In this issue, Barbui and colleagues¹ report the results of a meta-analysis of 8 large-scale observational studies that compared the risk of suicide among patients with depression who received SSRIs and those with no exposure to antidepressants. In contrast to the results reported from a meta-analysis performed by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which concluded that there was a neutral effect of SSRIs on the risk of suicide among adults aged 25–64 years, Barbui and colleagues report a protective effect of SSRIs in this age group. Furthermore, although the FDA concluded that there was increased risk of suicidality associated with the use of antidepressants among youth aged 18–24 years and extended the “black-box” warning for use of antidepressants to this age group, Barbui and colleagues found a beneficial effect. Of interest, a study by Gibbons and colleagues,² which was included in the analysis by Barbui and colleagues, included a large sample of patients with major depression from Veterans' Affairs centres. This study specifically examined the effect of SSRIs in patients aged 18–25 years. Gibbons and colleagues found a protective effect of antidepressants in terms of lower rates of suicide attempts compared to patients who received no treatment. They also reported a protective effect of SSRIs when the risk of suicide was compared in the same cohort before and during treatment.

Barbui and colleagues found a higher rate of suicide attempts and completions among adolescents and a lower rate among adults whose depression was treated with SSRIs. These results are reassuring for adults and their clinicians and families, but worrisome for adolescents and their clinicians and families. However, we must reconcile these findings with other conflicting data. Sondergard and colleagues³ noted that none of the 42 youth in Denmark aged 10–17 years who committed suicide between 1995 and 1999 had taken an SSRI within 2 weeks before their suicide. If SSRIs increase the risk of suicide, it is unclear why these drugs are so rarely found on toxicological examination of youth after suicide. In addition, in youth, suicide appears to occur most commonly among those with untreated mood disorders. The epidemiologic studies of Gibbons and colleagues⁴ and Olfson and colleagues,⁵ both of which used national US rates of suicide among youth, reported a correlation between lower prescription rates of SSRIs and higher suicide rates among both children and adults. Moreover, since the decrease in prescription rates in 2004 and 2005 among adolescents,⁶ there has been an increase in the suicide rate in that age group.⁷ Finally, observed differences between adolescents and adults in the association of the use of SSRIs and suicide may reflect confounding by severity of illness that may result from greater difficulty in matching treated and untreated adolescents because their historical record of illness is shorter than for adults. In this respect, studies that compare the rate of suicide attempts before and after treatment initiation within the same cohort may have an advantage over studies comparing rates in different cohorts.

Alarmingly, concerns about the risk of suicide in youth have led not only to fewer SSRI prescriptions without substitution of alternative medications or psychotherapies, but also to a decrease in predicted rates of diagnosis of mood disorders.⁸ Since a decrease in the rate of true depression is improbable, clinicians may be avoiding making this diagnosis to avoid the dilemma of whether to prescribe antidepressants to children and adolescents. With so many uncertainties, large randomized trials are now required. These are not impossible to carry out. Randomized controlled studies of the use of lithium for treatment of mood disorders and the use of clozapine for treatment of schizophrenia have shown that these drugs have antisuicidal therapeutic effects relative to comparators. Similar studies of SSRIs that include suicidal adolescents with major depression are urgently needed to determine the safety and efficacy of these medications.