We are sorry, but NCBI web applications do not support your browser and may not function properly. More information

Lancet. 2010 Nov 13;376(9753):1658-69. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(10)60310-8. Epub 2010 Nov 8.

Intensive lowering of LDL cholesterol with 80 mg versus 20 mg simvastatin daily in 12,064 survivors of myocardial infarction: a double-blind randomised trial.

Study of the Effectiveness of Additional Reductions in Cholesterol and Homocysteine (SEARCH) Collaborative Group, Armitage J, Bowman L, Wallendszus K, Bulbulia R, Rahimi K, Haynes R, Parish S, Peto R, Collins R.

Collaborators (650)

Meade T, Sleight P, Collins R, Armitage J, Bowman L, Parish S, Peto R, Barton J, Bray C, Wincott E, Dayanandan R, Clarke R, Graham I, Simpson D, Warlow C, Wilken D, Tobert J, Musliner T, Doll R, Wilhelmsen L, Fox K, Hill C, Sandercock P, Webster J, Henderson J, Nixon A, Lackie S, Thompson J, Brown M, Blackwood S, Morgan M, Rhoden W, Saeed B, Houghton M, Nicholson A, Simpson C, Hoburn B, Cooper I, Gallivan A, Pickerell E, Hancock J, Watkinson J, Ryder B, Jones S, Burbridge W, Kitchen M, O'Leary H, Verow C, Meynell L, Rollinson L, Bain S, Jones A, Jewkes C, Russon C, Bateson M, Gill P, Nicol J, Bayly G, Stansbie D, Andrews G, Halestrap M, Meredith J, Best R, Appleyard D, Brigg R, Wareing H, Holmes K, Holt J, Kenyon M, White C, Khalifa M, Newton D, Wass A, Watkinson R, Creamer J, Anderson S, Bethell A, Butler C, Castro K, Washington M, Weston M, Cleaver K, Machin J, Wray R, Sinclair J, Van Aalst A, Been M, Mattu R, Bates D, Burke A, Gill L, Walton E, Cowley M, Robson H, Graham A, Rose G, Kerr M, Mallinson J, Peascod B, Donnelly R, Kalk J, Scott A, Gibson T, Hannah J, Henshaw L, Margetts M, Pearson N, Frost S, Murray S, Marshall A, Went J, Inman A, Simmonds J, Teasdale A, Kemp T, Roberts G, Kooner J, Cahill S, Lloyd M, Molloy O, Wigley J, Galvin M, Wilder C, Lindley R, Shaw S, Swainson C, Hillis L, Johnston J, Johnstone A, Miller D, Kennedy M, Mushahwar S, Savage M, Appleyard D, Ayer G, Schofield J, Greenhalgh S, Parks J, Speak S, Coulson C, Papouchado M, Carpenter R, Wisby J, Cobbe S, Campbell C, Hunter J, Young H, Gallacher M, Lindsay D, Halliday A, Godfrey S, O'Donahoo L, Chambers J, Wierzbicki A, Jones A, Parkin D, Nwafor K, Oldroyd K, Vallance B, Cunningham N, Moreland G, Oldroyd C, Young H, Crawford M, Hillson R, Knott K, Mahabir N, Crouch A, MacDonald Y, Bellamy C, Green J, Brown L, Heron J, Jones N, Roberts M, Hainsworth D, Williams J, Barnes P, Fitchet A, Longworth C, Davidson J, Irvine N, Oliver R, Pond C, Nuttall M, Lloyd-Mostyn R, Brown M, Barrowcliffe J, Blackburn S, Furnell W, Webster S, Wheatley L, Hudson I, Pohl J, Nicholson S, Mallya S, Nash M, Spruce J, Bonner A, Leather J, Searle A, Davies E, Egdell R, Price B, Bennett AT, Horton S, Cunnington A, Giles P, Sidaway J, Tomlinson L, Walton E, Hawkins L, Long J, Murphy J, Brennan G, Boon M, Cassidy S, Rodger C, Hunter J, McNeilly A, Moreland G, Radcliffe A, Farrer M, Bluett J, Cowell L, Farrell A, Gilroy S, Warren S, MacConnell T, Burtchaell S, Williams L, Rylance P, Hodgson A, Kertland-Hill K, Robinson L, Smallwood A, Lomas S, Ball J, Benbow S, Hardy K, Gerrard M, Langley C, Beattie M, Fagan C, Green B, Pringle T, Hanna H, Mackintosh A, Watson E, Swan J, Appleyard D, McSorland D, Thompson G, O'Neill C, Curless R, Doig C, McKenna P, Martin J, Murdy J, Scott A, Martin S, Birkhead J, O'Donnell J, Fox C, Dixon S, Hassall A, Tanqueray E, Vass D, Cosford I, Elderkin M, McKenzie P, Gray T, Appleyard D, Holmshaw N, McKinnon A, Taylor-Bennett A, Ali I, Stephens N, Banfield A, Chester L, Wiseman J, Harrisingh N, Patel R, Thaker P, Armitage J, Watkins H, Beebe S, Fitzgerald J, Godden J, Lawson A, Lochhead H, Taylor A, Turner S, Rowlands D, Cooper A, Graham J, Hennessy S, Rashid T, Smith C, Nyman C, Adams J, Hardwick A, Buck P, Pattinson C, Trigg J, McLeod A, Gardner S, Haimes L, Orr S, Johns S, Capps N, Cook A, Donaldson D, Keighley C, Stiles C, Asbridge S, Buller N, Townend J, Hooks J, Jewkes C, Jones H, Watson R, Salt P, Francis M, MacLeod D, Allcoat P, Stuart R, Reynolds T, Maiden J, Reynolds J, Murray D, MacFadyen R, Potts L, Smith A, King L, Muthusamy R, Jones M, Lawan M, Nixon J, Wasnidge L, Weston C, Hutchesson A, Evans J, Morris K, Oultram M, Armitage M, Skule R, Cope C, Page M, Fleming S, Andain K, Parrett M, Soper R, MacLeod K, Gordon K, Green E, Havill S, Stewart V, Allen S, Henson S, Rimmer C, Davies J, Javed M, Norris A, Williams M, Khan S, Dobie G, Fitton J, Gilbert S, Davenport C, Williamson M, Vincent R, Joyce E, Reckless J, Bishop A, Brice L, Carpenter R, Field P, Shute C, Pope S, Stacey D, Findlay I, Campbell C, Hunter J, Gallacher M, Labib M, Hodgson A, Sidaway J, Beddoe L, Reed J, Barron J, Odemuyiwa O, Bradford B, McDonnell M, West L, Beck P, Gilbey S, Clarkson A, Drury K, Hall S, Quartey D, Whittam B, Lund D, Stott L, Griffiths H, Appleyard D, Fitzgerald J, Kudarenko A, Watkins J, Golledge S, Pottle J, Little S, Paine B, Shears C, Baxter M, Wilkinson P, Chambers R, Hamper C, Hollister E, Ramsay H, Barber J, Hopkins T, Hughes L, Elson-Whittaker J, Verow C, Lambley-Burke R, Lloyd C, Dhawan J, John J, Bramley D, Catchpole A, Colecchia A, Gray C, LeQuelenec M, Remington D, Wiseman J, Gray C, Anderson P, Woolass R, Thomas P, Weston C, Guy F, Lynch J, Thomas R, Coates S, Gait M, Waller D, Elkins K, Franklin M, Moore L, Signy M, Chilton R, Joyce E, Wrapson C, Wiltshire C, Lewis P, Curtis J, O'Toole J, Scanlon S, Carey C, Dobson L, Gould M, Mansfield H, Ranson G, Rodaway M, Germon J, Cockcroft J, McDowell I, Field R, Whiting J, Dennison C, Roberts D, Cooper M, Davies C, Fitton J, Hutt L, Radford L, Ward L, Williamson M, McAlpine H, Dougall H, Robertson L, Scott L, Young H, Humphrey P, Saminaden S, Watling D, Davies J, Owen L, Clements M, Walker E, Atkins E, Lindley R, Shaw T, Swainson C, Webb D, MacCallum H, Markie D, Melville V, Adamson L, Johnston A, Polukord E, Rudden M, Hogan J, Lie F, Badger V, Duffy S, Mitchell C, MacQueen E, Baxter R, Campbell S, McDonald L, Wood H, Munro A, Pycock C, Cadwell J, Doughty A, Harvey M, Price S, Aldersley M, Lock S, Pendrey P, Barton J, Bray C, Dayanandan R, Wincott E, Achiri P, Anderson C, Benham J, Bojowsky H, Boller I, Booker V, Brewer A, Brindley G, Cobb L, Collett A, Corbett M, Crowther J, Danesh-Pour S, Edmunds K, Fortun A, Grimsey T, Harwood C, Hope C, Jones R, Jones S, Kidney K, King M, Knight S, Lang H, Madgwick Z, Marsden C, Matthews C, Matthewson M, Miller J, Moss B, Mostefai Y, Murphy K, Naughten A, Pickworth S, Radley A, Southren S, Sutherland S, Tong R, Turakani M, Umbrath M, Armitage J, Baigent C, Bowman L, Bulbulia R, Chen Z, Clarke R, Collins R, Dunachie S, Dasgupta T, Haynes R, Landray M, Mafham M, Majoni W, Murray C, Naessens K, Porter T, Rahimi K, Reith C, Taylor-Clarke M, Turnbull C, Walter K, Harding P, Lay M, Wallendszus K, Berry C, Bettesworth H, Booth J, Bowes M, Bu Y, Charles A, Cody A, Cox J, Emberson J, Goodwin N, Hurt C, Link E, McCabe P, Munday A, Murawska A, Offer A, Palmer A, Parish S, Peto R, Prajapati N, Tochlin S, Young A, Young A, Clark S, Kourellias K, Radley M, Ambrose V, Bradley M, Bush E, Chavagnon T, Chukwurah B, Crowley S, Dunseath J, Emmens K, Fletcher L, Gordon J, Gordon A, Hickman C, Hill J, Ji M, Lee A, Lee N, Norris S, Priestley H, Sullivan J, Taylor J, Wintour J, Yeung M, Youngman L, Beebe S, Fitzgerald J, Godden J, Haimes L, Lawson A, Lochhead H, McDonnell M, Nash M, Taylor A, Taylor-Bennett A, Walton E.

Source

SEARCH Study, Clinical Trial Service Unit and Epidemiological Studies Unit, Richard Doll Building, Old Road Campus, Roosevelt Drive, Oxford OX3 7LF, UK.

Erratum in

Lancet. 2011 Jan 8;377(9760):126.

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Lowering of LDL cholesterol reduces major vascular events, but whether more intensive therapy safely produces extra benefits is uncertain. We aimed to establish efficacy and safety of more intensive statin treatment in patients at high cardiovascular risk.

METHODS:

We undertook a double-blind randomised trial in 12,064 men and women aged 18-80 years with a history of myocardial infarction. Participants were either currently on or had clear indication for statin therapy, and had a total cholesterol concentration of at least 3·5 mmol/L if already on a statin or 4·5 mmol/L if not. Randomisation to either 80 mg or 20 mg simvastatin daily was done centrally using a minimisation algorithm. Participants were assessed at 2, 4, 8, and 12 months after randomisation and then every 6 months until final follow-up. The primary endpoint was major vascular events, defined as coronary death, myocardial infarction, stroke, or arterial revascularisation. Analysis was by intention to treat. This study is registered, number ISRCTN74348595.

FINDINGS:

6031 participants were allocated 80 mg simvastatin daily, and 6033 allocated 20 mg simvastatin daily. During a mean follow-up of 6·7 (SD 1·5) years, allocation to 80 mg simvastatin produced an average 0·35 (SE 0·01) mmol/L greater reduction in LDL cholesterol compared with allocation to 20 mg. Major vascular events occurred in 1477 (24·5%) participants allocated 80 mg simvastatin versus 1553 (25·7%) of those allocated 20 mg, corresponding to a 6% proportional reduction (risk ratio 0·94, 95% CI 0·88-1·01; p=0·10). There were no apparent differences in numbers of haemorrhagic strokes (24 [0·4%] vs 25 [0·4%]) or deaths attributed to vascular (565 [9·4%] vs 572 [9·5%]) or non-vascular (399 [6·6%] vs 398 [6·6%]) causes. Compared with two (0·03%) cases of myopathy in patients taking 20 mg simvastatin daily, there were 53 (0·9%) cases in the 80 mg group.

INTERPRETATION:

The 6% (SE 3·5%) reduction in major vascular events with a further 0·35 mmol/L reduction in LDL cholesterol in our trial is consistent with previous trials. Myopathy was increased with 80 mg simvastatin daily, but intensive lowering of LDL cholesterol can be achieved safely with other regimens.

FUNDING:

Merck; The Clinical Trial Service Unit also receives funding from the UK Medical Research Council and the British Heart Foundation.

Comment in

Is intensive LDL-cholesterol lowering beneficial and safe? [Lancet. 2010]
Is intensive LDL-cholesterol lowering beneficial and safe?Cheung BM, Lam KS. Lancet. 2010 Nov 13; 376(9753):1622-4. Epub 2010 Nov 8.