Natural History
LRRK2-related Parkinson disease (PD) is characterized by features consistent with idiopathic PD: initial motor features of asymmetric tremor at rest and/or bradykinesia, cog-wheel muscle rigidity, postural instability and gait abnormalities including festination and freezing.
Onset is insidious and the disease course is slowly progressive. Age at onset is variable, even within a family. The mean age at onset is approximately 60 years, typical of late-onset Parkinson disease. The reported range of onset is 28 to 82 years [Ishihara et al 2006, Kay et al 2006]. Men and women are affected equally.
Non-motor symptoms in LRRK2-related PD, seen as frequently as in typical idiopathic PD, may include constipation, seborrhea, hyposmia/anosmia, sympathetic denervation of the heart, cognitive decline, and dementia. They may appear prior to the movement disorder or emerge during the disease progression. Both constipation and olfactory dysfunction are potential preclinical markers of PD. Virtually all individuals with PD demonstrate some sleep disruption, which may manifest very early in the disease course. Dementia or depression is quite common and can occur in up to 40% of affected individuals [Chaudhuri et al 2006, Langston et al 2006].
Seven members of one family (the 'Lincolnshire kindred'), in which the mutation p.Y1699C is segregating, presented with a behavioral disorder characterized by depression and anxiety [Khan et al 2005]. The first family identified with the p.Y1699C mutation ('family A') [Zimprich et al 2004] also presented with atypical symptoms of dementia and amyotrophy.
Cognitive impairment does not appear to be more common in LRRK2-related PD than in typical sporadic disease; however, one report of individuals with the p.G2019S mutation suggested that Mini-Mental State Examination scores were lower than expected [Lesage, Ibanez et al 2005]. These findings, however, do not reflect the vast majority of individuals with LRRK2-related PD and the significance of this observation remains unresolved.
Neuroimaging
-
Brain CT and MRI are normal.
-
Positron emission tomography (PET) associated with the LRRK2 mutations p.G2019S, p.Y1699C, and p.R1441C shows significant reduction in 18F-dopa uptake compared to controls; as typical of late-onset PD, the reduced uptake is asymmetric with a rostrocaudal gradient and the putamen more affected than the caudate [Adams et al 2005, Hernandez et al 2005, Khan et al 2005, Paisan-Ruiz et al 2005]. Comparable reduction in uptake may also be observed for the presynaptic membrane dopamine transporter (SLCA3) and vesicular monoamine transporter (SLC18A2) [Adams et al 2005]. Similar findings may be seen in asymptomatic individuals with one of the same LRRK2 mutations [Adams et al 2005].
Neuropathology. The hallmark pathologic features of the common idiopathic form of PD are neuronal loss and gliosis in the substantia nigra and the presence of intracytoplasmic inclusions (or Lewy bodies). The majority of individuals with LRRK2-related PD exhibit these characteristics. However, LRRK2-related PD has also been documented with three alternate pathologies including: 1) nigral neuronal loss and gliosis without Lewy body inclusions, 2) neurofibrillary tangles, and 3) ubiquitin immunopositive inclusions (Marinesco bodies) [Wszolek et al 1997, Wszolek et al 2004, Zimprich et al 2004, Funayama et al 2005, Ross et al 2006].
LRRK2-related PD has the potential to be the 'Rosetta stone' of parkinsonian disorders because: (1) all the major pathologies associated with parkinsonism have been observed; and (2) the end-stage pathology may differ even in families with the same
mutation (see
Table 2). For example:
-
p.R1441C. Four members of Family D with this mutation had variable, pleomorphic pathology: one with diffuse Lewy body disease within the cortex and brainstem; one with Lewy bodies restricted to brainstem, typical of idiopathic PD; one with a 4R-tauopathy with globose neurofibrillary tangles and tufted astrocytes, reminiscent of argyrophilic grains disease and progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP); and one with nigral neuronal degeneration and gliosis, without coexisting pathology [Wszolek et al 2004].
-
p.Y1699C. Two members of Family A with this mutation had ubiquitin-immunoreactive cytoplasmic and nuclear inclusions (Marinesco bodies), and a third had brainstem Lewy body disease [Wszolek et al 1997].
-
p.G2019S. As the most common mutation, p.G2019S is present in the majority of autopsied cases, in which brainstem or transitional, α-synuclein immunopositive Lewy body pathology is observed [Taylor et al 2006]. Rarely, however, nigral neuronal loss and gliosis only or alternate tauopathy or ubiquitin-immunopositive pathology are observed [Giasson et al 2006, Ross et al 2006]. (See Table 3.) -
p.I2020T. In four members of the Sagamihara kindred with this, mutation only moderate nigral neuronal degeneration and gliosis with no coexisting intracytoplasmic lesion pathology were observed [Funayama et al 2005].
| LRRK2 Mutation | Lewy Bodies and Neurites | Tau and NFTs | Ubiquitin | Neuronal Loss Only |
|---|
| p.R1441C | 2 | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| p.Y1699C | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 |
| p.G2019S | 13 | 2 | 1 | 1 |
| p.I2020T | 1 | 0 | 0 | 4 |
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
To date, no certain correlations between specific
LRRK2 mutations and age at onset, clinical presentation, or disease progression have been found. Neuropathologic correlations are noted in
Table 2.
'Dardarin,' the Basque word for tremor, was initially proposed as a name for the protein encoded by LRRK2, leucine-rich repeat serine/threonine-protein kinase 2 (Lrrk2) to highlight excessive tremor in families from this region with the p.R1441G mutation; however, individuals with this mutation are equally likely to present with bradykinesia [Paisan-Ruiz et al 2004; Mata, Taylor et al 2005].
Penetrance
Penetrance of LRRK2 mutations is age dependent but may vary depending upon mutation and population.
A pedigree-based estimate has been made for the most prevalent mutation, LRRK2 c.6055G>A (p.G2019S): The probability of a heterozygote manifesting symptoms is lower than 20% at age 50 years and increases in an almost linear fashion to more than 80% at age 75 years, but asymptomatic heterozygotes older than age 80 years have been reported [Kachergus et al 2005, Kay et al 2005, Carmine Belin et al 2006].
However, accurate estimates of penetrance are difficult to predict and different groups have reported alternate approaches [Kachergus et al 2005, Lesage et al 2005, Ozelius et al 2006]. Ozelius et al (2006) determined lifetime penetrance by two methods: (1) comparing the frequency of individuals with the p.G2019S mutation among individuals with PD vs. unrelated controls (penetrance, 35.2%), and (2) calculating the proportion of the parents of these individuals diagnosed with PD (penetrance, 31.8%). This calculation, performed in a population with a high frequency of the p.G2019S mutation, is a much lower estimate of penetrance than that proposed by Kachergus et al (2005) and Lesage et al (2005). Given the relative absence of the p.G2019S mutation in controls, the penetrance of this variant is clearly age-related and high. Global collaborative efforts to resolve these issues using population-specific approaches are under way.
The risk to heterozygotes and rarer homozygotes is equivalent [Ishihara et al 2006].
Prevalence
In the US, LRRK2-related Parkinson disease causes approximately 1.0% of simplex PD (i.e., single occurrences in a family) and approximately 5%-6% of familial PD.
LRRK2 c.6055G>A (p.G2019S) is the most common mutation, accounting for the following:
-
Approximately 0.5% of simplex PD and 2%-6% of familial PD in the US [Deng et al 2005, Farrer et al 2005, Nichols et al 2005, Kay et al 2006]
-
Approximamtely 0.5% of simplex PD in the UK [Williams-Gray et al 2006]
-
Approximately 2% in families from central Norway [Aasly et al 2005]
-
0.9% simplex PD and 5.1% familial PD in Italy [Goldwurm et al 2005]
-
2.7%-7.6% in northern Spain [Mata, Ross et al 2006]
-
37% of simplex PD [Gaig et al 2006, Infante et al 2006] and 41% of familial PD in North Africa (Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia) [Lesage et al 2006]
-
Approximately 18% of PD in Ashkenazi Jews (13% of simplex cases and 30% of familial cases) [Ozelius et al 2006]
-
0.4% of simplex PD in Japan [Zabetian et al 2006].
Note: (1) p.G2019S was reported in a Japanese individual with PD in another study [Tomiyama et al 2006]. In that study, however, the frequency of p.G2019S was reported in a pooled Asian sample and the frequency among Japanese individuals with PD was not specified. (2) p.G2019S has not been identified in over 1,200 PD individuals of Chinese ancestry screened to date [Lu et al 2005, Tan et al 2006, Tomiyama et al 2006]. Combining all Asian populations into a single group is not advisable; therefore, it is quite possible that p.G2019S occurs among the Japanese but not in other Asian populations.
These frequencies have largely been extrapolated from clinic and/or community-based series, but in the US they are in close agreement with incidence-based samples.
Asymptomatic heterozygotes are noted within families, typically ascertained via an affected proband including a 91-year-old person [Gaig et al 2006]; however, pathogenic LRRK2 mutations have negligible frequency in age-/gender-matched population controls [Kachergus et al 2005; Mata, Kachergus et al 2005]. Among unselected individuals of Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry, the prevalence of p.G2019S is likely 1%-2% [Ozelius et al 2006, Saunders-Pullman et al 2006].
The p.R1441G mutation, present in about 8% of individuals with PD from the Basque community in Northern Spain, probably represents a founder mutation as it has not been reported outside of Spanish-speaking countries [Paisan-Ruiz et al 2004; Mata, Taylor et al 2005].