Visible Chromosomal Landmarks
The microscopic study of chromosomes and analysis of their genetic properties is
called cytogenetics, a discipline that combines cytology with
genetics. Since a great deal of space in this book will be devoted to the
properties of chromosomes, we will begin with a look at the visible morphology
of chromosomes, the features that are commonly used in cytogenetic analysis for
telling chromosomes apart.
Chromosomes can be viewed relatively easily under the microscope, but only just
before, during, and immediately after cell division. When a cell divides, the
nucleus and its chromosomes also divide. The topics of cell and nuclear division
will be covered fully in Chapter 4.
At present we need note only that chromosomes must become very compact during
cell division, since they are moved around a great deal during their
apportionment into daughter cells. Thus, the components of a chromosome
(including its DNA) become condensed from the extended form found in nondividing
cells into a shorter, fatter form that can be easily handled by the division
apparatus of the cell. It is the landmarks of these condensed
chromosomes that are seen under the microscope, but it can be presumed that
these landmarks are in the same relative positions on the
extended chromosomes of nondividing cells.
Chromosome size
Table 2-4
| Large chromosomes |
| A | 1 |
| 8.4 | 48 (M) |
| 2 |
| 8.0 | 39 |
| 3 |
| 6.8 | 47 (M) |
| B | 4 |
| 6.3 | 29 |
| 5 |
| 6.1 | 29 |
| Medium chromosomes |
| C | 6 |
| 5.9 | 39 |
| 7 |
| 5.4 | 39 |
| 8 |
| 4.9 | 34 |
| 9 |
| 4.8 | 35 |
| 10 |
| 4.6 | 34 |
| 11 |
| 4.6 | 40 |
| 12 |
| 4.7 | 30 |
| D | 13 |
| 3.7 | 17 (A) |
| 14 |
| 3.6 | 19 (A) |
| 15 |
| 3.5 | 20 (A) |
| Small chromosomes |
| E | 16 |
| 3.4 | 41 |
| 17 |
| 3.3 | 34 |
| 18 |
| 2.9 | 31 |
| F | 19 |
| 2.7 | 47 (M) |
| 20 |
| 2.6 | 45 (M) |
| G | 21 |
| 1.9 | 31 |
| 22 |
| 2.0 | 30 |
| Sex chromosomes |
| X |
| 5.1 (group C) | 40 |
| Y |
| 2.2 (group G) | 27 (A) |
The
chromosomes of a single
genome may differ considerably in size. In the
human
genome, for example, there is about a fourfold range in size from
chromosome 1 (the biggest) to
chromosome 21 (the smallest), as shown in
Table 2-4. In studying the
chromosomes of a species, a cytogeneticist may have difficulty identifying
individual
chromosomes by size alone but may be able to group
chromosomes of
similar size. For example, in humans the
chromosomes are placed into seven
groups, labeled A (the largest
chromosomes) through G (the smallest), as
shown in the table.
Centromere position
The molecular strings (
spindle fibers) that move
chromosomes around during
cell division attach to a specialized region of the
chromosome called the
centromere. The centromeric
region usually appears as a constriction or neck at a specific position
along the
chromosome. This constriction divides the
chromosome into two
“arms.” The shorter arm is called
p and the longer arm
q. The position of the constriction defines the ratio
between the lengths of the two
chromosome arms. This arm ratio is a useful
characteristic for identifying individual
chromosomes (
Table 2-4).
Centromere positions also
can be categorized as
telocentric (at one end),
acrocentric (close to one end), or
metacentric
(in the middle).
The tips of the chromosomes are called telomeres. The telomeres
generally are not visibly distinct from the other parts of the chromosome.
The telomeres and the centromeres have unique molecular structures that are
crucial to normal chromosome behavior.
Position of nucleolar organizers
Nucleoli are spherical structures found associated with
constrictions of the chromosomes called nucleolar organizers.
Different organisms are differently endowed with nucleoli, which range in
number from one to many per chromosome set. The diploid cells of many
species have just a pair of nucleoli. Nucleolar organizers contain numerous
tandem copies of the genes that code for ribosomal RNA, an untranslated RNA
that is a component of the ribosomes. Ribosomal RNA is synthesized at the
nucleolar organizers, deposited into the nucleoli, and later exported to the
cytoplasm to become incorporated into ribosomes. The positions of nucleoli,
like the positions of centromeres, are quite useful landmarks for
cytogenetic analysis.
Chromomere patterns
The chromomeres are beadlike, localized thickenings found along
the chromosome during the early stages of nuclear division. The positions of
chromomeres are the same in all homologous chromosomes. Although chromomeres
can be useful as markers, their molecular nature is not known.
Figure 2-13
.
Chromosome 2 of tomato at pachytene of meiosis, showing the nucleous
and the nucleolar organizer: (a) photograph; (b) interpretation.
(Photo Peter Moens. From the genetic location of the centromere of
chromosome 2 in the tomato. P. Moens and L. Butler. Can. J. Genet.
Cytol. 5:364-370, 1963.)
Heterochromatin patterns
When chromosomes are treated with chemicals that react with DNA, such as
Feulgen reagent, distinct regions with different staining characteristics
are revealed. Densely staining regions are called heterochromatin and reflect a high degree of
compactness; poorly staining regions are called euchromatin and indicate less tightly packed regions.
Most of the active genes are in euchromatin. Figure 5-15 shows examples of heterochromatin in the tomato.
Banding patterns
Figure 2-14
.
Banding pattern of human chromosomes 1 and X, showing band
nomenclature and the positions of some genes. (From V. A.
McKusick, in S. J. O’Brien, ed., Genetic Maps,
vol. 2. Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y. 1982.)
Special
chromosome staining procedures have revealed intricate sets of
bands (transverse stripes) in many different organisms. The
positions and sizes of the bands are highly
chromosome-specific; therefore,
they represent useful landmarks. There are Q bands (produced by quinacrine
hydrochloride), G bands (produced by Giemsa stain), and R bands (produced by
reversed Giemsa). The G banding patterns in two human
chromosomes and the
locations of some of the
genes on those
chromosomes are shown in .
A rather specialized kind of banding occurs in a few organisms whose
chromosomes can replicate their DNA many times without separating. This
produces giant chromosomes, which are in essence magnified versions of the
unreplicated forms. Consequently, the natural banding patterns of the
chromosomes become readily visible and can serve as landmarks. These
polytene chromosomes (polytene means
“many-stranded”) are found in highly specialized cells of Malpighian
tubules, rectum, gut, footpads, and salivary glands of the dipteran insects
such as houseflies, mosquitoes, and fruit flies.
The fruit fly
Drosophila melanogaster is a much-studied
example. This insect (a
diploid) has a 2
n number of 8, and
these eight
chromosomes (see ) are present in most cells. However, in the cells of the
special organs that contain the
polytene chromosomes we see some interesting
peculiarities (). First,
there are only four
polytene chromosomes per cell (not eight) because during
the specialized
replication process the members of each homologous pair
unexpectedly unite with each other. Second, all four
polytene chromosomes
become joined at a structure called the
chromocenter, which
is a coalescence of the heterochromatic areas around the
centromeres of all
four
chromosomes. The
chromocenter of
Drosophila salivary
gland
chromosomes is shown in , where L and R stand for arbitrarily assigned left and
right arms.
Along the length of a
polytene chromosome, there are transverse bands (). Polytene bands are much
more numerous than Q, G, or R bands, numbering in the hundreds on each
chromosome. The bands differ in width and appearance, so that the banding
pattern of each
chromosome is unique and characteristic of that
chromosome.
Molecular studies have shown that in any chromosomal region of
Drosophila there are more genes than there are polytene
bands, so the bands do not represent genes. Similarly, the significance of
the Q, G, and R patterns in other eukaryotic cells is not clear. They
probably reflect the degree of compactness of the DNA, but it is not known
how this pattern is maintained.
Figure 2-16
.
The landmarks that distinguish the chromosomes of corn.
Using all the available chromosomal landmarks together, cytogeneticists can
distinguish each of the
chromosomes of many species. shows a map of the chromosomal landmarks
of the
genome of corn.
MESSAGE
Such features as size, arm ratio, heterochromatin, number and
position of chromomeres, number and location of nucleolar
organizers, and banding pattern identify the individual chromosomes
within the set that characterizes a species.
Three-Dimensional Structure of Nuclear Chromosomes
A human cell contains about 2 meters of DNA (1 m per chromosome set). The human
body consists of approximately 1013 cells, and each cell is diploid;
therefore, the body contains a total of about 2 × 1013 m of DNA. Some
idea of the extreme length of this DNA can be obtained by comparing it with the
distance from Earth to the sun, which is 1.5 × 1011 m. You can see
that the DNA in your body could stretch to the sun and back almost 100 times.
This peculiar fact makes the point that the DNA of eukaryotes is obviously
efficiently packed. In fact, the packing occurs at the level of the nucleus,
where the 2 m of DNA in a human cell are packed into 46 chromosomes, all inside
a nucleus only 0.006 mm in diameter. How can such long molecules be packaged
into to the wormlike structures, visible under the light microscope, that we
call chromosomes? To answer this question we need to understand the
three-dimensional structure of eukaryotic chromosomes.
Figure 2-17
.
Electron micrograph of metaphase chromosomes from a honeybee. The
chromosomes each appear to be composed of one continuous fiber 30 nm
wide. (From E. J. DuPraw, Cell and Molecular
Biology. Copyright © 1968 by Academic Press.)
Figure 2-18
.
Composite electron micrograph of a DNA molecule from
Drosophila. The overall length is 1.5 cm and is
thought to correspond to one chromosome. (From R. Kavenoff, L. C.
Klotz, and B. H. Zimm, Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant.
Biol. 38, 1974, 4.)
If
eukaryotic cells are broken, and the contents of their nuclei are examined
under the electron microscope,
chromosomes appear as masses of spaghetti-like
fibers with diameters of about 30 nm. Some examples are shown in the electron
micrograph in . If such
chromosomes are studied carefully, it becomes clear that there are no ends
protruding from the fibrillar mass. This suggests that each
chromosome is one
long, fine fiber folded up in some way. If the fiber somehow corresponds to a
DNA molecule, then we arrive at the idea that each
chromosome is one densely
folded DNA molecule. Measurements of the elasticity of
Drosophila DNA in solution further support this concept, as
does electron microscopy ().
Perhaps the best evidence that a chromosome consists of a single long DNA
molecule comes from a technique called pulsed field gel
electrophoresis. If DNA from a large number of cells is extracted,
purified with great care to avoid breaking the molecules, and placed on a
gelatinous matrix under the influence of powerful, alternating, crossed electric
fields, the DNA molecules of each chromosome move through the gel at speeds
proportional to their size. All the DNA of one chromosomal type ends up in one
position (called a band), so if the gel is stained with a dye
that binds to DNA, the number of bands of DNA is always equal to the number of
chromosomes, whether the cell is diploid or haploid.
MESSAGE
Each eukaryotic chromosome contains a single, long, folded DNA
molecule.
Histone proteins
Figure 2-19
.
(a) Model of a nucleosome showing the DNA wrapped twice around a
histone octamer. (Alan Wolffe and Van Moudrianakis.) (b) Two
views of a model of the 30-nm solenoid showing histone octamers
as purple disks. (Left) Partially unwound
lateral view. (Right) End view. The additional
histone H1 is shown running down the center of the coil,
probably acting as a stabilizer. With increasing salt
concentrations, the nucleosomes close up to form a solenoid with
six nucleosomes per turn. (From H. Lodish, D. Baltimore, A.
Berk, S. L. Zipursky, P. Matsudaira, and J. Darnell,
Molecular Cell Biology, 3d ed. Copyright ©
1995 by Scientific American Books.)
What are the precise mechanisms that pack DNA into
chromosomes? How is the
very long DNA thread converted into the relatively thick, dense, wormlike
structure visible to us during
cell division? The overall mixture of
material that comprises
chromosomes is given the general name
chromatin. It is DNA and protein.
If
chromatin is extracted and treated with differing concentrations of salt,
different degrees of compaction, or condensation, are observed under the
electron microscope. With low salt concentrations, a structure about 10 nm
in diameter is seen that resembles a beaded necklace. The string between the
beads of the necklace can be digested away with the
enzyme DNase, so the
string can be inferred to be DNA. The beads on the necklace are called
nucleosomes; these can be shown to be complexes of DNA and
special chromosomal proteins called
histones. Histone structure
is remarkably conserved across the range of eukaryotic organisms, and
nucleosomes are always found to contain an octamer of two units each of
histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4. The DNA is wrapped twice around the octamer
as shown in . When salt
concentrations are higher, the
nucleosome beaded necklace gradually assumes
a coiled form called a
solenoid (). This solenoid, produced
in vitro, is 30
nm in diameter and probably corresponds to the
in vivo spaghetti-like
structures we saw in . The
solenoid is stabilized by another
histone, H1, that runs down the center of
the structure, as
shows.
We see then that to achieve its first level of packaging, DNA winds onto
histones, which act somewhat like spools. Further coiling results in the
solenoid conformation. However, it takes one more level of packaging to
convert the solenoids into the three-dimensional structure we call the
chromosome.
Higher-order coiling
Figure 2-20
.
Drawings of chromosomes of a protozoan, demonstrating coiling and
supercoiling visible with the light microscope. Two large
chromosomes are shown: one orange and the other yellow; the
chromosomes are duplicated because sexual cell division is about
to occur. (From L. R. Cleveland, “The Whole Life Cycle of
Chromosomes and Their Coiling Systems,” Trans. Am.
Philosophical Soc. 39, 1949, 1.)
Figure 2-21
.
Electron micrograph of a metaphase chromosome from a cultured
human cell. Note the central core, or scaffold, from which the
DNA strands extend outward. No free ends are visible at the
outer edge. At even higher magnification, it is clear that each
loop begins and ends near the same region of the scaffold. (From
W. R. Baumbach and K. W. Adolph, Cold Spring Harbor
Symp. Quant. Biol., Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory,
Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y., 1977.)
Many cytogenetic studies show that
chromosomes are visibly coiled; shows a good example from
the nucleus of a protozoan. Whereas the diameter of the solenoids is 30 nm,
the diameter of these “
supercoils” is the same as the diameter of the
chromosome during
cell division, often about 700 nm. What produces the
supercoils? One clue comes from observing
chromosomes from which the
histone
proteins have been removed chemically. After such treatment, the
chromosomes
have a densely staining central core of nonhistone protein called the
scaffold, as shown in . Projecting laterally from
this protein
scaffold are loops of DNA. The fibers forming these loops are
believed to be the solenoids. At high magnifications, it is clear from
electron micrographs that each DNA loop begins and ends at the
scaffold. It
has been discovered that the central
scaffold is largely composed of the
enzyme topoisomerase II, which has the ability to pass a strand of DNA
through another strand, rather like a magician’s rings. Evidently, the
central
scaffold organizes the vast skein of DNA during
replication, a time
when the two strands of DNA must unwind to allow new synthesis. Anyone who
has tried to unwind the two strands of a piece of rope has experienced the
difficulties inherent in this process.
Figure 2-22
.
Model for chromosome structure. On the left is shown a more
relaxed supercoil, when the cell is not dividing. On the right,
much tighter coiling is shown, representing a chromosome during
cell division: here the loops are so densely packed, only their
tips are visible. At the free ends the solenoids are shown
uncoiled to give an approximation of relative scale.
Figure 2-23
.
Some loop domains that have been mapped in
Drosophila. Gene loci and scaffold
attachment regions (SARs) are shown.
Now, to return to the question of how the supercoiling of the
chromosome is
produced. The best evidence suggests that the solenoids arrange in loops
emanating from the central
scaffold matrix, which itself is in the form of a
spiral. We see the general idea in , which shows a representation of a loosely coiled
chromosome
from a nondividing cell and a more tightly coiled
chromosome during cell
division. The loops attach to the
scaffold by special regions along the DNA
called
scaffold attachment regions, or
SARs. Some
SARs that
have been mapped in
Drosophila are shown in .
As we saw in ,
chromosomes
are much less supercoiled (but still not naked DNA) in the nondividing
nucleus than during
cell division. Hence they are essentially invisible at
the light microscopic level. This more relaxed state is probably necessary
for most
genes to be expressed.
MESSAGE
In the progressive levels of chromosome packing
Representations of chromosomes
Figure 2-24
.
Three different diagrammatic ways of representing chromosomes in
nondividing cells. The first representation focuses on the
coiled structure of chromosomes. The second emphasizes the fact
that the genetic component of a chromosome is DNA. The third
shows the chromosomes as wormlike structures with centromeres as
white circles. No representation is perfectly accurate, but each
has its uses in genetics.
We have seen that eukaryotic
chromosomes are complex structures, and, not
surprisingly, they are difficult to represent diagrammatically. shows three shorthand
representations of
chromosomes in
diploid and
haploid nondividing cells,
focusing on coiled structure, linear DNA content, and
chromosome length and
arm ratio. Shorthand representations such as these are used for illustrating
specific chromosomal properties under discussion, but it should be
emphasized that none is a perfect representation. Indeed the diagrams shown
in on the following page
are representations of the
chromosomes in a nondividing cell, and as noted
before, at this stage the
chromosomes are not even visible under the
microscope. It is important to note that in the
diploid condition shown
homologous
chromosomes constitute a pair, but they are generally not in a
paired configuration. In fact, homologous chro-mosomes pair physically only
during the specialized type of nuclear division that occurs during the
production of sex cells (
meiosis), as we shall see in
Chapter 4.