TABLE 4-13Summary of Epidemiologic Assessments, Mechanistic Assessments, and Causality Conclusions for Measles, Mumps, and Rubella Vaccine

VaccineAdverse EventEpidemiologic AssessmentStudies Contributing to the Epidemiologic AssessmentMechanistic AssessmentCases Contributing to the Mechanistic AssessmentCausality Conclusion
MMRMeasles Inclusion Body EncephalitisInsufficientNoneStrong (measles; in individuals with demonstrated immunodeficiencies)1Convincingly Supportsa (in individuals with demonstrated immunodeficiencies)
Lacking (mumps or rubella)None
MMREncephalitisLimited3Weak3Inadequate
MMREncephalopathyLimited3Weak1Inadequate
MMRFebrile SeizuresHigh (increase)7Intermediate12Convincingly Supports
MMRAfebrile SeizuresLimited2LackingNoneInadequate
MMRMeningitisbModerate (null)3Weak (mumps)4Inadequate
Lacking (measles or rubella)None
MMRAtaxiaInsufficientNoneWeak (measles or mumps)1Inadequate
Lacking (rubella)None
MMRAutismHigh (null)4LackingNoneFavors Rejection
MMRAcute Disseminated EncephalomyelitisInsufficientNoneWeakNoneInadequate
MMRTransverse MyelitisInsufficientNoneWeak3Inadequate
MMROptic NeuritisbLimited1Weak2Inadequate
MMRNeuromyelitis OpticabInsufficientNoneWeak (rubella)1Inadequate
Lacking (measles or mumps)None
MMRMultiple Sclerosis Onset in AdultsLimited2LackingNoneInadequate
MMRMultiple Sclerosis Onset in ChildrenLimited1LackingNoneInadequate
MMRGuillain-Barré SyndromeInsufficientNoneWeakNoneInadequate
MMRChronic Inflammatory Disseminated PolyneuropathyInsufficientNoneLackingNoneInadequate
MMROpsoclonus Myoclonus SyndromeInsufficientNoneLackingNoneInadequate
MMRBrachial NeuritisInsufficientNoneLackingNoneInadequate
MMRAnaphylaxisInsufficientNoneStrong43cConvincingly Supports
MMRTransient Arthralgia in WomenModerate (increase) (rubella)4Intermediate (rubella)13Favors Acceptanced
Insufficient (measles or mumps)NoneLacking (measles or mumps)None
MMRTransient Arthralgia in ChildrenModerate (increase)7Weak (rubella)NoneFavors Acceptance
Lacking (measles or mumps)None
MMRChronic Arthralgia in WomenLimited (rubella)2Low-Intermediate (rubella)4Inadequate
Insufficient (measles or mumps)NoneLacking (measles or mumps)None
MMRChronic Arthritis in WomenLimited (rubella)2Low-Intermediate (rubella)5Inadequate
Insufficient (measles or mumps)NoneLacking (measles or mumps)None
MMRChronic Arthropathy in ChildrenInsufficientNoneWeak (rubella)2Inadequate
Lacking (measles or mumps)None
MMRArthropathy in MenLimited2Weak (rubella)NoneInadequate
Lacking (measles or mumps)None
MMRType 1 DiabetesHigh (null)5LackingNoneFavors Rejection
MMRHepatitisInsufficientNoneWeakNoneInadequate
MMRChronic Fatigue SyndromeInsufficientNoneLackingNoneInadequate
MMRFibromyalgiaInsufficientNoneLackingNoneInadequate
MMRHearing LossInsufficientNoneLow-Intermediate (measles or mumps)8Inadequate
Lacking (rubella)None
a

The committee attributes causation to the measles component of the vaccine.

b

Although not originally charged to the committee by the sponsor, the committee considered this adverse event in its review of the literature.

c

Some cases were from passive surveillance systems; however, it was not possible to know how many represented unique cases or were reported elsewhere.

d

The committee attributes causation to the rubella component of the vaccine.

From: 4, Measles, Mumps, and Rubella Vaccine

Cover of Adverse Effects of Vaccines
Adverse Effects of Vaccines: Evidence and Causality.
Committee to Review Adverse Effects of Vaccines; Institute of Medicine; Stratton K, Ford A, Rusch E, et al., editors.
Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2011 Aug 25.
Copyright 2012 by the National Academy of Sciences. All rights reserved.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.