Reconstruction of full thickness, total upper eyelid defects represents a significant challenge in terms of recreating an upper eyelid which has acceptable cosmesis and a degree of dynamic function. Options include bridging, eyelid-sharing techniques (e.g., Cutler-Beard), or nonbridging techniques such as an anterior lamella-based flap combined with a posterior lamella free graft or a "sandwich flap." The success of these techniques depends on the size of the defect, postoperative cosmesis and whether or not the upper eyelid still has a degree of dynamic function to avoid ptosis and exposure keratopathy. The authors present an innervated frontalis turnover flap supporting anterior and posterior lamella grafts as a reconstructive solution for an extensive upper eyelid defect. This technique is cosmetically acceptable, preserves local tissues, and maintains a degree of dynamic function, which keeps the patient's eye comfortable and does not adversely affect visual acuity.