Table F-1Quality Assesment of RCTs

Author YearJadad Q-1Jadad Q-2Jadad Q-3Jadad Q-4Jadad Q-5Total ScoresAllocation Concealment
Palmer 20001 100102Unclear
Seidman 20012 101114Unclear
Kongkanand 20033 101114Unclear
Stuckey 20034 111115Adequate
Choi 20035 101114Unclear
Levinson 20036 101013Unclear
DeBusk 20047 111014Unclear
Boolell 19968 101013Unclear
Goldstein 19989 101114Unclear
Tan 200010 101114Unclear
Meuleman 200111 101114Unclear
Eardley 200112 1-11102Unclear
Young 200213 101103Unclear
von Keitz 200214 1-11012Unclear
Goldstein 200315 101013Unclear
Nurnberg 200316 111115Adequate
Incrocci 200317 101013Unclear
Hellstrom 200318 111014Adequate
Price 199819 101013Unclear
Rendell 199920 111115Adequate
Christiansen 200021 111115Adequate
Olsson 200022 101013Unclear
Chen 200123 101114Unclear
Boulton 200124 101103Unclear
Hussain 200125 10100Unclear
Lewis 200126 101002Unclear
Brock 200227 100012Unclear
Porst 200328 101002Unclear
Montorsi 200429 101012Unclear
Safarinejad 200430 111014Adequate
Webster 200431 1-11012Unclear
Giuliano 200532 1-11001Unclear
Hatzichristou 200533 1-11002Unclear
Eardley 200534 100012Unclear
Cavallini 200535 1-11113Unclear
Diamond 200536 101013Unclear
Hellstrom 200537 101002Unclear
Melman 200538 000000Unclear
Valiquette 200539 101013Unclear
Shabsigh 200540 101002Unclear
Ardicoglu 200541 000000Unclear
Melnik 200542 110013Adequate
Seyam 200543 100012Unclear
Mirone 200544 100012Unclear
Nehra 200545 111014Unclear
Young 200546 1-11001Unclear
McMahon 200547 111115Unclear
Fowler 200548 111104Adequate
Haren 200549 111104Unclear
Carson 200550 101013Unclear
Mahon 200551 101103Unclear
Rosano 200552 101114Unclear
Kirby 200553 101114Unclear
De Rose 200554 110013Adequate
Gontero 200555 111115Adequate
Katz 200556 111014Unclear
Carson 200450 1-11114Unclear
Fonseca 200457 101002Unclear
Wheatley 200458 111104Adequate
Abdel-Naser 200459 100012Unclear
Parsons 200460 111003Inadequate
Deveci 200461 101002Unclear
Seftel 200462 100001Inadequate
Eardley 200463 100001Unclear
Gentile 200464 1-11002Unclear
Staab 200465 1-11113Adequate
Montorsi 200466 101103Unclear
Skoumal 200467 111115Unclear
Rosen 200468 1-11012Unclear
Shabsigh 200469 101103Unclear
Seftel 200470 111115Unclear
Nagao 200471 1-11113Adequate
Perimenis 200472 1-11-111Unclear
Tignol 200473 100001Unclear
Perimenis 200474 111115Unclear
Carson 200475 110013Unclear
Eardley 200476 101013Unclear
Stief 200477 110002Unclear
Hatzichristou 200478 101114Unclear
Cavallini 200479 111115Adequate
Rosen 200480 110002Adequate
von Keitz 200481 101103Unclear
Leder 200482 101114Unclear
Diamond 200483 111003Unclear
Mancini 200484 101103Unclear
Perimenis 200485 101013Unclear
Govier 200386 1-10001Unclear
Fox 200387 100012Unclear
Brock 200388 1-11012Unclear
Padma-Nathan 200389 101103Unclear
Hellstrom 200390 111115Adequate
Montorsi 200391 101114Unclear
Porst 200392 1-10011Unclear
Boyanov 200393 101002Unclear
Anderson 200394 111115Unclear
Steidle 200395 100012Unclear
Gontero 200396 110013Unclear
Aversa 200397 1-10000Unclear
Hagemann 200398 100001Unclear
Montorsi 200399 100001Unclear
McNicholas 2003100 100001Unclear
Padma-Nathan 2003101 101002Unclear
Harding 2002102 1-11002Unclear
Steidle 2002103 101002Unclear
Thadani 2002104 101013Unclear
Saenz, I 2002105 111003Inadequate
Hellstrom 2002106 101013Unclear
Seibel 2002107 101013Unclear
Bocchi 2002108 101013Unclear
Ugarte 2002109 111014Adequate
Gomez 2002110 111115Adequate
Becher 2002111 101013Unclear
Glina 2002112 100001Unclear
Schanz 2002113 101114Unclear
Padma-Nathan 2002114 101013Unclear
Lebret 2002115 101103Unclear
Lindsey 2002116 000000Unclear
Lim 2002117 000011Unclear
van der Windt 2002118 111003Unclear
Kunelius 2002119 111115Unclear
Lammers 2002120 101114Unclear
De Rose 2002121 100012Unclear
Eardley 2002122 111115Inadequate
Hatzichristou 2001123 101002Unclear
Incrocci 2001124 110013Adequate
Stark 2001125 101114Unclear
Choppin 2001126 001113Unclear
Porst 2001127 101013Unclear
Mann 2001128 101002Unclear
Dula 2001129 100001Unclear
Safarinejad 2001130 101114Unclear
Gomaa 2001131 101013Unclear
Olsson 2001132 101002Unclear
Padma-Nathan 2001133 101002Unclear
Klotz 2001134 101103Adequate
Goldstein 2001135 101002Unclear
Kloner 2001136 101002Unclear
Fu 2000137 101002Unclear
Montorsi 2000138 1-11113Unclear
Enzlin 2000139 101002Unclear
Baum 2000140 100001Unclear
Wessells 2000141 101114Unclear
Cappelleri 2000142 101013Unclear
Ekman 2000143 100001Unclear
Dula 2000 144 101013Unclear
Rabkin 2000145 101002Unclear
Shabsigh 2000146 100001Unclear
Anderson 1999147 101114Unclear
Palmer 1999148 111115Adequate
Shokeir 1999149 110002Unclear
Le Roux 1999150 100012Unclear
Sandhu 1999151 101114Unclear
Costabile 1999152 100012Unclear
Dinsmore 1999153 101114Adequate
Chen 1999154 101002Unclear
Montorsi 1999155 111003Unclear
Dinsmore 1999156 101002Unclear
Gramkow 1999157 101013Unclear
Klotz 1999158 101114Unclear
Eardley 1999159 101103Unclear
Hartmann 1999160 101002Unclear
Feldman 1999161 1-10001Unclear
Young 1999162 101002Unclear
Padma-Nathan 1998163 101013Unclear
Williams 1998164 101002Unclear
Foldvari 1998165 101002Unclear
Costabile 1998166 101114Unclear
Williams 1998167 1-11001Unclear
Engel 1998168 101103Unclear
Peterson 1998169 101002Unclear
Becker 1998170 1-11002Unclear
Buvat 1998171 101002Unclear
Montorsi 1998172 101002Unclear
Sogari 1997173 101013Unclear
Meinhardt 1997174 101114Unclear
Vogt 1997175 100001Unclear
Montorsi 1997176 100001Unclear
Soderdahl 1997177 101114Unclear
Schiavi 1997178 101013Unclear
Bechara 1997179 100001Unclear
Kunelius 1997180 1-10000Unclear
Rowland 1997181 101002Unclear
Padma-Nathan 1997182 101013Unclear
Aversa 1996183 101002Unclear
Hellstrom 1996184 001102Adequate
Colli 1996185 101013Unclear
Godschalk 1996186 100001Unclear
Mann 1996187 101002Unclear
Gheorghiu 1996188 101003Unclear
Peskircioglu 1996189 111014Unclear
Gomaa 1996190 101013Unclear
Linet 1996191 101002Unclear
Bechara 1996192 100001Unclear
Knoll 1996193 101002Unclear
Wegner 1995194 101114Unclear
van Ahlen 1995195 100001Unclear
Guay 1995196 100001Unclear
Vanderschueren 1995197 111104Unclear
Georgitis 1995198 101013Unclear
el-Saleh 1995199 111104Unclear
Ogrinc 1995200 101002Unclear
Kattan 1995201 101002Unclear
Martinez-Pineiro 1995202 110002Unclear
Cavallini 1994203 101002Unclear
Lazzeri 1994204 101114Unclear
Wegner 1994205 100001Unclear
Montorsi 1994206 111003Unclear
Schramek 1994207 100001Unclear
Kurt 1994208 1-10001Unclear
Godschalk 1994209 101114Adequate
Brennemann 1993210 101103Unclear
von Heyden 1993211 101013Unclear
Moriel 1993212 101013Unclear
Porst 1993213 1-11113Unclear
Korenman 1993214 100001Unclear
Costa 1993215 101103Unclear
Allen 1992216 100001Unclear
Mahmoud 1992217 101002Unclear
Cavallini 1991218 111014Unclear
Kattan 1991219 111-102Unclear
Segraves 1991220 101002Unclear
Floth 1991221 111003Unclear
Sonda 1990222 101103Unclear
Roy 1990223 101103Unclear
Earle 1990224 100001Unclear
van Ahlen 2005225 001113Unclear
Goldstein 2005226 101013Unclear
Fisher 2005227 1-10000Unclear
Carrier 2005228 101114Unclear
Moncada 2005229 111115Unclear
Hatzichristou 2005230 111115Unclear
Patterson 2005231 1-11113Unclear
Albuquerque 2005232 100001Unclear
Yonessi 2005233 101013Unclear
Shamloul 2005234 101114Unclear
McMahon 2005235 111115Unclear
Speel 2005236 111003Unclear
Chen 2004237 100001Unclear
Rosen 2004238 110013Unclear
Donatucci 2004239 100012Unclear
Gingell 2004240 111014Unclear
Montorsi 2004241 1-11013Unclear
Pickering 2004242 1-11002Unclear
Pavone 2004243 101-113Unclear
Bawa 2004244 1-11113Unclear
Petrov 2003245 101013Unclear
Dunzendorfer 2002246 100012Unclear
Glina 2001247 101002Unclear
Giammusso 1996248 100012Unclear
Garceau 1996249 100001Unclear
Claes 1992250 101114Unclear
Valiquette 2005251 101002Unclear
Reiter 1999252 101002Unclear
Kunelius 1998253 101002Unclear
Haslam 1992254 111003Unclear
Rosen 2006255 110014Unclear
Korenman 1994256 1-11001Unclear
Clopper 1993257 101114Unclear
Wang 2000258 101103Unclear
Nickel 2007259 101103Unclear
Yassin 2006260 100001Unclear
Martin-Morales 2007261 101013Unclear
Heiman 2007262 101102Unclear
Bank 2006263 100012Unclear
McVary 2007264 101002Unclear
Saylan 2006265 111014Inadequate
Zinner 2007266 101103Unclear
Edwards 2006267 101013Unclear
Rajfer 2007268 101013Unclear
Valiquette 2006269 101002Unclear
Wespes 2007270 101013Unclear
Porst 2006271 101013Unclear
Yip 2006272 101103Unclear
Safarinejad 2006273 100001Unclear
Agostini 2006274 101013Unclear
Mazo 2006275 101013Unclear
El-Shafey 2006276
Tolra 2006277 101103Unclear
Ziegler 2006278 101002Unclear
Ishii 2006279 101002Unclear
Guo 2006280 100012Unclear
Nagao 2006281 101114Unclear
Padma-Nathan 2006282 101114Unclear
Dean 2006283 101013Unclear
Seidman 2006284 101013Unclear
Demir 2006285 111003Unclear
Althof 2006286 100001Unclear
Buvat 2006287 100012Unclear
McMahon 2006288 100001Unclear
Fava 2006289 101013Unclear
Gopalakrishnan 2006290 100001Unclear
Herrmann 2006291 111014Unclear
Titta 2006292 111014Unclear
Sommer 2006293 111115Inadequate
Rochira 2006294 101103Unclear
O'Leary 2006295 100001Unclear
Viswaroop 2005296 101002Unclear
Carson 2005297 100001Unclear
Kaplan 2007298 111003Unclear
Choi 2006299 110002Unclear
Gomaa 2006300 101002Unclear

From: Appendix F. Quality Assessment

Cover of Diagnosis and Treatment of Erectile Dysfunction
Diagnosis and Treatment of Erectile Dysfunction.
Evidence Reports/Technology Assessments, No. 171.
Tsertsvadze A, Yazdi F, Fink HA, et al.

PubMed Health. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.