Shown are fitness measurements (OD600, mean and standard error, normalized to the progenitor value) for 48 offspring fully genotyped for all coding alleles identified by sequencing – from each of the crosses S2 × P (A, C, 5 loci) and S6 × P (B, D, 3 loci). Data are aggregated by specific alleles as marked (in each marked category, e.g. “PMA1–2”, the other alleles are segregating). Full data (including intergenic loci) are available in Tables S3 and S4. (A, B). The bars represent the average fitness effect of each variant across all offspring. Light gray bars, ancestral alleles; dark bars, evolved alleles. Fitness of evolved parent is shown at the upper right corner. Significant differences are noted with P-value. (C, D) Average pair-wise effects of the two most advantageous mutations in each strain. Shown are the same data as in A and B, but averaged for two-locus genotypes showing positive interaction. Superscript a = ancestral allele; superscript e = evolved allele. Interaction was tested by ANOVA; all P values appear in Table S8.