We recently demonstrated that Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 undergoes a pronounced phenotypic change when introduced into the intestines of rats during surgical injury. Recovered strains displayed a specific phenotype (termed the P2 phenotype) characterized by altered pyocyanin production, high collagenase activity, high swarming motility, low resistance to chloramphenicol, and increased killing of Caenorhabditis elegans compared to the inoculating strain (termed the P1 phenotype). The aims of this study were to characterize the differences between the P. aeruginosa P1 and P2 phenotypes in quorum sensing and competitiveness. We then determined the presence of the P2 phenotype among PAO1 strains from various laboratories. Results demonstrated that P2 cells display accelerated growth during early exponential phase and early activation of quorum-sensing systems and overcome the growth of P1 cells in a mixed population. Among eight PAO1 strains obtained from different laboratories, four exhibited the P2 phenotype. Of 27 mutants analyzed from the P. aeruginosa MPAO1 transposon library, 25 displayed P2 phenotypes. The P2 phenotype in both cases correlated with a lack of expression of mexE or mexF due to mutations in mexT and mexF genes. In summary, strains possessing the P2 phenotype are distributed among PAO1 strains commonly used across a variety of research laboratories. Genetically, they are characterized by various mutations in mexT or mexF.