Clinical Description
AP-4-associated hereditary spastic paraplegia (AP-4-HSP) is a childhood-onset and complex form of hereditary spastic paraplegia. Spastic paraparesis is a universal feature in affected individuals. Manifestations typically begin before age one year, with infants presenting with hypotonia, mild postnatal microcephaly, and delayed developmental milestones. Seizures are common in early childhood, often starting as prolonged febrile seizures. As the disease progresses, hypotonia transitions to progressive lower-extremity weakness and spasticity, accompanied by pyramidal signs such as plantar extension, ankle clonus, and hyperreflexia. Although some children achieve independent ambulation, most eventually lose this ability and rely on mobility aids or wheelchairs. In adolescence or early adulthood, spasticity may affect the upper extremities in some individuals but is generally less severe and not significantly disabling.
Complications include contractures, foot deformities, and bladder and bowel dysfunction. Dysphagia may emerge in advanced stages of the disease. Dystonia is a prominent extrapyramidal manifestation in early childhood in some, and cerebellar features may become more apparent in later stages. Behavioral manifestations such as impulsivity, hyperactivity, and inattention are frequently observed.
To date, uncomplicated hereditary spastic paraplegia, a pure spastic paraparesis without other neurologic manifestations, has not been reported in individuals with AP-4-HSP.
This summary integrates findings from 156 individuals across 101 families [Ebrahimi-Fakhari et al 2020] and ongoing longitudinal data from a natural history study including 303 individuals from 289 families (NCT04712812) [D Ebrahimi-Fakhari, unpublished data].
Progressive lower-limb spasticity and weakness typically emerge in early childhood and become universal in individuals with AP-4-HSP. The condition usually progresses from mild global hypotonia in infancy (92% of affected individuals, 244/264) to pronounced lower limb spasticity.
Onset of progressive spastic paraparesis typically occurs between ages four and six years (85%, 256/301).
In children younger than age four years, lower limb spasticity is present in 60% (47/78).
In children age four years and older, lower limb spasticity is present in 96% (216/226).
Pyramidal signs, such as hyperreflexia in the lower extremities, ankle clonus, and a positive Babinski sign, are often evident in early childhood. Spasticity initially manifests in the ankles, often accompanied by in-toeing, and progressively moves proximally, further impairing ambulation. Over time, most children with AP-4-HSP require mobility aids or transition to full-time wheelchair use.
Developmental delay is universal. Delayed motor milestones (99%, 277/281) are often the presenting manifestation:
Sitting (median age: 12 months; Q1-Q3: 9-18 months)
Crawling (median age: 18 months; Q1-Q3: 12.3-24 months)
Standing unsupported (median age: 24 months; Q1-Q3: 18-36 months)
Walking with support (median age: 25 months; Q1-Q3: 20-36 months)
About 45% (110/243) of individuals achieve independent walking (median age: 30 months; Q1-Q3: 24-36 months), a skill that is often lost as the disease progresses.
Speech and language development is significantly impaired or absent (97%, 269/276). The majority of affected individuals communicate nonverbally. Intellectual disability in older children is usually moderate to severe.
Microcephaly becomes evident in infancy in the majority of affected individuals (67%, 73/109) and is often two to three standard deviations below the mean for age and sex.
Seizures often occur in the first two years of life; about 60% (96/160) of individuals have a diagnosis of epilepsy. Seizure types include focal-onset seizures (often with secondary generalization) as well as primary generalized seizures. Status epilepticus has been reported in a significant subset of affected individuals.
About 70% (94/134) of affected individuals, including individuals with and without epilepsy, have seizures in the setting of fever.
In general, seizures become less frequent with age and are often well controlled with standard anti-seizure medications (ASMs). Children with developmental brain malformations, such as polymicrogyria, often require continued treatment with ASMs and may develop medically refractory epilepsy.
Bladder and bowel dysfunction. Urinary incontinence is seen in 81% of affected individuals (112/139) and stool incontinence in 72% (105/146).
Foot deformities, most commonly clubfoot, occur in 50% (118/238) of affected individuals.
Episodes of stereotypic laughter, perhaps indicating a pseudobulbar affect, are a characteristic finding in a subset of individuals (46%, 113/245) [Ebrahimi-Fakhari et al 2018, Ebrahimi-Fakhari et al 2020].
Less frequent findings
Impaired pain sensation (38%, 36/96) has been reported; however, formal investigations for sensory neuropathy have not been performed.
Short stature has been observed (34%, 25/74).
Extrapyramidal manifestations are present in 28% (83/301) of affected individuals, with the most common phenomenology being dystonia (14%, 43/301), followed by ataxia (7%, 20/301). Bradykinesia (3%, 10/301) and rigidity (3%, 8/301) are observed in later stages of the disease.
Dysphagia may emerge in advanced stages of the disease (24%, 54/224) and may lead to dependence on gastrostomy tube feeding (5%, 4/88).
Dysarthria (21%, 30/140) impairs speech production.
Neurobehavioral/psychiatric manifestations have been observed in some individuals, including:
Short attention span (33%, 100/301);
Overactivity (12%, 35/301);
Impulsivity (12%, 37/301).
Prognosis. Natural history data are beginning to emerge. The oldest reported individual is age 55 years [D Ebrahimi-Fakhari, unpublished data].
Prevalence
AP-4-HSP is rare. To date, more than 300 individuals with AP-4-HSP are known; 311 have been included in the Registry and Natural History Study for Early Onset Hereditary Spastic Paraplegia (HSP) (NCT04712812) (updated 1-6-25).
Families with AP-4-HSP have been reported from North America, South America Europe, the Middle East, China, and the Indian subcontinent [D Ebrahimi-Fakhari, unpublished data].
About half of individuals with AP-4-HSP have consanguineous parents (46%, 142/311) [D Ebrahimi-Fakhari, unpublished data]. Previously reported consanguinity rates were higher likely due to ascertainment bias, as initial reports were focused on families from countries with high rates of consanguinity [Verkerk et al 2009, Abou Jamra et al 2011, Moreno-De-Luca et al 2011]. More recently, AP-4-HSP has been reported in populations with low rates of consanguinity [Ebrahimi-Fakhari et al 2018, Ebrahimi-Fakhari et al 2020].