In contrast to the wild-type MoFe protein, neither the alpha-195(Asn) nor the alpha-191(Lys) MoFe protein catalyzed N(2) reduction to NH(3), when complemented with wild-type Fe protein. However, N(2) was bound by the alpha-195(Asn) MoFe protein and inhibited the reduction of both protons and C(2)H(2). The alpha-191(Lys) MoFe protein did not interact with N(2). With the alpha-195(Asn) MoFe protein, the N(2)-induced inhibition of substrate reduction was reversed by removing the N(2). Surprisingly, even though added H(2) also relieved N(2) inhibition of substrate reduction, the alpha-195(Asn) MoFe protein did not catalyze HD formation under a N(2)/D(2) atmosphere. This observation is the first indication that these two reactions have different chemical origins, prompting a revision of the current hypothesis that these two reactions are consequences of the same nitrogenase chemistry. A rationale that accounts for the dichotomy of the two reactions is presented. The two altered MoFe proteins also responded quite differently to azide. It was a poor substrate for both but, in addition, azide was an electron-flux inhibitor with the 195(Asn) MoFe protein. The observed reactivity changes are correlated with likely structural changes caused by the amino acid substitutions and provide important details about the interaction(s) of N(2,) H(2), D(2), and azide with Mo-nitrogenase.