Objective: Cognitive deficits are common in adults following surgery utilizing cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB). A previous retrospective study suggested that surgical closure of an ASD in children was associated with neurologic injury, while transcather therapy was not. In a prospective study, we sought to determine whether neurologic deficits occur following repair of non-complex congenital heart lesions in school-age children and young adults.
Methods: Inclusion criteria were: age between 5 and 20 years, cardiac surgery utilizing CPB without deep hypothermic circulatory arrest, and no prior cardiac surgery. Patients underwent psychometric testing 1-3 days prior to surgery and re-evaluation 7-18 days after surgery. In order to determine the test/re-test effect an age-matched cohort of children undergoing transcather closure of ASD under general anesthesia was also evaluated. The primary outcome measures were verbal and picture memory. Additional psychometric tests included: computerized performance test (CPT) and Digit Span (DS). Forty-one patients were enrolled, 29 undergoing surgery with CPB and 12 controls. Surgical procedures included ASD closure (n=13), VSD closure (n=10), resection of sub-aortic stenosis (n=3), mitral valvuloplasty (n=3). Mild hypothermia was used in all cases. The mean duration of CPB was 54+/-22 min.
Results: There was no significant difference in any of the psychometric test scores between subjects undergoing surgery with CPB or controls.
Conclusions: There are no marked adverse neurologic effects of CPB in school-age children and young adults undergoing non-complex open-heart surgery. These data are important in counseling patients and families and should be considered in the debate as to the relative merits of transcather versus open-heart repair of various heart lesions.