The essence of cell chemistry is to isolate a particular cellular component and then
analyze its chemical structure and activity. In the case of DNA, this is feasible
for relatively short molecules such as the genomes of small viruses. But genomes of
even the simplest cells are much too large to directly analyze in detail at the
molecular level. The problem is compounded for complex organisms. The human genome,
for example, contains about 6 × 109 base pairs (bp) in the 23
pairs of chromosomes. Cleavage of human DNA with restriction enzymes that produce
about one cut for every 3000 base pairs yields some 2 million fragments, far too
many to separate from each other directly. This obstacle to obtaining pure DNA
samples from large genomes has been overcome by recombinant DNA technology. With
these methods virtually any gene can be purified, its sequence determined, and the
functional regions of the sequence explored by altering it in planned ways and
reintroducing the DNA into cells and into whole organisms.
The essence of recombinant DNA technology is the prep-aration of large numbers of
identical DNA molecules. A DNA fragment of interest is linked through standard
3′ → 5′ phosphodiester bonds to a
vector DNA molecule, which can
replicate when introduced into a host cell. When a single recombinant DNA molecule,
composed of a vector plus an inserted DNA fragment, is introduced into a host cell,
the inserted DNA is reproduced along with the vector, producing large numbers of
recombinant DNA molecules that include the fragment of DNA originally linked to the
vector. Two types of vectors are most commonly used: E. coli
plasmid vectors and bacteriophage
λ vectors. Plasmid vectors replicate along with their host cells, while
λ vectors replicate as lytic viruses, killing the host cell and packaging
the DNA into virions (Chapter 6). In
this section, the general procedure for cloning DNA fragments in E.
coli plasmids is described.
Plasmids Are Extrachromosomal Self-Replicating DNA Molecules
Plasmids are circular, double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) molecules that are separate
from a cell’s chromosomal DNA. These extrachromosomal DNAs, which
occur naturally in bacteria, yeast, and some higher eukaryotic cells, exist in a
parasitic or symbiotic relationship with their host cell. Plasmids range in size
from a few thousand base pairs to more than 100 kilobases (kb). Like the
host-cell chromosomal DNA, plasmid DNA is duplicated before every cell division.
During cell division, at least one copy of the plasmid DNA is segregated to each
daughter cell, assuring continued propagation of the plasmid through successive
generations of the host cell.
Many naturally occurring plasmids
contain genes that provide some benefit to the host cell, fulfilling the
plasmid’s portion of the symbiotic relationship. For example, some
bacterial plasmids encode enzymes that inactivate antibiotics. Such
drug-resistance plasmids have become a major problem in the treatment of a
number of common bacterial pathogens. As antibiotic use became widespread,
plasmids containing several drug-resistance genes evolved, making their host
cells resistant to a variety of different antibiotics simultaneously. Many of
these plasmids also contain “transfer genes” encoding
proteins that can form a macromolecular tube, or pilus, through
which a copy of the plasmid can be transferred to other host cells of the same
or related bacterial species. Such transfer can result in the rapid spread of
drug-resistance plasmids, expanding the number of antibiotic-resistant bacteria
in an environment such as a hospital. Coping with the spread of drug-resistance
plasmids is an important challenge for modern medicine.
E. Coli Plasmids Can Be Engineered for Use as Cloning Vectors
Figure 7-1
.
Diagram of a simple cloning vector derived from a plasmid, a
circular, double-stranded DNA molecule that can replicate within an
E. coli cell
Plasmid vectors are
≈1.2 – 3 kb in length
and contain a replication origin (ORI) sequence and a gene that
permits selection, usually by conferring resistance to a particular
drug. Here the selective gene is ampr;
it encodes the enzyme β-lactamase, which inactivates
ampicillin. Exogenous DNA can be inserted into the bracketed region
without disturbing the ability of the plasmid to replicate or
express the ampr gene.
The
plasmids most commonly used in
recombinant DNA technology replicate in
E. coli.Generally, these
plasmids have been engineered to
optimize their use as
vectors in
DNA cloning. For instance, to simplify working
with
plasmids, their length is reduced; many
plasmid vectors are only
≈3kb in length, which is much shorter than in naturally occurring
E. coli plasmids. (The circumference of
plasmids usually
is referred to as their “length,” even though
plasmids are
almost always circular DNA molecules.) Most
plasmid vectors contain little more
than the essential
nucleotide sequences required for their use in
DNA cloning: a
replication origin, a drug-resistance
gene, and a region in which exogenous DNA
fragments can be inserted ().
Plasmid DNA Replication
Figure 7-2
.
Plasmid DNA replication
The parental strands are shown in blue, and newly synthesized
daughter strands are shown in red. The short segments represent
the A·T and G·C base pairs connecting the
complementary strands. Once DNA replication is initiated at the
origin (ORI), it continues in both directions around the
circular molecule until the advancing growing forks merge and
two daughter molecules are produced. The origin is the only
specific nucleotide sequence required for replication of the
entire circular DNA molecule.
The
replication origin (ORI) is
a specific DNA sequence of 50 – 100
base
pairs that must be present in a
plasmid for it to replicate. Host-cell
enzymes bind to ORI, initiating replication of the circular
plasmid. Once
DNA replication is initiated at ORI, it continues around the circular
plasmid regardless of its
nucleotide sequence (). Thus any DNA sequence inserted into such
a
plasmid is replicated along with the rest of the
plasmid DNA; this
property is the basis of molecular
DNA cloning.
Selection of Transformed Cells
In 1944, O. T. Avery, C. M. Macleod, and M. McCarty first demonstrated gene
transfer with isolated DNA obtained from Streptococcus
pneumoniae. This process involved the genetic alteration of a
bacterial cell by the uptake of DNA isolated from a genetically different
bacterium and its recombination with the host-cell genome. Their experiments
provided the first evidence that DNA is the genetic material. Later studies
showed that such genetic alteration of a recipient cell can result from the
uptake of exogenous extrachromosomal DNA (e.g., plasmids) that does not
integrate into the host-cell chromosome. The term transformation is used to denote the genetic
alteration of a cell caused by the uptake and expression of foreign DNA
regardless of the mechanism involved. (Note that
transformation has a second meaning defined in Chapter 6, namely, the process
by which normal cells with a finite life span in culture are converted into
continuously growing cells similar to cancer cells.)
The phenomenon of transformation permits plasmid vectors to be introduced
into and expressed by E. coli cells. In order to be useful
in DNA cloning, however, a plasmid vector must contain a selectable
gene, most commonly a drug-resistance gene encoding an enzyme
that inactivates a specific antibiotic. As we’ve seen, the
ampicillin-resistance gene (ampr) encodes
β-lactamase, which inactivates the antibiotic ampicillin. After
plasmid vectors are incubated with E. coli, those cells
that take up the plasmid can be easily selected from the larger number of
cells that do not by growing them in an ampicillin-containing medium. The
ability to select transformed cells is critical to DNA cloning by plasmid
vector technology because the transformation of E. coli
with isolated plasmid DNA is inefficient.
Normal E. coli cells cannot take up plasmid DNA from the
medium. Exposure of cells to high concentrations of certain divalent
cations, however, makes a small fraction of cells permeable to foreign DNA
by a mechanism that is not understood. In a typical procedure, E.
coli cells are treated with CaCl2 and mixed with
plasmid vectors; commonly, only 1 cell in about 10,000 or more cells becomes
competent to take up the foreign DNA. Each competent cell incorporates a
single plasmid DNA molecule, which carries an
antibiotic-resistance gene. When the treated cells are plated on a petri
dish of nutrient agar containing the antibiotic, only the rare transformed
cells containing the antibiotic-resistance gene on the plasmid vector will
survive. All the plasmids in such a colony of selected transformed cells are
descended from the single plasmid taken up by the cell that established the
colony.
Plasmid Cloning Permits Isolation of DNA Fragments from Complex
Mixtures
Figure 7-3
.
General procedure for cloning a DNA fragment in a plasmid
vector
Although not indicated by color, the plasmid contains a
replication origin and ampicillin-resistance gene. Uptake of
plasmids by E. coli cells is stimulated by high
concentrations of CaCl2. Even in the presence of
CaCl2, transformation occurs with a quite low
frequency, and only a few cells are transformed by incorporation
of a single plasmid molecule. Cells that are not transformed die
on ampicillin-containing medium. Once incorporated into a host
cell, a plasmid can replicate independently of the host-cell
chromosome. As a transformed cell multiplies into a colony, at
least one plasmid segregates to each daughter cell.
A DNA fragment of a few
base pairs up to ≈20 kb can be inserted into
a
plasmid vector. When such a recombinant
plasmid transforms an
E.
coli cell, all the antibiotic-resistant progeny cells that arise
from the initial transformed cell will contain
plasmids with the same inserted
sequence of DNA (). The
inserted DNA is replicated along with the rest of the
plasmid DNA and segregates
to daughter cells as the colony grows. In this way, the initial fragment of DNA
is replicated in the colony of cells into a large number of identical copies.
Since all the cells in a colony arise from a single transformed parental cell,
they constitute a
clone of cells. The initial fragment of DNA inserted into the
parental
plasmid is referred to as
cloned DNA, since it can be
isolated from the
clone of cells.
Figure 7-4
.
Isolation of DNA fragments from a mixture by cloning in a
plasmid vector
Four distinct DNA fragments, depicted in different colors, are
inserted into plasmid cloning vectors, yielding a mixture of
recombinant plasmids each containing a single DNA fragment.
E. coli cells treated with CaCl2
are incubated with the mixture of recombinant plasmids and then
plated on nutrient agar containing ampicillin. Each colony of
transformed, antibiotic-resistant cells that grows (represented
by a group of cells) arises from a single cell that took up one
or another of the recombinant plasmids; all the cells in a given
colony thus carry the same DNA fragment. Overnight incubation of
E. coli at 37 °C produces visible
colonies containing about a million cells. Since the colonies
are separated from one another on the culture plate, copies of
the DNA fragments in the original mixture are isolated in the
individual colonies. Although it’s not shown here, the
transformed cells contain multiple copies of a given
plasmid.
DNA cloning allows fragments of DNA with a particular
nucleotide sequence to be
isolated from a complex mixture of fragments with many different sequences. As a
simple example, assume you have a solution containing four different types of
DNA fragments, each with a unique sequence (). Each fragment type is individually inserted into a
plasmid vector. The resulting mixture of recombinant
plasmids is incubated with
E. coli cells under conditions that facilitate
transformation; the cells then are cultured on antibiotic selective plates.
Since each colony that develops arose from a single cell that took up a single
plasmid, all the cells in a colony harbor the identical type of
plasmid
characterized by the DNA fragment inserted into it. As a result, copies of the
DNA fragments in the initial mixture are isolated from one another in the
separate bacterial colonies.
DNA cloning thus is a powerful, yet simple method
for purifying a particular DNA fragment from a complex mixture of fragments and
producing large numbers of the fragment of interest.
Restriction Enzymes Cut DNA Molecules at Specific Sequences
To clone specific DNA fragments in a plasmid vector, as just described, or in
other vectors discussed in later sections, the fragments must be produced and
then inserted into the vector DNA. As noted in the introduction, restriction
enzymes and DNA ligases are utilized to produce such recombinant DNA
molecules.
Figure 7-5
.
Restriction-recognition sites are short DNA sequences recognized
and cleaved by various restriction endonucleases
(a) EcoRI, a restriction enzyme from E.
coli, makes staggered cuts at the specific 6-bp
inverted repeat sequence shown. This cleavage yields fragments with
single-stranded, complementary “sticky” ends.
Many other restriction enzymes also produce fragments with sticky
ends. (b) Bacterial cells with restriction endonucleases also
contain corresponding modification enzymes that methylate bases in
the restriction-recognition site. For example, E.
coli cells containing the EcoRI
restriction enzyme also contain EcoRI methylase, a
modification enzyme that catalyzes addition of a methyl group to two
adenines in the EcoRI recognition sequence. The
methylated restriction site is not cleaved by
EcoRI, assuring that a cell making this restriction
enzyme does not destroy its own DNA.
Figure 7-6
.
Fragments produced by cleavage of the ≈36-kb DNA
genome from adenovirus 2 (Ad2) by EcoRI and another
restriction enzyme, HindIII from
Haemophilus influenzae.
Double-stranded DNA is represented by single black lines in this
figure. Digestion of Ad2 DNA (center) with
EcoRI generates 6 EcoRI
fragments (top); these result from cleavage at each
EcoRI restriction site (GAATTC) in the Ad2
sequence. Digestion with HindIII cleaves the Ad2
DNA at each HindIII site (AAGCTT), generating 11
specific fragments (bottom), all different from the
EcoRI fragments. By convention, restriction
fragments are labeled A – Z in order
of decreasing size. By techniques described later, the order of
fragments in the original DNA can be determined, thus mapping the
restriction sites on the uncut DNA (indicated by short arrows). Such
a “restriction-site map” for various restriction
enzymes is a unique characteristic of each DNA.
Restriction
enzymes are bacterial
enzymes that recognize specific 4- to 8-bp
sequences, called
restriction sites, and then cleave both DNA
strands at this site. Since these
enzymes cleave DNA within the molecule, they
are also called
restriction endonucleases to distinguish them
from exonucleases
, which digest
nucleic acids from an end. Many
restriction sites, like the
EcoRI site shown in , are short inverted repeat
sequences; that is, the restriction-site sequence is the same on each DNA strand
when read in the 5′ → 3′
direction. Because the DNA isolated from an individual organism has a specific
sequence, restriction
enzymes cut the DNA into a reproducible set of fragments
called
restriction fragments ().
Table 7-1
Selected Restriction Endonucleases and Their Restriction-Site
Sequences
| Arthrobacter luteus | AluI | AG↓CT | Blunt |
| Bacillus amyloliquefaciens H | BamHI | G↓GATCC | Sticky |
| Escherichia coli | EcoRI | G↓AATTC | Sticky |
| Haemophilus gallinarum | HgaI | GACGC+5↓ | ‡ |
| Haemophilus influenzae | HindIII | A↓AGCTT | Sticky |
| Haemophilus parahaemolyticus | HphI | GGTGA+8↓ | ‡ |
| Nocardia otitiscaviaruns | NotI | GC↓GGCCGC | Sticky |
| Staphylococcus aureus 3A | Sau3AI | ↓GATC | Sticky |
| Serratia marcesens | SmaI | CCC↓GGG | Blunt |
| Thermus aquaticus | TaqI | T↓CGA | Sticky |
The word
restriction in the name of these
enzymes refers to
their function in the bacteria from which they are isolated: a restriction
endonuclease destroys (restricts) incoming foreign DNA (e.g., bacteriophage DNA
or DNA taken up during
transformation) by cleaving it at all the restriction
sites in the DNA. Another
enzyme, called a
modification enzyme,
protects a bacterium’s own DNA from cleavage by modifying it at or
near each potential cleavage site. The modification
enzyme adds a methyl group
to one or two
bases, usually within the restriction site. When a methyl group is
present there, the restriction endonuclease is prevented from cutting the DNA
(). Together with the
restriction endonuclease, the methylating
enzyme forms a
restriction-modification system that protects the host DNA while it destroys
foreign DNA. Restriction
enzymes have been purified from several hundred
different species of bacteria, allowing DNA molecules to be cut at a large
number of different sequences corresponding to the recognition sites of these
enzymes (
Table 7-1).
Restriction Fragments with Complementary “Sticky Ends”
Are Ligated Easily
As illustrated in ,
EcoRI makes staggered cuts in the two DNA strands. Many
other restriction
enzymes make similar cuts, generating fragments that have a
single-stranded “tail” at both ends. The tails on the
fragments generated at a given restriction site are
complementary to those on
all other fragments generated by the same restriction
enzyme. At room
temperature, these single-stranded regions, often called “sticky
ends,” can transiently
base-pair with those on other DNA fragments
generated with the same restriction
enzyme, regardless of the source of the DNA.
This
base pairing of sticky ends permits DNA from widely differing species to be
ligated, forming chimeric molecules.
Figure 7-7
.
Ligation of restriction fragments with complementary sticky
ends
In this example, EcoRI fragments from DNA I
(left) are mixed with several different
restriction fragments, including EcoRI fragments,
produced from DNA II (right). The short DNA
sequences composing the sticky ends of each fragment type are shown.
The complementary sticky ends on the two types of
EcoRI fragments, (a′) and (a), can
transiently base-pair, whereas the TaqI fragments
(b) and HindIII fragments (c) with noncomplementary
sticky ends do not base-pair to EcoRI fragments.
The adjacent 3′-hydroxyl and 5′-phosphate groups
(red) on the base-paired fragments then are covalently joined
(ligated) by T4 DNA ligase. One ATP is consumed for each
phosphodiester bond (red) formed.
During
in vivo DNA replication, DNA
ligase catalyzes formation of
3′ → 5′ phosphodiester
bonds between the short fragments of the discontinuously synthesized DNA strand
at a
replication fork (see
Figure 4-16).
In
recombinant DNA technology, purified DNA
ligase is used to covalently join
the ends of
restriction fragments in vitro. This
enzyme can catalyze the
formation of a 3′ → 5′
phosphodiester bond between the 3′-hydroxyl end of one
restriction-fragment strand and the 5′-phosphate end of another
restriction-fragment strand during the time that the sticky ends are transiently
base-paired (). When DNA
ligase and ATP are added to a solution containing
restriction fragments with
sticky ends, the
restriction fragments are covalently ligated together through
the standard 3′ → 5′
phosphodiester bonds of DNA.
Some restriction
enzymes, such as
AluI and
SmaI, cleave both DNA strands at the same point within the
recognition site (see
Table 7-1).
These restriction
enzymes generate DNA
restriction fragments with
“blunt” (flush) ends in which all the
nucleotides at the
fragment ends are
base-paired to
nucleotides in the
complementary strand. In
addition to ligating
complementary sticky ends, the DNA
ligase from
bacteriophage T4 can ligate any two blunt DNA ends. However, blunt-end ligation
requires a higher DNA concentration than ligation of sticky ends.
Polylinkers Facilitate Insertion of Restriction Fragments into Plasmid
Vectors
Figure 7-8
.
Plasmid vectors containing a polylinker, or multiple-cloning-site
sequence, commonly are used to produce recombinant plasmids carrying
exogenous DNA fragments
(a) Sequence of a polylinker that includes one copy of the
recognition site, indicated by brackets, for each of the 10
restriction enzymes indicated. Polylinkers are chemically
synthesized and then are inserted into a plasmid vector. Only one
strand is shown. (b) Insertion of genomic restriction fragments into
the pUC19 plasmid vector, which contains the polylinker shown in
(a). (The length of the polylinker in relation to the rest of the
plasmid is greatly exaggerated here.) One of the restriction enzymes
whose recognition site is in the polylinker is used to cut both the
plasmid molecules and genomic DNA, generating singly-cut plasmids
and restriction fragments with complementary sticky ends (letters at
ends of green fragments). By use of appropriate reaction conditions,
insertion of a single restriction fragment per plasmid can be
maximized. Note that the restriction sites are reconstituted in the
recombinant plasmid. [See C. Yanisch-Perron, J. Vieira, and J.
Messing, 1985, Gene
33:103.]
Restriction
enzymes to create fragments with sticky ends and DNA
ligase to
covalently link them allow foreign DNA to be inserted into
plasmid vectors in
vitro in a straightforward procedure.
E. coli plasmid vectors
can be constructed with a
polylinker, a synthetic
multiple-cloning-site sequence that contains one copy of several different
restriction sites (). When
such a
vector is treated with a restriction
enzyme that recognizes a recognition
sequence in the polylinker, it is cut at that sequence, generating sticky ends.
In the presence of DNA
ligase, DNA fragments produced with the same restriction
enzyme will be inserted into the
plasmid (). The ratio of DNA fragments to be inserted to cut
vectors and other reaction conditions are chosen to maximize the insertion of
one
restriction fragment per
plasmid vector. The recombinant
plasmids produced
in
in vitro ligation reactions then can be used to transform
antibiotic-sensitive
E. coli cells as shown in . All the cells in each
antibiotic-resistant
clone that remains after selection contain
plasmids with
the same inserted DNA fragment, but different
clones carry different
fragments.
Small DNA Molecules Can Be Chemically Synthesized
Advances in synthetic chemistry now permit the chemical synthesis of
single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) molecules of any sequence up to about 100
nucleotides in length. Synthetic DNA has a number of applications in recombinant
DNA technology.
Complementary ssDNAs can be synthesized and hybridized to each
other to form a dsDNA with sticky ends. Such completely synthetic dsDNAs can be
cloned into
plasmid vectors just as DNA
restriction fragments prepared from
living organisms are. For example, the 57-bp polylinker sequence shown in was chemically synthesized and
then inserted into
plasmid vectors to facilitate the cloning of fragments
generated by different restriction
enzymes. This example illustrates the use of
synthetic DNAs to add convenient restriction sites where they otherwise do not
occur. As described later in the chapter, synthetic DNAs are used in sequencing
DNA and as
probes to identify
clones of interest. Synthetic DNAs also can be
substituted for natural DNA sequences in cloned DNA to study the effects of
specific
mutations; this topic is examined in
Chapter 8.
Figure 7-9
.
Chemical synthesis of oligonucleotides by sequential addition of
reactive nucleotide derivatives in the
3′ → 5′
direction
The first nucleotide (monomer 1) is bound to a glass support by its
3′ hydroxyl; its 5′ hydroxyl is available for
addition of the second nucleotide. The second nucleotide in the
sequence (monomer 2) is derivatized by addition of
4′,4′-dimethoxytrityl (DMT) to its 5′
hydroxyl, thus blocking this hydroxyl from reacting; in addition, a
highly reactive methylated diisopropyl phosphoramidite group (red
letters) is attached to the 3′ hydroxyl. When the two
monomers are mixed in the presence of a weak acid, they form a
5′ → 3′
phosphodiester bond with the phosphorus in the trivalent state.
Oxidation of this intermediate with iodine (I2) increases
the phosphorus valency to 5, and subsequent removal of the DMT group
by detritylation with zinc bromide (ZnBr2) frees the
5′ hydroxyl. Monomer 3 then is added, and the reactions
are repeated. Repetition of this process eventually yields the
entire oligonucleotide. Finally, all the methyl groups on the
phosphates are removed at the same time at alkaline pH, and the bond
linking monomer 1 to the glass support is cleaved. [See S. L.
Beaucage and M. H. Caruthers, 1981, Tetrahedron
Lett.
22:1859.]
The technique for chemical synthesis of DNA oligonucleotides is outlined in . Note that chains grow in the
3′ → 5′ direction,
opposite to the direction of DNA chain growth catalyzed by
DNA polymerases. Once
the chemistry for producing synthetic DNA was standardized, automated
instruments were developed that allow researchers to program the synthesis of
oligonucleotides of specific sequences up to about 100
nucleotides long.
SUMMARY
-
In DNA cloning, recombinant DNA molecules
are formed in vitro by inserting DNA fragments of interest into vector
DNA molecules. The recombinant DNA molecules are then introduced into
host cells, where they replicate, producing large numbers of recombinant
DNA molecules that include the fragment of DNA originally linked to the
vector.
-
The most commonly used cloning vectors are
E. coli plasmids, small circular DNA molecules that
include three functional regions: (1) an origin of replication, (2) a
drug-resistance gene, and (3) a region where DNA can be inserted without
interfering with plasmid replication or expression of the
drug-resistance gene.
-
Two enzymes are used to produce recombinant
plasmids. Restriction enzymes cut DNA at specific 4- to 8-bp sequences,
often leaving self-complementary single-stranded tails (sticky ends).
These enzymes are used to cut long DNA molecules into multiple
restriction fragments and to cut a plasmid vector at a single site. If a
restriction fragment and cut plasmid vector with complementary ends are
mixed under the proper conditions, DNA ligase will form phosphodiester
bonds between the restriction fragment and vector DNA (see ). -
When recombinant plasmids are incubated
with E. coli cells first treated with a high
concentration of divalent cations, a very small fraction of the cells
take up a single recombinant plasmid. These transformed cells, which
carry the plasmid drug-resistance gene, can be selected by plating on
nutrient agar containing the antibiotic (see ). All the cells in each colony that
grows on this medium contain identical plasmids descended from the
single plasmid that entered the founder cell of the colony. Isolated
colonies thus represent clones of the different restriction fragments
originally inserted into the plasmid vector. -
Polylinkers are synthetic oligonucleotides
composed of one copy of several different restriction sites. Plasmid
vectors that contain a polylinker will be cut only once by multiple
restriction enzymes, each acting at its own site. Inclusion of a
polylinker in a plasmid vector thus permits cloning of restriction
fragments generated by cleavage of DNA with multiple different
restriction enzymes.
-
Single-stranded DNA containing up to 100
nucleotides of any desired sequence can be chemically synthesized using
automated instruments. Synthetic dsDNAs are produced by synthesizing
complementary ssDNAs and then hybridizing them.
ǀ