Targeting Antibiotic Resistance Genes Is a Better Approach to Block Acquisition of Antibiotic Resistance Than Blocking Conjugal Transfer by Recipient Cells: A Genome-Wide Screening in Escherichia coli

The conjugal transfer is a major driving force in the spread of antibiotic resistance genes. Nevertheless, an effective approach has not yet been developed to target conjugal transfer to prevent the acquisition of antibiotic resistance by this mechanism. This study aimed to identify potential targets for plasmid transfer blockade by isolating mutants defective in the completion of the acquisition of antibiotic resistance via conjugal transfer. We performed genome-wide screening by combining an IncP1α-type broad host range plasmid conjugation system with a comprehensive collection of Escherichia coli gene knockout mutants (Keio collection; 3884 mutants). We followed a six-step screening procedure to identify the mutants showing conjugation deficiency precisely. No mutants defective in the conjugal transfer were isolated, strongly suggesting that E. coli cannot escape from being a recipient organism for P1α plasmid transfer. However, several mutants with low viability were identified, as well as mutants defective in establishing resistance to chloramphenicol, which was used for transconjugant selection. These results suggest that developing drugs capable of inhibiting the establishment of antibiotic resistance is a better approach than attempting to prevent the conjugal transfer to block the spread of antibiotic resistance genes. Our screening system based on the IncP1α-type plasmid transfer can be extended to isolation of target genes for other drugs. This study could be the foundation for further research to understand its underlying molecular mechanism through functional analysis of the identified genes.