Continuing Education Activity
Butterbur (derived from the leaves of Petasites hybridus) is an herbal supplement that has been found to be effective in the prophylaxis of adult migraines in multiple studies. Based on these trials, the American Headache Society gave the herb a level A recommendation and declared it effective in preventing migraine headaches. This activity reviews the mechanism of action, adverse event profile, toxicity, dosing, and pharmacodynamics of butterbur and the recommended monitoring of patients taking the drug to avoid adverse effects.
Objectives:
Identify the proposed mechanism of action of butterbur in relieving migraine headaches.
Review the indications for initiating butterbur.
Summarize the contraindications of butterbur.
Discuss interprofessional team strategies for improving care coordination and communication when considering or using butterbur in migraine management.
Access free multiple choice questions on this topic.
Indications
FDA Approved Indications
Non-FDA Approved Indications
Adult Migraine
The American Headache Society and the American Academy of Neurology: 2012 evidence-based guideline update indicated that Petasites (butterbur) demonstrates effectiveness for migraine prevention and is a valid option for patients with migraine to reduce both the severity and frequency of migraine attacks (Level A). The recommendation was questioned and then retracted in 2016.[1]
Butterbur (leaves of Petasites hybridus) has been found to be effective in the prophylaxis of adult migraines in multiple studies.[2] Based on these trials, the American Headache Society gave the herb a level A recommendation and declared it to be effective in the prevention of migraine headaches. Similarly, the Canadian Headache Society guidelines give butterbur a strong recommendation for use in migraine prophylaxis.[3] Although the American Academy of Neurology recommended butterbur, it has retracted its current guidelines on it.[3] In the United Kingdom and Germany, butterbur is not authorized for official use due to safety concerns.[3] In one randomized, parallel-group study from 2004, the group given butterbur had a response rate of 45%, whereas the group who used placebo had a response rate of 15%. In another randomized controlled trial from 2004, butterbur reduced the frequency of migraines by 48% in the experimental group, whereas the placebo reduced the frequency by 26% in the control group.[2]
Pediatric Migraine
Similar to adult migraines, there is evidence for Petasites in the prevention of pediatric migraines.[4] In one randomized controlled trial from 2005, butterbur reduced the frequency of attacks by at least 50% in 77% of the pediatric experimental group.[2] In another randomized controlled trial from 2008, butterbur reduced the frequency of attacks by 59% in the experimental group, whereas the placebo reduced the frequency of attacks by 31% in the control group.[5]
Allergic Rhinitis and Asthma
Butterbur has been used in countries in Asia as a herbal treatment of asthma and allergic diseases.[6]There is a limited body of evidence from randomized controlled trials that butterbur may be useful as a therapy for asthma and allergic rhinitis but not as effective as preventing migraine.[2][7]
Alzheimer's Disease
Studies have found that butterbur may potentially be effective in treating Alzheimer's disease due to its neuroprotective effect. However, only studies involving in vitro and in vivo models have been performed.[8]
Mechanism of Action
Mechanism of Action for the Treatment of Migraines
Petasites inhibit the opening of L-type voltage-gated calcium channels, decreasing vasoconstriction of vessels and excitation of neurons.
[4] The herb's active components include Sesquiterpenes (Petasin and Isopetasin) which have been found to exhibit anti-inflammatory effects through the inhibition of COX-2. This leads to decreased leukotriene synthesis and prostaglandin E2 release.
[9]
Mechanism of Action for the Treatment of Asthma and Allergic Rhinitis
Petatewalide B, a derivative of Petasites, has also been found to exhibit anti-allergic activities.
[6] Specifically, the compound inhibits the activation of ß-hexosaminidase in RBL-2H3 mast cells. Petatewalide B also inhibits nitric oxide synthase, which decreases nitric oxide production in mouse peritoneal macrophages. The compound also decreases the concentration of eosinophils, macrophages, and lymphocytes in mouse bronchoalveolar lavage fluid.
[6]
Mechanism of Action for the Treatment of Alzheimer Disease
Derivatives of Petasites have been found to have antioxidant activity; the DPPH free radical-scavenging value and ferric ion reducing potential were both increased.
[10] In one study examining the cognitive effects of butterbur, the herb significantly decreased levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels and increased the viability of HT22 mouse neuronal cells exposed to Aß plaques. The study found that the mechanism for the former was related to increased expression of heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1), NAD(P)H quinine dehydrogenase 1, and cyclic AMP response element-binding protein (CREB), which are all involved in antioxidant pathways.
[8] Similarly, in Aß plaque-injected mice, the administration of butterbur resulted in significantly decreased CREB expression in the dentate gyrus.
[8]
Administration
Butterbur is given almost exclusively via oral administration.[11] The recommended daily dose is between 50 mg to 150 mg.
Adverse Effects
Previous randomized controlled trials have found no serious adverse effects and good overall tolerance of the drug.[2] Minor effects include gastrointestinal symptoms (belching is the most common), dyspepsia, headache, itchy eyes, drowsiness, fatigue, and asthma. Long-term use of butterbur may rarely lead to cholestatic hepatitis (estimated incidence of 1:175,000). Patients who are allergic to ragweed and daisies may also have similar allergic reactions to butterbur.[2]
One major area of concern regarding safety is with pyrrolizidine alkaloids which are commonly found in the butterbur plant.[9] These substances can cause hepatotoxicity, lung toxicity, carcinogenesis, and thrombosis. Fortunately, the commercial preparation process of butterbur typically removes these substances. Thus, it is recommended for consumers of butterbur only buy brands that are free of alkaloids and other plant carcinogens.
Severe hepatotoxicity may be associated with butterbur use, but the evidence is unclear. From the World Health Organization's Vigibase, one study reported 40 cases of hepatotoxicity, including two liver transplants associated with the use of Petasites formulations.[3] However, these cases may be the result of the use of butterbur contaminated with alkaloids. Another article reported detecting levels of toxic alkaloids in seven out of 21 commercially available compounds.[3] Therefore, at least some brands are inadequately removing alkaloids from their butterbur formulations. In summary, it is unclear if hepatotoxicity is due to alkaloids in the formulation or the butterbur itself. To evaluate the hepatotoxic effects of butterbur more clearly, a future study can collect data on brands that claim to be alkaloid-free by thoroughly reviewing the literature and the Periodic Update Safety Report. The data can then be analyzed with the Roussel Uclaf Causality Assessment Method test to determine if butterbur carries an association with hepatotoxicity.[12]
Contraindications
Butterbur use is contraindicated in patients using anticholinergic medications. Also, there have not been studies establishing safety criteria in children under six or pregnant or lactating women. Therefore, butterbur use is not recommended in these groups.[9]
Monitoring
Multiple studies recommend a daily dose of 50-150 mg.[11] Monitoring liver function (AST, ALT, ALP, GCT, bilirubin) is recommended due to potential hepatotoxicity from butterbur or drug contamination with pyrrolizidine alkaloids.[2]
Toxicity
The list of side effects of butterbur is in the adverse effects section. Long-term use of butterbur may rarely lead to reversible cholestatic hepatitis (estimated incidence of 1:175,000).[9] Butterbur may also interact with anticholinergic medications. There is no known antidote for butterbur overdose. The recommendation in such cases is to cease using the drug.
Enhancing Healthcare Team Outcomes
There have been no formal studies examining interprofessional care and its relationship to butterbur. Nevertheless, close coordination among all interprofessional healthcare team members, including clinicians (MDs, DOs, PAs, NPs), nurses, pharmacists, and other healthcare providers, is recommended to monitor for side effects and interactions with other medications, especially anticholinergics. As a herbal remedy, butterbur may often not appear on a patient's official prescribed medication list. Therefore, every healthcare provider needs to inquire about alternative or natural remedies when interviewing patients and record it in the patient's chart. By employing interprofessional care coordination and open communication, the healthcare team can optimize patient care and prevent adverse events for patients using butterbur. [Level 5]
References
- 1.
Holland S, Silberstein SD, Freitag F, Dodick DW, Argoff C, Ashman E., Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology and the American Headache Society. Evidence-based guideline update: NSAIDs and other complementary treatments for episodic migraine prevention in adults: report of the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology and the American Headache Society.
Neurology. 2012 Apr 24;78(17):1346-53. [
PMC free article: PMC3335449] [
PubMed: 22529203]
- 2.
Malone M, Tsai G. The evidence for herbal and botanical remedies, Part 1.
J Fam Pract. 2018 Jan;67(1):10-16. [
PubMed: 29309469]
- 3.
Rajapakse T, Pringsheim T. Nutraceuticals in Migraine: A Summary of Existing Guidelines for Use.
Headache. 2016 Apr;56(4):808-16. [
PubMed: 26954394]
- 4.
Orr SL. The Evidence for the Role of Nutraceuticals in the Management of Pediatric Migraine: a Review.
Curr Pain Headache Rep. 2018 Apr 04;22(5):37. [
PubMed: 29619575]
- 5.
Oelkers-Ax R, Leins A, Parzer P, Hillecke T, Bolay HV, Fischer J, Bender S, Hermanns U, Resch F. Butterbur root extract and music therapy in the prevention of childhood migraine: an explorative study.
Eur J Pain. 2008 Apr;12(3):301-13. [
PubMed: 17659990]
- 6.
Choi YW, Lee KP, Kim JM, Kang S, Park SJ, Lee JM, Moon HR, Jung JH, Lee YG, Im DS. Petatewalide B, a novel compound from Petasites japonicus with anti-allergic activity.
J Ethnopharmacol. 2016 Feb 03;178:17-24. [
PubMed: 26674157]
- 7.
Lee DK, Haggart K, Robb FM, Lipworth BJ. Butterbur, a herbal remedy, confers complementary anti-inflammatory activity in asthmatic patients receiving inhaled corticosteroids.
Clin Exp Allergy. 2004 Jan;34(1):110-4. [
PubMed: 14720270]
- 8.
Kim N, Choi JG, Park S, Lee JK, Oh MS. Butterbur Leaves Attenuate Memory Impairment and Neuronal Cell Damage in Amyloid Beta-Induced Alzheimer's Disease Models.
Int J Mol Sci. 2018 Jun 01;19(6) [
PMC free article: PMC6032106] [
PubMed: 29865187]
- 9.
D'Andrea G, Cevoli S, Cologno D. Herbal therapy in migraine.
Neurol Sci. 2014 May;35 Suppl 1:135-40. [
PubMed: 24867850]
- 10.
Ezzatzadeh E, Hossaini Z. Green synthesis and antioxidant activity of novel series of benzofurans from euparin extracted of
Petasites hybridus.
Nat Prod Res. 2019 Jun;33(11):1617-1623. [
PubMed: 29376428]
- 11.
D'Onofrio F, Raimo S, Spitaleri D, Casucci G, Bussone G. Usefulness of nutraceuticals in migraine prophylaxis.
Neurol Sci. 2017 May;38(Suppl 1):117-120. [
PubMed: 28527067]
- 12.
Chen CW. [Carefully reviewing the history of diagnostic scales and paying more attention to the diagnostic value of Roussel - Uclaf causality assessment method scale for drug - induced liver injury].
Zhonghua Gan Zang Bing Za Zhi. 2016 Nov 20;24(11):801-803. [
PubMed: 27978922]
Disclosure: Lennox Din declares no relevant financial relationships with ineligible companies.
Disclosure: Forshing Lui declares no relevant financial relationships with ineligible companies.
