Immune responses leading to antibody-mediated elimination of the transgenic protein are a concern in gene replacement for congenital protein deficiencies, for which hemophilia is an important model. Although most hemophilia B patients have circulating non-functional but immunologically crossreactive factor IX (FIX) protein (CRM+ phenotype), inciting factors for FIX neutralizing antibody (inhibitor) development have been studied in crossreactive material-negative (CRM-) animal models. For this study, determinants of FIX inhibitor development were compared in hemophilia B mice, in which circulating FIX protein is absent (CRM- factor IX knockout (FIXKO) model) or present (CRM+ missense R333Q-hFIX model) modeling multiple potential therapies. The investigations compare for the first time different serotypes of adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors (AAV2 and AAV1), each at multiple doses, in the setting of two different FIX mutations. The comparisons demonstrate in the FIXKO background (CRM- phenotype) that neither vector serotype nor vector particle number independently determine the inhibitor trigger, which is influenced primarily by the level and kinetics of transgene expression. In the CRM+ missense background, inhibitor development was never stimulated by AAV gene therapy or protein therapy, despite the persistence of lymphocytes capable of responding to FIX with non-inhibitory antibodies. This genotype/phenotype is strongly protective against antibody formation in response to FIX therapy.