Crit Care. 2006;10(5):232.

Evidence-based medicine: classifying the evidence from clinical trials--the need to consider other dimensions.

Source

Department of Intensive Care, Austin Hospital, Studley Rd, Heidelberg, Victoria 3084, Australia. rinaldo.bellomo@austin.org.au

Abstract

The current approach to assessing the quality of evidence obtained from clinical trials focuses on three dimensions: the quality of the design (with double-blinded randomised controlled trials representing the highest level of such design); the statistical power (beta) and the level of significance (alpha). While these aspects are important, we argue that other significant aspects of trial quality impinge upon the truthfulness of the findings: biological plausibility, reproducibility and generalisability. We present several recent studies in critical care medicine where the design, beta and alpha components of the study are seemingly satisfactory but where the aspects of biological plausibility, reproducibility and generalisability show serious limitations. Accordingly, we argue for more reflection, definition and consensus on these aspects of the evaluation of evidence.

PMID:: 17029653; [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
PMCID:: PMC1751050

Free PMC Article

Publication Types, MeSH Terms

Publication Types

MeSH Terms

LinkOut - more resources

Full Text Sources

Supplemental Content

Save items

Related citations in PubMed

The need to reform our assessment of evidence from clinical trials: a commentary. [Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2008]
The need to reform our assessment of evidence from clinical trials: a commentary.
Bagshaw SM, Bellomo R. Philos Ethics Humanit Med. 2008 Sep 30; 3:23. Epub 2008 Sep 30.
[Controlled randomized clinical trials]. [Bull Acad Natl Med. 2007]
[Controlled randomized clinical trials].
Jaillon P. Bull Acad Natl Med. 2007 Apr-May; 191(4-5):739-56; discussion 756-8.
Review Randomised controlled trials in orthopaedic surgery and traumatology: overview of parameters and pitfalls. [Injury. 2008]
Review Randomised controlled trials in orthopaedic surgery and traumatology: overview of parameters and pitfalls.
Soucacos PN, Johnson EO, Babis G. Injury. 2008 Jun; 39(6):636-42.
Review Evidence-based medicine, systematic reviews, and guidelines in interventional pain management: Part 2: Randomized controlled trials. [Pain Physician. 2008]
Review Evidence-based medicine, systematic reviews, and guidelines in interventional pain management: Part 2: Randomized controlled trials.
Manchikanti L, Hirsch JA, Smith HS. Pain Physician. 2008 Nov-Dec; 11(6):717-73.
Review How to perform a critical analysis of a randomised controlled trial. [Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol....]
Review How to perform a critical analysis of a randomised controlled trial.
Estellat C, Torgerson DJ, Ravaud P. Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol. 2009 Apr; 23(2):291-303.

See reviews... See all...

Cited by 4 PubMed Central articles

Review Self-medication of migraine and tension-type headache: summary of the evidence-based recommendations of the Deutsche Migräne und Kopfschmerzgesellschaft (DMKG), the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Neurologie (DGN), the Österreichische Kopfschmerzgesellschaft (ÖKSG) and the Schweizerische Kopfwehgesellschaft (SKG). [J Headache Pain. 2011]
Review Self-medication of migraine and tension-type headache: summary of the evidence-based recommendations of the Deutsche Migräne und Kopfschmerzgesellschaft (DMKG), the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Neurologie (DGN), the Österreichische Kopfschmerzgesellschaft (ÖKSG) and the Schweizerische Kopfwehgesellschaft (SKG).
Haag G, Diener HC, May A, Meyer C, Morck H, Straube A, Wessely P, Evers S, DMKG, DGN, et al. J Headache Pain. 2011 Apr; 12(2):201-17. Epub 2010 Dec 23.
Automatic colorimetric calibration of human wounds. [BMC Med Imaging. 2010]
Automatic colorimetric calibration of human wounds.
Van Poucke S, Haeghen YV, Vissers K, Meert T, Jorens P. BMC Med Imaging. 2010 Mar 18; 10:7. Epub 2010 Mar 18.
Extending an evidence hierarchy to include topics other than treatment: revising the Australian 'levels of evidence'. [BMC Med Res Methodol. 2009]
Extending an evidence hierarchy to include topics other than treatment: revising the Australian 'levels of evidence'.
Merlin T, Weston A, Tooher R. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2009 Jun 11; 9:34. Epub 2009 Jun 11.

See all...

Related information

Related Citations
Calculated set of PubMed citations closely related to the selected article(s) retrieved using a word weight algorithm. Related articles are displayed in ranked order from most to least relevant, with the “linked from” citation displayed first.
References for this PMC Article
Citation referenced in PubMed article. Only valid for PubMed citations that are also in PMC.
Free in PMC
Free full text articles in PMC
Cited in PMC
Full-text articles in the PubMed Central Database that cite the current articles.

Recent activity

Clear Turn Off Turn On

Evidence-based medicine: classifying the evidence from clinical trials--the need...
Evidence-based medicine: classifying the evidence from clinical trials--the need to consider other dimensions.
Crit Care. 2006 ;10(5):232.

PubMed
Endogenous nitric oxide release required for long-term synaptic depression in th...
Endogenous nitric oxide release required for long-term synaptic depression in the cerebellum.
Nature. 1991 Jan 24 ;349(6307):326-8.

PubMed
Intensive care unit-acquired Stenotrophomonas maltophilia: incidence, risk facto...
Intensive care unit-acquired Stenotrophomonas maltophilia: incidence, risk factors, and outcome.
Crit Care. 2006 ;10(5):R143.

PubMed
cAMP and human neutrophil chemotaxis. Elevation of cAMP differentially affects c...
cAMP and human neutrophil chemotaxis. Elevation of cAMP differentially affects chemotactic responsiveness.
J Immunol. 1991 Jan 1 ;146(1):224-32.

PubMed
Regulation of vascular nitric oxide in vitro and in vivo; a new role for endogen...
Regulation of vascular nitric oxide in vitro and in vivo; a new role for endogenous hydrogen sulphide?
Br J Pharmacol. 2006 Nov ;149(6):625-34. Epub 2006 Oct 3 .

PubMed

Your browsing activity is empty.

Activity recording is turned off.

Turn recording back on

PubMed

Result Filters

Display Settings:

Send to:

Evidence-based medicine: classifying the evidence from clinical trials--the need to consider other dimensions.

Source

Abstract

Publication Types, MeSH Terms

Publication Types

MeSH Terms

LinkOut - more resources

Full Text Sources

Other Literature Sources

Education

Libraries

Supplemental Content

Save items

Related citations in PubMed

Cited by 4 PubMed Central articles

Related information

Recent activity

Simple NCBI Directory

Getting Started

Resources

Popular

Featured

NCBI Information