Abstract

We studied the mechanical, metabolic, and histologic properties of short-term nonvascularized cortical bone grafts in a canine fibular graft model. Sham operated nonvascularized autotransplanted and allotransplanted bones were compared. The allografts were performed between dog leukocyte antigen (DLA) class I and II matched; DLA class I and II mismatched; and cyclosporin A (CsA) treated, DLA class I and II mismatched animals. Cyclosporin was given for 1 month, and all the animals were followed for 3 months after surgery. Mechanical properties were investigated using standard torsional tests, metabolic kinetics were assessed using isotopic prelabeling techniques, and histomorphometric analysis of cross-sectional area properties and sequential fluorochrome labels were performed. Autografts were mechanically stronger and stiffer than all the types of allograft. CsA-treated, DLA-mismatched allografts performed better than matched allografts. These in turn were stronger than non-CsA-treated, mismatched allografts, which underwent nearly complete resorption. These relationships were preserved in the metabolic and histologic analyses. In this short-term animal study, although DLA matching resulted in a slight improvement in graft outcome, mismatched grafts in dogs receiving a short course of cyclosporin A fared even better.