Better specificity and less ischemia: three-dimensional reconstruction is superior to routine computed tomography angiography in navigation of super-selective clamping robot-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy

Background: Available technologies could be used to guide surgeons in controlling highly selective tumor-bearing arteries robot-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy (RALPN).

Methods: Patients undergoing RALPN (from September 2018 to January 2020) for intermediate-high complex renal tumor (R.E.N.A.L. score ≥7) who underwent abdominal computed tomography (CT) scan with angiography and hyper-accuracy 3-dimensional reconstruction (H3DR). All patients underwent high-resolution CT scan with angiography and H3DR with special software, based on which two kinds of highly selective arterial clamp protocols were made for each patient and analyzed independently by two urologists and two radiologists to confirm which renal arterial branch was supplying the tumor. We chose the optimized clamping protocol with the principle of the minimized ischemic regions. During the operation, meticulous microdissection and clip ligation of the specific vascular branch was guided by optimized protocol [H3DR or computed tomography angiography (CTA) reconstruction], according to the in vivo anatomy (identified by intraoperative ultrasound).

Results: Of 82 patients, the minimum-ischemic regions planning completed rate (MIRPCR) of preoperative planning with H3DR (90.2%) was higher than that with CTA (34.1%) (P<0.01). H3DR identified 78 high-order arteries (70.3%), whereas CTA identified 33 (29.7%) high-order arteries (P<0.001). H3DR detected a more optimal blocking option in 51 cases that were either missed (n=13) or misclassified by CTA (n=38). A total of 18 cases (56.3%) were converted to H3DR-guided occurred in CTA-guided surgery [5 (10.0%) occurred in group H3DR to CTA, P<0.01]. Moreover, in the CTA-guided group, the separation of renal hilum was avoided in 14 of 19 (73.7%) cases, whereas in the H3DR-guided group, it was avoided in 60 of 63 (95.3%) cases.

Conclusions: For patients undergoing RALPN, H3DR-guided surgery compared with standard CTA-guided surgery has higher accuracy and feasibility in controlling arterial branches supplying the tumor and intraoperative surgical navigation. Additionally, it reduces the ischemic lesion area and simplifies vascular isolation steps, thus decreasing procedural difficulty.