Clinical Description
MCM8/MCM9-related syndromes are characterized by primary gonadal insufficiency (hypergonadotropic hypogonadism), incomplete or delayed pubertal development, and increased risk of early-onset germ cell tumors in females [Alvarez-Mora et al 2020, Helderman et al 2025]. MCM9-related syndrome is also associated with increased susceptibility to colorectal polyposis, early-onset colorectal cancer, and gastric cancer. To date, 54 individuals (26 with MCM8-related syndrome and 28 with MCM9-related syndrome) have been reported in the literature [Wood-Trageser et al 2014, AlAsiri et al 2015, Goldberg et al 2015, Tenenbaum-Rakover et al 2015, Dou et al 2016, Fauchereau et al 2016, Bouali et al 2017, Desai et al 2017, Jolly et al 2019, Terradas et al 2019, Yang et al 2019, Alvarez-Mora et al 2020, França et al 2020, Golubicki et al 2020, Guo et al 2020, Heddar et al 2020, Jin et al 2020, Liu et al 2020, Wang et al 2020, Zhang et al 2020, Goldberg et al 2021, Shen et al 2021, Soares de Lima et al 2021, Turkyilmaz et al 2021, Kherraf et al 2022, Tucker et al 2022, Potorac et al 2023]. Individuals reported to date were curated from the literature and summarized by Helderman et al [2025], who only included individuals with biallelic pathogenic and likely pathogenic variants (n=15 for MCM8; n=22 for MCM9) as well as variants of uncertain significance (VUS) with a combined annotation-dependent depletion (CADD) score higher than 20 and a gnomAD allele frequency lower than 1% (n=11 for MCM8; n=6 for MCM9). The following description of the phenotypic features associated with these conditions is based on these data. These reports should be interpreted in light of potential ascertainment bias, as most individuals were identified through fertility-focused studies rather than cancer cohorts, likely explaining the high prevalence of primary gonadal insufficiency.
Note: Unless otherwise specified, data and information do not apply to MCM8/MCM9 heterozygotes and individuals with biallelic variants of uncertain significance that do not pass the pathogenicity filtering (CADD score higher than 20 and a gnomAD allele frequency lower than 1%).
Primary gonadal insufficiency (hypergonadotropic hypogonadism) is the most consistent phenotypic feature associated with biallelic MCM8 or MCM9 variants. In the largest aggregated cohort, gonadal dysfunction was reported in 88% of individuals with biallelic MCM8 pathogenic variants (23/26) and 93% with biallelic MCM9 pathogenic variants (26/28), typically recognized between ages ten and 30 years; these proportions may be inflated by ascertainment through fertility-focused studies [Helderman et al 2025].
Females typically present with primary ovarian insufficiency, which may manifest as absent puberty, delayed or incomplete pubertal development, primary amenorrhea, or secondary amenorrhea/oligomenorrhea after spontaneous menarche. Underdeveloped uterus and small/streak ovaries on pelvic ultrasound are common (particularly prior to estrogen exposure) [Wood-Trageser et al 2014, AlAsiri et al 2015, Bouali et al 2017, Wang et al 2020].
Males most often present with infertility due to impaired spermatogenesis. The spectrum of spermatogenic phenotype includes azoospermia to severe oligospermia/oligoasthenospermia. Semen parameters can fluctuate with age and intercurrent factors (smoking, obesity, stress, exposure to heat). Sertoli cell-only syndrome (complete absence of germ cells on testicular biopsy) has been reported in some males [Tenenbaum-Rakover et al 2015, Kherraf et al 2022, Potorac et al 2023]. Note: The presence of sperm – even with apparently normal parameters on a single evaluation – should not be used to exclude MCM8/MCM9-related syndromes, particularly if the broader clinical picture (e.g., hypergonadotropic hypogonadism, family history consistent with autosomal recessive inheritance) remains suggestive.
Short stature has been reported in individuals with pubertal delay due to an MCM8/MCM9-related syndrome. Final adult height is affected by age at treatment initiation and adherence to hormone therapy [Wood-Trageser et al 2014, França et al 2020, Guo et al 2020, Wang et al 2020, Turkyilmaz et al 2021].
Germ cell tumors have only been reported in females, including two individuals with biallelic MCM8 pathogenic variants and one individual with biallelic MCM9 pathogenic variants [Alvarez-Mora et al 2020, Helderman et al 2025]. Reported tumors include endodermal sinus tumors, dysgerminomas, and gonadal tumors arising in the setting of marked gonadal dysgenesis. These tumors have occurred in childhood and adolescence (age range: 11 to 15 years) [Helderman et al 2025].
Thyroid dysfunction (including hypothyroidism) has been reported in three individuals with biallelic MCM8 variants. Two individuals had primary hypothyroidism; the third individual had hypothyroidism identified in childhood and had normal thyroid-stimulating hormone and free T4 levels at the time of evaluation but persistent anti-TPO (thyroid peroxidase) antibodies [AlAsiri et al 2015, Heddar et al 2020].
Colorectal polyposis has been observed primarily in individuals with biallelic MCM9 variants [Helderman et al 2025]. Polyps were often numerous, frequently exceeding 20 at the time of endoscopic evaluation, with reported histologic types including adenomas and hyperplastic and serrated polyps [Goldberg et al 2015]; age at identification of polyps ranged between 19 and 68 years [Goldberg et al 2021, Helderman et al 2025]. Two previously reported individuals with biallelic MCM8 pathogenic variants subsequently developed colorectal polyps after publication [Helderman et al 2025; N Helderman, unpublished data]. One individual had a sessile serrated lesion and a tubular adenoma with low-grade dysplasia at age 26 years; her 35-year-old sister developed six tubular adenomas with low-grade dysplasia and three hyperplastic polyps [N Helderman, unpublished data]. The prevalence of colorectal polyposis may be underestimated, as many individuals with biallelic MCM8 or MCM9 pathogenic variants were young at the time of diagnosis and/or were not evaluated by colonoscopy.
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the most frequently reported malignancy in individuals with biallelic MCM9 pathogenic variants, with ages at diagnosis ranging between 30 and 60 years [Goldberg et al 2015, Goldberg et al 2021, Helderman et al 2025]. The prevalence of CRC in individuals with biallelic MCM8 or MCM9 pathogenic variants may be underestimated due to ascertainment bias in this cohort, as cancer risk is age dependent, most individuals were identified through fertility-focused studies, and many did not have longitudinal follow up.
Gastric cancer has been reported in one individual with biallelic MCM9 variants [Helderman et al 2025]. Consistent with this observation, population-level analyses suggest significant enrichment of biallelic MCM9 pathogenic variants among individuals with gastric cancer (odds ratio: 27.03; 95% CI: 2.93-248.5). No enrichment was observed among individuals with biallelic MCM8 pathogenic variants, and no individuals with biallelic MCM8 pathogenic variants with gastric cancer have been reported to date [Helderman et al 2025].
Other findings have been reported in isolated individuals with MCM8/MCM9-related syndromes. Given the limited number of reported individuals, these features should be interpreted with caution but warrant mention. Reported findings include intellectual disability, temporal lobe epilepsy, hearing loss, and unilateral kidney agenesis in one individual [Tenenbaum-Rakover et al 2015]. Another individual presented with facial nevi and a shield-like chest [Wang et al 2020], and pilomatricomas were reported in a further individual [Heddar et al 2020]. At present, it remains unclear whether these features are part of the phenotype or represent coincidental findings.
MCM8/MCM9 heterozygotes. Individuals heterozygous for an MCM8 or MCM9 variant may have reduced fertility. Hypogonadism was observed in 29% (14/49) of individuals with a heterozygous MCM8 pathogenic variant and 22% (10/45) of individuals with a heterozygous MCM9 pathogenic variant [Helderman et al 2025].
CRC and polyposis have been rarely reported in heterozygous individuals (two individuals with CRC and two with polyposis in those with a heterozygous MCM8 pathogenic variant; six individuals with CRC and seven with polyposis in those with a heterozygous MCM9 pathogenic variant, including three individuals having both). CRC onset was at older ages (age >40 years) compared to individuals with biallelic pathogenic variants [Helderman et al 2025]. However, to date there is no clear evidence that heterozygotes are at increased risk of CRC or polyposis.