Clinical Description
To date, more than 400 individuals with a deletion or pathogenic variant involving RAI1 have been reported [Edelman et al 2007, Vilboux et al 2011, Perkins et al 2017, Linders et al 2023]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with Smith-Magenis syndrome (SMS) is based on these reports.
SMS has a clinically recognizable phenotype that includes physical, developmental, and behavioral features (see Table 2). The phenotypic features can be subtle in infancy and early childhood, frequently delaying diagnosis until school age, when the characteristic facial appearance and behavioral manifestations may be more readily apparent.
Table 2.
Clinical Features of Smith-Magenis Syndrome
View in own window
| Frequency | System | Finding |
|---|
>75% of
individuals
|
Craniofacial/
Skeletal/
Growth
| Brachycephaly Midface retrusion Relative prognathism w/age Broad, square-shaped face Everted, "tented" vermilion of the upper lip Deep-set, close-spaced eyes Short broad hands Dental anomalies (missing premolars, taurodontism) Obesity (>90th centile for weight), w/abdominal fat deposition (esp after age 10 yrs)
|
|
Neurobehavioral
| Infantile hypotonia Generalized lethargy (infancy) Oral sensorimotor dysfunction (early childhood) Sensory processing issues Developmental delay / cognitive impairment Speech-language impairment Sleep disturbances & inverted circadian rhythm Attention-seeking behaviors Inattention ± hyperactivity Tantrums, behavioral dysregulation Impulsivity Stereotypic behaviors Self-injurious behaviors Hyporeflexia Signs of peripheral neuropathy
|
|
Otolaryngologic
|
|
Common
(50%-75% of
individuals)
| Short stature 1 (esp in those w/deletions; <10% in those w/RAI1 PVs) Scoliosis Mild ventriculomegaly on brain imaging Hyperacusis Tracheobronchial problems Velopharyngeal insufficiency Ocular abnormalities (strabismus, myopia, iris anomalies, &/or microcornea) REM sleep abnormalities Hypercholesterolemia/hypertriglyceridemia Chronic constipation Features of autism spectrum disorder Immune function abnormalities (esp low IgA)
|
Less common
(25%-50% of
individuals)
|
|
Occasional
(<25% of
individuals)
| Renal / urinary tract abnormalities EEG abnormalities (slowing, spikes) in absence of clinical seizures 1 (25%) Forearm abnormalities Cleft lip/palate Retinal detachment; keratoconus (adulthood) Dystonia
|
Based on Greenberg et al [1996], Chen et al [1997], Allanson et al [1999], Smith et al [2002], Potocki et al [2003], Gropman et al [2006], Smith et al [2006], Edelman et al [2007], Burns et al [2010], Perkins et al [2017], Smith & Gropman [2021]
- 1.
Frequency varies by study.
Facial Appearance
The facial appearance in SMS is characterized by a broad, square-shaped face, brachycephaly, prominent forehead, synophrys, mildly upslanted palpebral fissures, deep-set eyes, broad nasal bridge, midfacial retrusion (formerly known as midfacial hypoplasia), short, full-tipped nose with reduced nasal height, micrognathia in infancy changing to relative prognathia with age, and a distinct appearance of the mouth, with fleshy everted vermilion of the upper lip (see ).
The facial appearance in SMS becomes more recognizable in early childhood (see and ), with persisting midfacial retrusion, relative prognathism, and heavy brows with coarsening facial appearance.
Early school-age children with Smith-Magenis syndrome (SMS). Male age four years (left) and female age five years (right); the female is also pictured at age 15 years in Figure 3. Note broad forehead, deep-set eyes, and midface retrusion. Images courtesy (more...)
Neurologic Manifestations
Hypotonia is reported in virtually all infants, accompanied by hyporeflexia (84%) and generalized lethargy.
Clinical signs of peripheral neuropathy are seen in approximately 75% of individuals with SMS, regardless of the deletion size [Gropman et al 2006].
In infancy and early childhood, these include infantile hypotonia, hyporeflexia, relative insensitivity to pain, and mild intention tremor (6-8 Hz) of the upper extremities [
Gropman et al 2006].
In later childhood, affected children often exhibit a characteristic appearance of the legs and feet observed in peripheral nerve syndromes or neuropathies (i.e., "inverted champagne bottle appearance") with pes cavus or pes planus deformity and unusual broad-based gait (foot flap). This can cause pain and discomfort.
Some individuals with a large
deletion extending into
PMP22 may have insensitivity to pain, resulting in injuries that are not apparent to them. This is associated with recurrent acute focal sensory and motor neuropathies mainly at entrapment sites, painless nerve palsy after minor trauma or compression, and evidence on physical examination of previous nerve palsy such as focal weakness, atrophy, or sensory loss.
Toe walking (60%) may persist despite the absence of tight heel cords [Smith & Gropman 2021].
Microcephaly. Head circumference at birth is generally in the normal range with microcephaly developing over time [Gropman et al 2006].
Seizures. Seizures are reported in 11%-30% of individuals, and abnormal EEG without overt clinical seizures has been documented in 25% of individuals. Pubertal onset of catamenial seizures has also been observed in some females coinciding with menses [Merideth et al 2016, Smith & Gropman 2021]. Other seizure types have been reported but are not common in SMS, including tonic-clonic seizures [Maya et al 2014, Abad et al 2018] and absence seizures [Truong et al 2010].
One adult was reported to have a history of psychogenic seizures consisting of hyperventilation with tremors and a rapid pulse [Yeetong et al 2016]. Previous research has not found a correlation between the age of individuals with SMS and onset of seizures [Goldman et al 2006].
Stroke-like episodes have been reported in three individuals with SMS to date including:
A 10-year-old female with a ventricular septal defect who was also diagnosed with moyamoya disease and had evidence of ischemic changes at age five years [
Girirajan et al 2007];
A 32-year-old female with evidence of severe atherosclerotic disease of the intracranial vessels documented after she experienced an ischemic infarct postoperatively following repeat cardiac surgery [
Chaudhry et al 2007].
Neurodevelopmental Features
Developmental delays are evident in early childhood, with most individuals with SMS functioning in the mild-to-moderate range of intellectual disability. When reported, measured developmental or intelligence quotients range from 20 to 78, with a majority falling in the moderate range. Individuals with heterozygous deletions of 17p11.2 are more cognitively impaired than those with intragenic RAI1 pathogenic variants [Edelman et al 2007, Linders et al 2023]. Comprehensive literature review by Korteling et al [2024] found that many neuropsychiatric manifestations that commonly emerge in childhood and adolescence persist into adulthood, including mild-to-moderate intellectual disability, features related to autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and/or attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) (40%), self-injurious and physically aggressive behaviors (>50%), self-hugging behavior, circadian sleep-wake disorder, and seizures (20%).
Note: Due to the maladaptive behaviors and sleep deficits, cognitive functioning may not be accurately assessed in many individuals and test scores may be an underestimation of an individual's true cognitive capacity.
Gross and fine motor skills are delayed in the first year of life and may be exacerbated by generalized hypotonia. Issues related to sensory integration are frequently noted [Hildenbrand & Smith 2012].
Speech and language
In infancy, crying is infrequent and often hoarse.
Most infants show markedly decreased babbling and vocalization for age.
By age two to three years, significant expressive language deficits relative to receptive language skills are recognized [
Wolters et al 2009].
Analysis of data from the
PRISMS SMS Patient Registry revealed that 60% of individuals with SMS in the data set communicated verbally, 79% began speaking words at/after age 24 months, 92% combined words at/after age 36 months, and 41% used sign language before speech [
Brennan et al 2024].
With appropriate intervention and a total communication program that includes sign/gesture language and other augmentative communication approaches, verbal speech generally develops by school age; however, articulation problems usually persist. Speech intensity may be mildly elevated with a rapid rate and moderate explosiveness, accompanied by hypernasality and hoarse vocal quality.
A comparison of individuals with SMS with a 17p11.2
deletion had similar profiles related to speech-language milestones, mode of communication, intelligibility, vocal quality, language abilities, and literacy ability. Slight differences were found when communication profiles of individuals with SMS due to an
RAI pathogenic variant were compared to those with a deletion. Specifically, individuals with a deletion had slightly more pronounced speech delay and a lower percentage for verbal communication with lower reading abilities [
Brennan & Baiduc 2024].
Communication strengths noted in more than 40% of individuals with SMS included social interest, humor, and memory for people, past events, and/or facts [
Brennan et al 2024].
Cognitive abilities
Affected individuals typically have relative weaknesses observed in sequential processing and short-term memory [
Dykens et al 1997].
Relative strengths include long-term memory and perceptual closure (i.e., a process whereby an incomplete visual stimulus is perceived to be complete: "parts of a whole") [
Dykens et al 1997,
Udwin et al 2001].
Behavioral Manifestations
The behavioral manifestations of SMS, which includes sleep, maladaptive and self-injurious behaviors (SIB), and stereotypies, is generally not recognized until age 18 months or older and escalates with age, often coinciding with expected life cycle stages: 18-24 months, school age, and onset of puberty [Gropman et al 2006].
Maladaptive behaviors in people with SMS reflect a complex interplay between physiology and environment that may be further compounded by an underlying developmental asynchrony; specifically, emotional maturity is delayed relative to intellectual functioning [Finucane & Haas-Givler 2009].
With age, the gap between intellectual attainment and emotional development appears to widen for many people with SMS, and this disparity poses significant behavioral and programmatic challenges in older children and adults [
Haas-Givler & Finucane 2014]. For example, adults with SMS may exhibit academic achievement at the 6- to 8-year-old level while emotional reactions are more reflective of the developmental level of a 1- to 3-year-old (i.e., referred to as the "inner toddler").
One study found that 90% of individuals with SMS (ages 4 and 18 years) demonstrated significant social impairment (35% in the mild-to-moderate range and 55% in the severe range per the Social Responsiveness Scale) per parent report, with manifestations that overlapped those of children with ASD or other developmental disorders [
Laje et al 2010b].
A large-scale investigation of children and adults with SMS (ages 4 to 30 years) and six other genetic syndromes associated with intellectual or learning disabilities reported high levels of autistic features on the Social Responsiveness Scale, 2nd edition (SRS-2), a parent report measure [
Lee et al 2022]. Of the autism subdomains investigated, the Restricted Interests and Repetitive Behavior scale was the most impacted. The SMS group received a higher score on this scale than the six other genetic syndromes studied. It was also the highest score received of the five SRS-2 scales within SMS group. When examining scores on the social scales of the SRS-2 among SMS participants only, parents reported the lowest level of concern on the Social Motivation scale and intermediate concerns on the Social Communication, Cognition, and Awareness scales.
Self-injurious behaviors (SIB) are present in most individuals after age two years [Arron et al 2011, Sloneem et al 2011].
Note: Given the high rates of SIB, including self-insertion of objects or digits into body orifices, caution must be taken when evaluating individuals with SMS for maltreatment or abuse. Although individuals with intellectual disability are at high risk for maltreatment, abuse may also be incorrectly suspected due to SIB or self-insertion behaviors.
Sensory integration issues are present and persist throughout childhood. A prominent pattern of sensory processing difficulties is recognized, characterized by an imbalance in neurologic thresholds and a fluctuation between active and passive self-regulation [Hildenbrand & Smith 2012].
Other maladaptive behaviors may include the following:
Head banging, which may begin as early as age 18 months
Frequent outbursts / temper tantrums
Attention-seeking behaviors (especially from adults)
Impulsivity, which may increase over time, particularly in females [
Martin et al 2006]
Inattention with or without hyperactivity
Oppositional behaviors
Aggression
Rapid mood shifts
Anxiety, which can become a significant issue in adolescence and adulthood
Toileting difficulties
Stereotypies common to SMS include the following:
The spasmodic upper body squeeze or "self-hug" behavior, which may provide an effective clinical diagnostic marker for the syndrome [
Finucane et al 1994]
Mouthing of hands or objects, which persists from early childhood to ages where this is not socially acceptable
Teeth grinding
Vocal stereotypies, "crickets" sound (comforting, self-regulating)
Body rocking
Spinning or twirling objects
Sleep disturbances. The abnormal diurnal (inverted) circadian rhythm of melatonin appears pathognomonic in SMS and is documented in more than 90% of affected individuals with studied profiles [Potocki et al 2000b, De Leersnyder et al 2001, Boudreau et al 2009, Chik et al 2010, Boone et al 2011, Nováková et al 2012]. Further studies suggest that sleep disturbances cannot be caused solely by aberrant melatonin synthesis and/or degradation as previously suggested [Boudreau et al 2009]. While not inverted, the 24-hour circadian rhythm of body temperature is phase advanced by about three hours relative to controls [Smith et al 2019].
Sleep disturbances are characterized by fragmented and shortened sleep cycles with frequent nocturnal and early morning awakenings and excessive daytime sleepiness [Greenberg et al 1996, Smith et al 1998, Potocki et al 2000b, De Leersnyder et al 2001, Smith & Duncan 2005].
Growth and Feeding
At birth, weight, length, and head circumference are generally in the normal range.
Feeding difficulties in infancy leading to failure to thrive are common, including marked oral motor dysfunction with poor suck and swallow and textural aversion.
In early infancy, length and weight gradually decelerate; short stature (height <5th centile) is frequently observed (67%), especially at young ages, but may not persist into adulthood.
Dietary preferences, hyperphagia, and food foraging at night (especially at older ages), coupled with a general sedentary lifestyle and psychotropic medication side effects (affecting appetite / weight gain), contribute to obesity (increased BMI), typically beginning in school-age children (age 6-9 years) [Gandhi et al 2022, Elatrash et al 2024, Lazareva et al 2024].
Hyperlipidemia. Hypercholesterolemia that is not associated with diet or BMI values is recognized in more than 50% of individuals with SMS [Smith et al 2002]. In a pediatric study of 49 individuals with SMS caused by a deletion of 17p11.2 younger than age 18 years, one third had total cholesterol (TC) or low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol in the borderline range, and more than one third had values in the high range. Fewer than one third had normal values for all three variables (TC, LDL, triglycerides) [Smith et al 2002]. In an older Italian SMS group (mean age 13.9 years) [Cipolla et al 2023], TC and LDL cholesterol were high in 20% of individuals and 63% had low HDL cholesterol. Dyslipidemia was not documented in individuals with RAI1 pathogenic variants.
Gastrointestinal
Gastroesophageal reflux and constipation are frequently reported.
Oral and Dental Anomalies
Oral sensorimotor dysfunction is a significant issue, including the following:
Lingual weakness, asymmetry, and/or limited mobility
Weak bilabial seal (64%)
Palate abnormalities (64%), although cleft lip and/or palate occur in fewer than 25% of affected individuals
Open-mouth posture with tongue protrusion and frequent drooling
A high prevalence (~90%) of dental anomalies, specifically tooth agenesis (especially premolars) and taurodontism, has been reported. This is accompanied by an age-related increase in dental caries and poor gingival health due to decreased oral hygiene, supporting the need for increased dental care in adolescent years [Tomona et al 2006].
Musculoskeletal Manifestations
Mild-to-moderate scoliosis, most commonly of the mid-thoracic region, is seen in approximately 60% of affected individuals age four years and older, although vertebral anomalies are seen in only a few to date.
A tethered cord has been reported in three individuals with RAI1 deletions at ages four, eight, and 34 years, respectively [Wigby & Reiner 2024].
Hands and feet are usually small for age.
Markedly flat or highly arched feet and unusual gait are generally observed.
Ocular Abnormalities
Ocular abnormalities are present in approximately 85% of affected individuals and include strabismus, progressive myopia, iris anomalies, and/or microcornea. About 20% of affected individuals older than age ten years experience retinal detachment, which may be due to a combination of aggressive/self-injurious behaviors and high myopia. Adults may experience keratoconus and glaucoma.
Ears and Hearing
Otitis media occurs frequently (≥3 episodes/year) and often leads to tympanostomy tube placement (85%).
Hearing loss is documented in more than 79% of affected individuals [Brendal et al 2017], with conductive loss most common before age ten years.
A pattern of fluctuating and progressive hearing decline occurs with age, including sensorineural hearing loss (48%) after age 11 years [Brendal et al 2017].
Hyperacusis, or oversensitivity to certain frequencies/sounds tolerable to listeners with normal hearing, is reported in approximately 74% [Brendal et al 2017].
Laryngeal Anomalies
Laryngeal anomalies, including polyps, nodules, edema, or partial vocal cord paralysis, are common.
Velopharyngeal insufficiency and/or structural vocal fold abnormalities without reported vocal hyperfunction are seen in most individuals with SMS.
Functional impairments in voice (hoarseness) may contribute to the marked delays in expressive speech.
Cardiovascular Defects
Cardiovascular defects are identified in fewer than 50% of affected individuals with SMS who have a deletion of 17p11.2. Congenital heart defects remain rare among individuals with SMS due to heterozygous pathogenic RAI1 variants, with only a single reported infant born with severe congenital pulmonary valve stenosis to date [Onesimo et al 2022]. Cardiac anomalies may include mild tricuspid or mitral valve stenosis or regurgitation, ventricular septal defects, supravalvular aortic or pulmonic stenosis, atrial septal defects, tetralogy of Fallot, and total anomalous pulmonary venous connection [Onesimo et al 2021, Smith & Gropman 2021].
Genitourinary Anomalies
Genitourinary anomalies are found in 15%-35% of affected individuals who have a deletion of 17p11.2 but have not been reported in those who have a heterozygous pathogenic variant in RAI1. Anomalies may include the following [Smith et al 1986, Greenberg et al 1996, Chou et al 2002, Myers et al 2007]:
Duplicated collecting renal system
Unilateral renal agenesis and ectopic kidney
Ureterovesical obstruction
Malposition of the ureterovesical junction
Additionally, the majority of affected individuals have nocturnal enuresis in childhood. Genital anomalies reported include cryptorchidism, shawl, or undeveloped scrotum in males, and infantile cervix and/or hypoplastic uterus in females [Smith & Gropman 2021].
Immunologic Manifestations
More than 50% of affected individuals have low serum immunoglobulin (Ig) profiles, which may increase susceptibility to sinopulmonary infections. A systematic study of serum Ig profiles (IgA, IgG, IgM) in a large cohort (age 4-27 years) documented diminished immunologic function in most affected individuals (60%). Recurrent otitis media (88%), upper respiratory infections (61%), pneumonia (47%), and/or sinusitis (42%) requiring antibiotics are frequently reported [Perkins et al 2017].
Endocrine
The specific incidence of endocrine abnormalities in individuals with SMS remains undefined.
About 25% of affected individuals have mild hypothyroidism.
Puberty typically occurs within the normal time frame; however, precocious puberty (premature adrenarche), premature ovarian failure [A Smith, personal observation], and delayed sexual maturation have been observed.
Adrenal aplasia/hypoplasia was described in one affected male infant who died unexpectedly after palatoplasty [
Denny et al 1992].
Dermatologic Manifestations
In addition to skin problems due to self-injurious behaviors, a minority of affected individuals have rosy cheeks (which may be related to drooling and/or eczema) and/or hyperkeratosis (~20%) over the hands, feet, or knees.
Malignancy and Other Features of Birt-Hogg-Dubé Syndrome (BHDS)
The risk of cancer appears to be no greater than in the general population for most individuals with SMS. However, SMS due to a heterozygous 17p11.2 deletion often results in haploinsufficiency of FLCN, which is associated with BHDS, an adult-onset hereditary cancer syndrome characterized by cutaneous fibrofolliculomas, pulmonary cysts, spontaneous pneumothorax, and renal tumors.
Individuals with SMS due to a deletion that contains FLCN have an increased chance of developing BHDS, but the diagnosis should never be made in children or adults who show no evidence of features. One hit (an SMS deletion) does not mean that a person has or ever will develop the clinical features of BHDS.
Features of BHDS have been described in several individuals with SMS [Vocke et al 2023]:
Neuroimaging Abnormalities
The most common structural brain abnormalities identified on imaging are non-specific and include ventriculomegaly and cortical atrophy. Also reported are enlarged posterior fossa, periventricular gray matter heterotopia, and decreased grey matter in the insula and lenticular nucleus [Greenberg et al 1996, Boddaert et al 2004]. In addition, heterotopias and thin corpus callosum have been reported in several individuals [Capra et al 2014, Maya et al 2014].
Co-occurrence of moyamoya disease and SMS has been reported in an individual with a large deletion of 17p11.2 [Girirajan et al 2007].
Neuropathologic Abnormalities
Foreshortened frontal lobes with a choroid plexus hemangioma have been reported on neuropathologic examination [Smith et al 1986].
Prognosis
Insufficient longitudinal data are available to accurately determine life expectancy. One would expect that in the absence of major organ involvement the life expectancy of individuals with SMS would not differ from that of individuals with intellectual disability at large. Anecdotally, the oldest known individual with SMS lived to age 88 years [A Smith & E Magenis, unpublished data]. In the month prior to her death, she was reportedly her usual alert, happy, "SMS" self with ongoing sleep issues and was being treated for chronic recurrent sinusitis. Four days prior to death, she suffered an apparent right-sided stroke with left-sided weakness. No autopsy was performed.
Recurrence of SMS in two sibs, a 37-year-old male and his older 54-year-old sister, with deletion of 17p11.2 due to gonadal mosaicism and transmission from their 79-year-old mosaic mother (62% mosaicism in lymphocytes), has been reported [Smith et al 2006]. The brother, who died at age 45 years from aggressive B-cell lymphoma, showed postmortem central nervous system white matter findings in addition to unsuspected BHDS with chromophobe renal cell carcinoma and a confirmed second FLCN pathogenic variant [Smith et al 2006, Vocke et al 2023]. The mother, cognitively normal in her youth, had a medical history significant for behavior/emotional problems and aggressive mood swings, obesity, idiopathic thrombocytopenia, hysterectomy for uterine cancer at age 42 years, cholecystectomy at age 69 years, adult-onset diabetes from age 77 years, and early-onset dementia accompanied by explosive behaviors at age 79 years. She died at age 85 years from an intraventricular hemorrhage. Brain histopathology showed significant white matter atrophy and degenerative Alzheimer disease.