RNase H2 Is Absent from Rnaseh2b−/−;p53−/− MEFs; Quantitative Estimation of Ribonucleotide Levels in Genomic DNA, Related to Figure 5
(A) All three RNase H2 subunits are absent from MEFs derived from Rnaseh2b−/−;p53−/− embryos, as shown by immunoblotting. Loading control, Actin.
(B) Whereas RNase H2 activity is reduced in Rnaseh2b+/−;p53−/− MEFs (+/−), substrate cleavage is not detected in two independent Rnaseh2b−/−;p53−/− lines (−/−), within the sensitivity of the assay. Error bars represent SEM of technical triplicates.
(C) PolyADPribosylation is increased in RNaseH2null MEFs. Immunoblot probed with α-PAR antibody. PolyADPribosylation occurs on a large number of proteins in response to DNA damage, but auto-PARylation of PARP1 predominates (Satoh and Lindahl, 1992). ‘+/+, +/−, −/− and −/−’ correspond to 4 independent MEF cell lines. ‘+HU’, RNaseh2b+/+ MEFs treated with 300 μM hydroxyurea for 48 hr as a positive control. Immunoblot representative of 4 independent experiments. Densitometry of immunoblots confirmed that compared to the +/+ control polyADPribosylation was significantly increased in both −/− lines (n = 4, paired t test, p < 0.05 and p = 0.001 respectively for −/− lines; for the ‘+/−’ line, the p-value was not significant).
(D) Untreated total nucleic acids purified from MEFs and yolk sacks (E9.5 or E10.5) separated by agarose gel electrophoresis.
(E) Genomic DNA from E9.5 RNaseH2null yolk sacks is cleaved by RNase H2, but not RNase HI, showing accumulation of incorporated mono or di-ribonucleotides. Treated nucleic acids were denatured in 90% formamide and separated by agarose gel electrophoresis.
(F) Quantification of ribonucleotide incorporation rates: estimation by analytical methodology and simulation studies. (i-iii) Gel background intensity was uniformly subtracted from all raw densitometry distributions of electrophoresed alkali-digested genomic DNA (i). The distributions were transformed to nucleotide size (iii) on the basis of a DNA calibration curve derived from size standard ladders (ii) and a spline with 40 degrees of freedom used to produce a smoothed distribution. (iv) Analytical estimate: Histograms of fragment counts per nucleotide length were fitted to the smoothed distributions. These were modeled on the basis of a linear relationship between staining intensity and nucleotide content. Nucleotide number was scaled to 109 per distribution. From these resulting histograms (iv) an analytical estimate for additional fragmentation in mutant (‘−/−’, orange) versus control DNA (here, ‘+/−’, blue) was obtained, by subtracting fragment count of control from that of mutant. Overall, this resulted in an estimate of 1 ribonucleotide every 7,600 nucleotides in RNaseH2null MEFs (1 in 7.6 ± 0.8 kb; SD, n = 4, biological replicates compared to +/+ and +/− controls). Transforming the x axis to a log scale (v) allows the fragment count distributions to be viewed as areas under the curve, the excess area of the −/− relative to the +/− curve is proportional to the number of additional fragments the Rnaseh2b−/− genome is hydrolyzed into, as also shown in Figures 5E and 6F. (vi) To explore the spatial distribution of incorporated ribonucleotides, a simulation study was performed in which the control distribution (solid blue) was transformed by random fragmentation, and a best-fit (dotted green) to the mutant distribution (solid orange) obtained. This simulation was broadly consistent with cleavage at random positions, however given that the fit is not exact it remains conceivable that ribonucleotide incorporation is in part non-random. The random cut simulation provided a frequency estimate of 1 in 6,100 nucleotides. The analytic estimate of 1 in 7.6 ± 0.8 kb (SD) is supported by experimental results that showed a site frequency between 1 in 3.7 and 11 kb (Figure 5F, G and Figure S4H) and a similar simulation result. As the mouse haploid genome contains ∼2.5x109 bp (Waterston et al., 2002), each diploid nucleus contains 1010 nucleotides of DNA. Thus with a ribonucleotide frequency of 1 in 7.6 kb; in excess of 1.3 million ribonucleotide sites would be expected per replicating cell in the absence of RNase H2 activity.
(G) Quantification of DNA fragmentation pattern calculated from densitometry traces shown in Figure 5G. Fragment counts normalized so that total nucleotide number is equal between samples.