro studies have shown that TPO from monkeys is more resistant to inhibition by propylthiouracil (PTU) and sulfamethazine than is TPO from rodents (359. Comparisons of the relative sensitivity of TPO across species would assist in risk assessment for chemicals that inhibit TPO activity. The iodination and coupling assays are specific for chemicals that inhibit TH synthesis and are unlikely to produce false positives. However, used alone as a screen, these assays have high potential for false negatives, as chemicals that alter TH concentrations through other mechanisms would not be detected. These assays have been performed for many years, are well established in the scientific literature, and numerous chemicals have been tested using these assays. Although there are no published methodologies that can be defined as high through-put screens, modification of this assay into a high through-put screen is under development in several laboratories. Perchlorate discharge test. Perchlorate competes with iodide for thyroid uptake and could also promote the efflux of iodide from the follicular cells (34,40,41). A perchlorate discharge test has been used for decades in both animals and humans to detect iodide organification defects (34,(40)(41)(42)(43). In this assay, animals are exposed to a test chemical and then administered Na125I followed by perchlorate. Accumulation of 1251 in the thyroid is determined before and after administration of perchlorate. Perchlorate promotes the release of iodine that has not been incorporated into thyroglobulin. If a chemical inhibits or deactivates thyroid peroxidase, there would be a brisk decrease in the accumulation of 1251 in the thyroid gland. This assay has the potential for providing mechanistic information on the actions of chemicals that alter thyroid function, but it does not necessarily meet the requirements of a screen. Workshop Summary a Screening for thyroid hormone disruptors this assay measures TSH concentrations before and after challenge with TRH. Challenge with TRH should increase serum concentrations of TSH. A hyperreactive response is observed in the case of hypothyroidism, occurring at the level of the thyroid while a decreased response is observed in hypothyroidism of central origin. This assay has been used both clinically (44) and experimentally (34). The TRH challenge can also help to distinguish between pituitary and hypothalamic causes of hypothyroidism (44). Although the TRH challenge has potential for providing mechanistic information on the actions of chemicals that alter thyroid function, the assay may not be a useful screen because of the limited number of chemicals which may act through this mechanism.
Serum protein-binding assays. In mammalian systems, the serum-binding proteins for THs are thyroid-binding globulin (TBG), transthyretin (TTR), and albumin. TBG and TTR are specific for THs and T4 has a greater affinity for these serum-binding proteins than T3 (25). TBG is present in humans and primates but is not present in rodents. It appears that TBG is responsible for the much longer half-life of T4 and T3 in humans as compared to other species, such as rodents (25). TTR is present in humans, rodents, and nonhuman primates. In humans, TBG is the predominant binding protein, whereas in rodents TTR is the predominant carrier of THs. TTR is also secreted by the choroid plexus and is present in the cerebral spinal fluid, suggesting a role in the transport of T4 into the cerebral spinal fluid and eventually to periventricular areas of the brain (45). In addition, TTR transports T4 into the fetus. There are a number of reports of chemicals that displace T4 from TTR. The research on environmentally relevant chemicals has focused mainly on the polyhalogenated dibenzo-p-dioxins, biphenyls, and diphenylethers (32,33,(46)(47)(48). The displacement of T4 from serum binding proteins is hypothesized to increase the dearance of T4 and decrease serum T4 concentrations. It has also been suggested that TTR binding is predictive of interactions with other TH binding proteins such as the deiodinases and sulfotransferases as well as chemicals with potential for high fetal accumulation (33). These assays have been performed in several laboratories examining xenobiotics for several decades (46,49,50). Although these assays can be modified for high through-put screening they are specific for chemicals that compete with THs for serum binding proteins and will not detect chemicals that act through other mechanisms. In addition, the use of either TBG or TTR may not be relevant for nonmammalian species such as teleosts. However, one of the strengths of this assay is that it may be predictive of chemicals that alter fetal concentrations of TH and may provide for a useful screen in this capacity Deiodinase assays. In mammals, approximately 80% of the T4 secreted by the thyroid gland is deiodinated in target tissues into either T3, the most active form of the THs, or reverse T3 (rT3), an inactive iodothyronine (51). There are several enzymes involved in the deiodination ofT4, T3, and their metabolites, and the expression of these proteins is tissue specific. Type I deiodinase catalyzes the 5'-deiodination of T4, rT3, and the sulfated metabolites ofT4 and T3 (52). Type I deiodinase is sensitive to PTU inhibition and is found in liver, lung, kidney, pituitary, and thyroid (53,54). Type II deiodinase is present in the central nervous system, brown adipose tissue, anterior pituitary, and the placenta (55-5X). Type II deiodinase is insensitive to PTU. In the brain, type II deiodinase converts T4 into T3 and ensures adequate brain concentrations ofT3 during critical periods of development (57,58) and during hypothyroidism (59). Type III deiodinase is resistant to PTU and catalyzes the conversion of T3 and T4 into 3,3'-diiodothyronine and rT3, respectively, in brain, skin, placenta, and fetal tissues (60-6).
The deiodinase enzymes are critical in regulation of serum and tissue concentrations of THs. Decreases in serum concentrations of T4 alter expression of the tissue deiodinases. For example, prenatal exposure to Aroclor 1254 increases brain type II deiodinase in rats with decreased serum T4 (63). There are also tissue-specific and isoform-specific changes in deiodinases following thyroidectomy and T4 and T3 replacement in rats (59). Deiodinase assays have been used for decades to understand the metabolism of THs. Because the activity of these enzymes is dependent on the serum concentrations of these hormones, these assays would be sensitive toward chemicals that alter serum TH concentrations. However, alterations in deiodinase activity also alter serum TH concentrations. The relationship between serum TH concentrations and deiodinase activity may decrease the usefulness of this assay as a screen. If serum TH concentrations are changed by deiodinase inhibitors, it may be easier to measure serum TH concentrations than it is to determine deiodinase activity. Similar to many of the assays described above, these assays have greater utility in understanding the mechanism of action of a chemical rather than as an initial screen.
Glucuronidation assays. Glucuronidation followed by biliary elimination of T4 is one of the major pathways of deactivation of T4. In humans there is evidence of sulfation of T4 as well. In mammals, there are at least three isoforms of UDP-GT that glucuronidate T4 (64). Several classes of chemicals induce UDP-GTs responsible for the glucuronidation of T4 (17,23,31,32). Induction of T4 glucuronidation increases clearance and decreases serum concentrations of T4. Induction of T4 glucuronidation is typically determined in hepatic microsomes from animals treated with test chemicals. These assays have been performed for decades in numerous laboratories throughout the world. These ex vivo assays require several days of dosing of the test chemical. The advantage of this type of assay is that it is responsive to metabolic activation of the test chemical because exposure occurs in vivo. The activity of hepatic microsomal T4 glucuronidation is not as sensitive to stress and circadian rhythms as is measurements of serum TH concentrations. The disadvantage is that these assays are not developed for use as high through-put screening tests and at present are laborious. Additionally, although these assays provide data useful in understanding the mechanisms of action, not all chemicals that effect the thyroid produce alterations in T4 glucuronidation. Section summary. The assays described in this section are specific for particular mechanisms of action. A combination of these assays could provide predictive information on the availability of intracellular T concentrations, particularly in the fetus. This information could be useful in assessing the potential adverse effects of chemicals that disrupt TH homeostasis and tissue concentrations. These assays have been used to understand the mechanism of chemically induced alterations in serum concentrations of TH and TSH or changes in thyroid histopathology (17,23,32,50,65). If these assays were to be used as initial screens, all of them would have to be performed to demonstrate that a chemical does not alter TH concentrations.
Thyroid hormone receptor binding and activation. Chemicals can alter thyroid hormone action by binding to TR. There are several isoforms of the receptors that have tissue specific localization (19). The structure-activity relationships for binding to the nuclear thyroid hormone receptor have been determined using crude nuclear homogenates (20,21) as well as various TR isoforms expressed in Escherichia coli or translated in vitro (66,69). These binding studies have focused on T3 analogs and not on environmentally relevant chemicals (24,25,(66)(67)(68)(69) (47,48). However, this hypothesis has not been adequately tested. At present there is a lack of evidence that environmentally relevant chemicals bind to TRs, which should not be confused with the presence of negative evidence. It should be noted that the chemicals that have been proposed to bind to TRs also decrease serum TH concentrations in experimental animals and are known thyroid hormone disruptors (30,31,70).
In vitro binding assays. In vitro binding assays can be used as potential screens for chemicals that bind to TRs. The classical binding assays have used nuclear extracts from a variety of tissues and cell lines expressing TRs (66). More recent studies have used various TR isoforms expressed in E. coli or translated in vitro (661-69. These assays require separating bound from free hormones using either filtering or chromatographic methods. Either separation method is cumbersome and time consuming. More recent advances have used solidstate binding assays using specific isoforms of TRs. The solid-state binding assays developed allow for high through-put screening. In the solid-state binding assays, the TR is coupled to either a multiwell plate or to beads. Coupling of the receptors to plates or beads readily enables the separation of free and bound ligands without the use of either filtering or chromatographic methods. Only three of the four TR isoforms have ligand-binding capability and two of these (TR betal and TR beta2) have identical ligand-binding domains. Binding assays are expected to have a low rate of false positives. False negatives can occur if the chemical requires metabolic activation or if solubility problems are encountered.
Transfection and transformation assays. One of the problems with TR binding assays is that they cannot differentiate between agonists and antagonists. Alternative assays that would examine receptor binding and differentiate between agonists and antagonists are systems in which a specific TR is transfected into a mammalian cell line along with a reporter gene, typically coding for luciferase, beta-galactosidase, or choline acetyl transferase (70). Transformed yeast cell lines containing TR gene constructs have also been developed. In these systems, T3 or other ligands to TR bind and activate the receptor, which then interacts with specific response elements upstream from the reporter gene and enhances its transcription.
The increased transcription is determined by increased enzymatic activity of the reporter gene product, e.g., luciferase. Chemicals can be tested alone or in combination with T3 to determine agonist or antagonist properties. Similar systems have been used to examine the interactions of TR with different response elements (71), different cofactors (72), and with phosphorylation of TR (73).
Although these systems have not been used for screening for environmental chemicals that are TR ligands, similar screens have been developed for estrogens and androgen agonists and antagonists (4).
Transformed yeast cell and transfected mammalian cell lines have been used to study several of the steroid hormone receptor super family members. There are differences among the assays used for estrogen, androgen, and thyroid hormone receptors. There are currently only two recognized mammalian estrogen receptors and a single androgen receptor, in contrast to the four isoforms of TR. TRs act predominately as heterodimers with RXR (74-76), whereas the estrogen and androgen receptors are active as homodimers. Both TR and the peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR) form heterodimers with RXR and agonists of PPAR can alter TR mediated gene expression by binding and competing for RXR (71). Hence, chemicals might alter TR activation by altering RXR or PPAR pathways. TR activation is also regulated by phosphorylation (72,73), similar to the estrogen and androgen receptors. In designing a screen for TR ligands, chemicals may have different effects depending on the TR transfected, the response element used, and their interactions with PPAR and RXR. Because of the complexity of this system, several screens would have to be incorporated to account for the multiplicity of interactions of the different TR isoforms. An advantage of the transfection assays is that chemicals that alter TR activation through mechanisms not involving direct binding to TR would be detected in these assays. Another advantage of these assays is that they are readily adapted to high through-put screens.
A major disadvantage of these in vitro screens is the lack of metabolic capability of the cells or assays. It is possible that the metabolites of some chemicals would produce these effects and not the parent compound. The cell lines typically used in these assays have limited ability to metabolize the test compounds, particularly persistent organic pollutants such as the polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and the dioxins. The transformation assays in yeast have additional drawbacks in that for many chemicals entry into the yeast is limited because of the cell wall.
GH3 cell assay for thyroid hormone action. An in vitro bioassay has been designed that can detect TR agonists (77). This assay uses the rat pituitary tumor cell line GHM . The growth of these cells are dependent on TH when plated at low-density in serum-free medium (77). In addition, the morphology of these cells is also altered by THs in a dose-dependent manner. One form of the assay measures cell proliferation in response to TR agonists by the determination of the transformation of monotetrazolium (MTT) tetraxolium salt into MTT fromazan by mitochondrial enzymes (77). This assay is performed on microwell plates and can be considered a high through-put screen. Although this assay is relatively new, it has the potential to provide information as a screen for chemicals that activate TR.
Section summary. Although there are no known environmental chemicals that act as either TR agonists or antagonists, there are dear examples of environmental chemicals, both synthetic and naturally occurring, that bind to the estrogen receptor and act as agonists, antagonists, or partial agonists (3). In addition, there are several chemicals found in the environment that act as antiandrogens (78). Although the hypothesis that environmental chemicals bind TR has been proposed, it has not been adequately tested. Recent methodological developments resulting in high through-put assays could be performed on a limited number of chemicals to test this hypothesis. However, broad-based screening should reflect known biologic mechanisms and at this time there is no evidence of any xenobiotic binding to the thyroid receptor.
Developmental assays. The role of THs in developing humans and other animals is well documented. Hypothyroidism during development leads to permanent alterations in a number of organ systems including the central nervous system and the male reproductive system. The sensitivity of developing animals may provide models for testing and screening chemicals that alter thyroid hormone catabolism or interfere with thyroid hormone signaling.
Neurodevelopmental assays. The development of the central nervous system is dependent on thyroid hormones for control of neuronal proliferation, initiation of neuronal differentiation, formation and development of neuronal processes, and timely myelinization of the neurons (14). In humans, hypothyroidism induced by iodine deficiency results in neurologic endemic cretinism. This disorder is characterized by a high incidence of severe mental retardation, deaf-mutism, and problems with gross and fine motor coordination. Congenital hypothyroidism also results in cognitive impairment and growth delay. In addition, maternal hypothyroidism during pregnancy results in an increased incidence of neurologic and behavioral disorders in the offspring. In rodents maternal hypothyroidism Environmental Health Perspectives a Volume 107, Number 5, May 1999 produces a variety of behavioral and morphologic changes in the brain similar to those observed in humans.
Morphologic and biochemical assays in developing brains. Morphologic and biochemical changes in the developing brain have been observed in animals exposed to agents that decrease thyroid hormone concentrations, such as PTU. For example, decreased brain weight occurs in rodents, with marked decreases in serum THs during perinatal development (79,80). Perinatal hypothyroidism also results in morphologic abnormalities in the organ of Corti (81)(82)(83). Biochemical changes observed in hypothyroid animals include decreases in myelin basic protein and alterations in neurotransmitter concentrations, among others (14). The morphologic and biochemical changes induced by hypothyroidism are detectable when maternal, fetal, or neonatal serum T4 concentrations are significantly decreased.
Behavioral testing. Numerous behavioral assays have examined the effects of goitrogens or iodine deficiency in developing mammals. Hypothyroidism during development delays eye opening (84), reflex development (84) and weaning (85) in rodents. Decreased motor activity has also been demonstrated following developmental hypothyroidism (86). Exposure to PTU in drinking water from gestational day 18 to postnatal day 25 produces delays in eye opening, reduced body weights, decreased or delayed preweaning motor activity, and increased postweaning motor activity (87). Similar to humans, developmental hypothyroidism in rodents permanently alters auditory function (87,88). These behavioral assays can be used to detect hypothyroidism; however, most of these behavioral changes may not be specific to hypothyroidism and have the potential for a high rate of false negatives. More importantly, these behavioral changes occur only when there are significant decreases in serum T4 concentrations (87,88).
Male reproductive system development. Testes weight and sperm counts. Hypothyroidism in humans during the juvenile stage is associated with megalotestis and high sperm counts. Maternal iodine deficiency or repeated exposure to goitrogens such as PTU or PCBs during lactation increases testes weight and sperm counts in rats when the animals reach maturity (89)(90)(91). Similar findings have been reported in mice, hamsters, and roosters. Conversely, neonatal hyperthyroidism results in decreased testes weights and lower sperm counts (92). Hence, testes weights and sperm counts can be used as measures of thyroid status in developing animals. An advantage of these measurements is their ease. Testes weights are simple to determine and methods to measure sperm counts have been developed over decades and are readily performed. The disadvantage of this assay is that it requires repeated dosing of the animals during lactation and a waiting period of several weeks prior to measuring the end points. In response to a thyrotoxic agent, these responses are observed only when there are significant decreases in serum TH concentrations (89)(90)(91). Additionally, testes weights and sperm counts can also be affected by other types of agents, such as estrogenic antiandrogenic compounds, as well as chemicals that have a direct effect on the testis. Section summary. Hypothyroidism during development produces profound permanent change in the auditory system, central nervous system, and the male reproductive system. A number of assays or test systems can be used to detect chemicals that produce hypothyroidism. However, most of these assays or test systems are time consuming and not necessarily specific for hypothyroidism. In addition, pronounced decreases in serum T4 concentrations are required to detect the behavioral or morphologic changes. Alterations in serum THs can be detected at lower dose levels than those required to detect the behavioral and morphologic changes in these systems. Because of the greater sensitivity and simplicity, determination of serum TH concentrations is recommended instead of these developmental assays. It should be remembered that using adult, pubescent, or prepubescent animals may be qualitatively predictive of fetal response, whereas it may not be quantitatively predictive of dose or response in fetal tissue.
Screeningfor chemicals that alter thyroidfiuntion and homeostasis in nonmammalian wildlife. Similar to mammalian systems, the thyroid and THs are critical in the development of amphibians, birds, fish, and reptiles (7)(8)(9). Although there are similarities in the basic structure and function of the thyroid system among vertebrate species (93,94), there are also differences that must be considered when recommending tests of thyroid function. TRs have been doned in one species of teleosts (95), in two species of frogs (96), and in chickens (19). TRs from all species examined show similar structurebinding activity relationships with regard to T4, T3, and their analogs (97)(98)(99)(100). However, there are some differences in the regulation of THs by nonmammalian wildlife. In teleosts a negligible amount of T3 is synthesized and secreted (93) from the thyroid gland. The plasma proteins involved in transport of THs in teleosts bind T3 preferentially in contrast to the mammalian plasma proteins that bind T4 preferentially (93). The serum TH binding proteins in teleosts do not appear to be structurally related to TTR (101). Although the serumbinding protein found in the bullfrog tadpole is a homolog of TTR, it preferentially binds T3 (102). In addition, there are seasonal changes in THs in teleosts that are not apparent in mammalian systems. One important difference among mammals, fish, and amphibians is the hypothalamic control of TSH from the pituitary. In teleosts, the hypothalamus negatively controls the release of TSH, whereas in mammals it is positively controlled. In developing tadpoles, the hypothalamus positively controls TSH release via corticotropinreleasing factor rather than TRH. TRH in tadpoles and adult frogs appears to play a role in osmoregulation by regulating prolactin release from the pituitary (103). This suggests that assays routinely used in rodents, such as the TRH challenge and the TTR binding assays, may not be uniformly applicable to nonmammalian species. Some of the assays used to assess thyroid function in rodents must be viewed cautiously when applied to nonmammalian systems.
Despite some of the species differences in TH regulation, there is a concordance between mammals and fish in response to many chemicals that alter TH function or homeostasis (93). An example of chemicals that demonstrate significant differences in species sensitivity are the mono-ortho substituted PCBs, which are efficacious in decreasing plasma or serum T4 in rodents but have little effects on plasma TH in fish. Many of the assays described previously could be used to examine chemical effects on TH function and homeostasis in fish and other wildlife if appropriately adapted for the species of interest. Alterations in thyroid function can be examined histologically in teleosts (93), similar to the mammalian system. However, it should be noted that the thyroid gland in most teleosts is not encapsulated and consists of diffuise scattered follicles, making metrics like thyroid weights more difficult to obtain. This anatomical difference also makes histologic evaluation difficult, particularly for weak goitrogens. In fish, there appears to be considerable control of the thyroid system via the mechanisms controlling peripheral T3 production (93). Consequently, measures of deiodinase activities in conjunction with peripheral T4 assessments are required to thoroughly evaluate T3 availability to target tissues.
Tadpole metamorphosis assay. The development of tadpoles into frogs occurs in multiple stages, with different organ systems developing at different times. THs are required for metamorphosis (7-9!) but TH action is modulated by other hormones Workshop Summary * Screening for thyroid hormone disruptors (104,105). In conjunction with T3, corticosterone accelerates metamorphosis at later stages of development (106). Circulating prolactin concentrations increase toward the end of metamorphosis (7) and prolactin down regulates TR expression, apparently modulating the stimulatory action of T (107). Chemicals that alter tadpole deve?opment may not interact directly with TRs or directly alter TH concentrations, but may act indirectly by altering other endocrine pathways. In addition, chemicals that alter calcium homeostasis, such as calmodulin antagonists, also alter metamorphosis (108). The tadpole metamorphosis assay may be a valuable tool for screening chemicals that alter TH signaling pathways either directly or indirectly.
One disadvantage of the tadpole assay is that it has not been validated and several questions need to be answered prior to use of this assay as a screen. There are a number of different classes of chemicals that alter TH synthesis, transport, and catabolism. Few of these chemicals have been examined in this assay. It is not clear whether the tadpole will respond to different inducers of UDP-GT in a manner similar to mammals or even to other aquatic species. Clearly this assay requires further validation and standardization prior to use as a screen.
Section summary. THs are critical in development for nonmammalian wildlife and there are examples of chemicals that alter THs and produce alterations in nonmammalian wildlife. Many of the assays discussed for mammalian system can be used for nonmammals provided these assays are sufficiently modified to examine the nonmammalian species of interest. The tadpole metamorphosis assay is potentially useful as a screen but requires further validation and standardization.

Conclusion
The workshop participants attempted to address the merits and limitations of numerous assays available as potential screening methods for chemicals that alter thyroid hormone action, function, or homeostasis. Not every existing assay was examined because of limitations of time and expertise. Some combinations of the assays evaluated may be useful as screens. Chemicals appear to alter the thyroid system by either inhibiting synthesis of THs, altering serum binding to transport proteins, or by increasing TH metabolism. Few if any environmentally relevant chemicals have been demonstrated to act as either TR agonists or antagonists. The development and implementation of screens should reflect the known mechanism of action.
Screening for chemicals using either thyroid histology or serum TH concentrations in mammals should provide tests that would produce few false negatives or false positives. Subchronic studies in mammals examining thyroid histology provide the most useful measure of a chemical's thyrotoxic potency and efficacy. However, these assays are not necessarily screens, and they require dosing animals for at least 2-6 weeks to observe consistent responses. Determination of serum TH concentrations in short-term tests may provide an adequate initial screen for chemicals in mammals. The exact dosing regimen and time course for these responses have not been adequately examined in the published literature. Determination of serum TH concentrations and thyroid histology may also be of value in teleosts; however, indices of peripheral T3 production are also required to evaluate thyroid status and should be included when determining the effects of chemicals on teleosts.