Clinical Description
Niemann-Pick disease type C (NPC) is a slowly progressive lysosomal disorder whose principal manifestations are age dependent. The manifestations in the perinatal period and infancy are predominantly visceral, with hepatosplenomegaly, cholestatic jaundice, and (in some instances) pulmonary infiltrates. From late infancy onward, the presentation is dominated by neurologic manifestations. The youngest children may present with hypotonia and developmental delay, with the subsequent emergence of ataxia, dysarthria, dysphagia, and (in some individuals) epileptic seizures, dystonia, and gelastic cataplexy. Although cognitive impairment may be subtle at first, it eventually becomes apparent that affected individuals have progressive dementia. Older teenagers and young adults may present predominantly with apparent early-onset dementia or psychiatric manifestations; however, detailed examination usually identifies typical neurologic signs.
Table 2.
Niemann-Pick Disease Type C: Comparison of Age-Related Phenotypes by Select Features
View in own window
| Feature | Phenotypes by Age of Onset |
|---|
Visceral neurodegenerative | Neurodegenerative | Psychiatric neurodegenerative |
|---|
Early infantile (age <2 yrs) | Late infantile (2 to <6 yrs) | Juvenile (6 to <15 yrs) | Adult (>15 yrs) |
|---|
| Hepatomegaly | ● | | | |
| Splenomegaly | | ● | ● | (●) |
| Ataxia | | ● | ● | ● |
| Epilepsy | | ● | ● | (●) |
| Cataplexy | | (●) | ● | ● |
| Dementia | | | (●) | ● |
| Psychiatric | | | (●) | ● |
| Dystonia | | (●) | ● | ● |
| VSSP | (●) | ● | ● | ● |
| VSGP | | (●) | ● | ● |
VSGP = vertical supranuclear gaze palsy; VSSP = vertical supranuclear saccadic palsy
(●) = sometimes present; ● = usually present
Neonatal and Infantile Presentations
The presentation of NPC in early life is typically nonspecific and may go unrecognized by inexperienced clinicians. However, on occasion ultrasound examination in late pregnancy detects fetal ascites and newborns thus identified typically have severe neonatal liver disease with cholestatic jaundice, persistent ascites, and organomegaly.
López de Frutos et al [2021] reported five neonates with NPC who presented with neonatal cholestasis and organomegaly. Subsequently, in a retrospective study of 34 children with NPC and early liver involvement, Gardin et al [2023] found that all had hepatomegaly at initial evaluation, 33 had splenomegaly, and 30 had cholestasis. Serum alpha-fetoprotein was elevated in 17/21. Four children died by age six months; cholestasis regressed in all who survived after age six months.
Infiltration of the lungs with foam cells may accompany neonatal liver disease or occur as a primary presenting feature (pulmonary failure secondary to impaired gas exchange).
Many infants succumb at this stage. Of those who survive, some are hypotonic and delayed in psychomotor development, whereas others may have complete resolution of disease manifestations, only to present with neurologic disease many years later. Liver and spleen are enlarged in children with symptomatic hepatic disease; however, children who survive often "grow into their organs," so that organomegaly may not be detectable later in childhood. Indeed, many individuals with NPC never have organomegaly.
Another subgroup of children has minimal or absent hepatic or pulmonary dysfunction and presents primarily with hypotonia and delayed development. Children in this group might develop vertical supranuclear saccade palsy (VSSP) or even vertical supranuclear gaze palsy (VSGP), but this is only apparent if actively searched for by the clinician [Bremova & Strupp 2017, Bremova-Ertl et al 2021]. Children compensate for the oculomotor deficits with blinks and head / upper body movements that represent a diagnostic clue for this disease.
Childhood Presentations
The classic presentation of NPC is in mid- to late childhood, with clumsiness and gait disturbance that eventually become frank ataxia. Many observant parents are aware of impaired vertical saccades, which is an early manifestation. VSSP first manifests as decreased velocity of vertical saccades, gradually slowing down and eventually lost, resulting in restricted range of vertical eye movements, or VSGP. "Around-the-house" sign (i.e., rolling eye movements while performing vertical saccades) can occur [Eggink et al 2016]. In late stages of the illness, horizontal saccades are also impaired. These physical manifestations are accompanied by insidiously progressive cognitive impairment, often mistaken at first for simple learning disability. Some children are thought to have primary behavioral disturbances, reflecting unrecognized dyspraxia in some instances. As the disease progresses, it becomes clear that the child is mentally deteriorating.
In addition to the manifestations above, many children develop dystonia, typically beginning as action dystonia in one limb that gradually spreads to involve all limbs and axial muscles. Speech gradually deteriorates, with a mixed dysarthria and dysphonia. Dysphagia progresses in parallel with the dysarthria, and oral feeding eventually becomes impossible.
Approximately one third of individuals with NPC have partial and/or generalized seizures. Epilepsy may be refractory to medical therapy in some. Seizures usually improve if the child's survival is prolonged; this improvement presumably reflects continued neuronal loss. About 20% of children with NPC have gelastic cataplexy, a sudden loss of muscle tone evoked by a strong emotional (humorous) stimulus. This can be highly disabling in those children who experience daily multiple attacks, during which injuries may occur, and can progress into narcolepsy [Madan et al 2021, Leppmeier et al 2022].
Mild demyelinating peripheral neuropathy has been described in a child with otherwise typical late-infantile NPC [Zafeiriou et al 2003]. This finding is likely a rare manifestation of NPC; prospective nerve conduction studies in a cohort of 41 affected individuals participating in a clinical trial of miglustat identified two individuals with peripheral neuropathy. One adult in the miglustat group had worsening of peripheral neuropathy, not considered to be treatment related; and one individual in the standard care group exhibited the neurophysiologic changes of peripheral neuropathy [Patterson et al 2007]. Subsequently, only a single instance of peripheral neuropathy in a 42-month-old girl with NPC with areflexia and abnormal nerve conduction studies has been reported; however, explicit biochemical and molecular data were not included [Barzegar et al 2022].
Death from aspiration pneumonia usually occurs in the late second or third decade [Walterfang et al 2012b].
Adolescent and Adult Presentations
Adolescents or adults may present with neurologic disease like that in childhood, albeit with a much slower rate of progression. One individual survived into the seventh decade, having first developed manifestations 25 years earlier [M Patterson, personal observation].
Older individuals may also present with apparent psychiatric illness [Imrie et al 2002, Josephs et al 2003], sometimes appearing to have major depression or schizophrenia. The psychiatric manifestations may overshadow neurologic signs, although the latter can usually be detected with detailed examination.
Nineteen adults with NPC exhibited behavioral (15/17) and cognitive disorders (18/19) that included executive dysfunction (11/12), apathy (13/17), impaired social cognition (11/13), and stereotyped behaviors (5/10). Psychotic manifestations were often drug resistant (8/9); however, improvement in psychotic manifestations has been reported in individuals treated with miglustat [
Morin et al 2023].
A 59-year-old man presenting with asymmetric parkinsonism and dementia was initially suspected to have corticobasal degeneration before proven to have NPC [
Balázs et al 2019].
An individual presenting with features of progressive supranuclear palsy at age 61 years and another with parkinsonism at age 68 years were subsequently diagnosed with NPC [
Wu et al 2020], as was a 67-year-old female with a five-year history of progressive walking and balance difficulties with near-fall episodes [
Sousa et al 2024].
Other Studies
Imaging. MRI of the brain is usually normal until the late stages of the illness, when marked atrophy of the superior/anterior cerebellar vermis, thinning of the corpus callosum, and mild cerebral atrophy may be seen. Increased signal in the periatrial white matter, reflecting secondary demyelination, may also be observed. In one adult, areas of confluent white matter signal hyperintensity mimicked multiple sclerosis [Grau et al 1997].
Quantitative MRI studies in adults have found widespread gray and white matter abnormalities [Walterfang et al 2010] and reduction in callosal volume as the disease progresses [Walterfang et al 2011]. In addition, the pontine-to-midbrain ratio correlates with oculomotor function and disease severity [Walterfang et al 2012a].
A study of 16 adults with NPC found that the choline (Cho)-to-N-acetylaspartate (NAA) ratio in the centrum ovale on proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (H-MRS) correlated with disease progression, and that both responded in parallel to treatment with miglustat [Sedel et al 2016]. These findings were reinforced by a study of 12 juvenile and adult individuals with NPC in which H-MRS showed reduction in NAA-to-creatine (Cr) resonance intensity and an increase in the choline and lipid signals that correlated with signal hyperintensities in the white matter [Guo et al 2018].
In a case-control study in nine individuals with NPC, PET scanning utilizing a ligand-binding activated microglia suggested that neuroinflammation – particularly in white matter – was driving the neurodegenerative process [Walterfang et al 2020].
Heterozygotes
Josephs et al [2004] attributed tremor in an individual to presence of a heterozygous NPC1 pathogenic variant.
More recently, a study of 20 obligate heterozygotes for an NPC1 pathogenic variant found varying manifestations typically seen in compound heterozygotes (i.e., individuals with biallelic pathogenic variants), including hepatosplenomegaly, increased cholestane-3β,5α,6β-triol levels, hyposmia, REM sleep behavior disorder, and typical oculomotor abnormalities [Bremova-Ertl et al 2020].
In contrast, three large studies did not find an association between the frequency of a heterozygous NPC1 pathogenic variant in individuals with neurodegenerative disease that included Parkinson disease, frontotemporal lobar degeneration, progressive supranuclear palsy, REM sleep behavior disorder, and dementia with Lewy bodies [Zech et al 2013, Ouled Amar Bencheikh et al 2020, Somerville et al 2023].
Nomenclature
The older literature on NPC is bedeviled by the large number of terms used to describe individuals now known to have the disease. These include juvenile dystonic idiocy, juvenile dystonic lipidosis, juvenile NPC, neurovisceral lipidosis with vertical supranuclear gaze palsy, Neville-lake disease, sea-blue histiocytosis, lactosylceramidosis, and DAF (downgaze paralysis, ataxia, foam cells) syndrome.
The term Niemann-Pick disease type D describes a genetic isolate from Nova Scotia that is biochemically and clinically indistinguishable from NPC and that also results from biallelic pathogenic variants in NPC1.
The terms Niemann-Pick disease type C1 (NPC1) and Niemann-Pick disease type C2 (NPC2) are now preferred because they correspond with the associated genes (NPC1 and NPC2).
Prevalence
The prevalence of NPC has been estimated at 1:150,000 in Western Europe.
The incidence of NPC in France has been calculated at about 1:120,000, based on the number of individuals diagnosed postnatally in a ten-year period versus the number of births during the same period. When pregnancies that did not result in a live-born infant were included, a slightly higher incidence of 1:100,000 was found [Vanier 2010].
The prevalence of NPC in the United States was estimated at 2.9 in one million, based on assumption of underdiagnosis and misdiagnosis [Burton et al 2021].
A study in Quebec, Canda, reported a prevalence of 0.61 in 100,000 births [Labrecque et al 2021].
The prevalence of NPC in childhood is probably underestimated, owing to the nonspecific presentations in that age group. The overall prevalence is likely higher than the calculated incidence, owing to relatively prolonged survival in those with later-onset disease, although no comprehensive data are available.
Genetic isolates with NPC1 founder variants include Acadians in Nova Scotia and a Bedouin group in Israel (see Table 9).