Natural History
Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is characterized by progressive muscle weakness involving the face, scapular stabilizers, upper arm, lower leg (peroneal muscles), and hip girdle [Tawil et al 1998]. Asymmetry of limb and/or shoulder weakness is common [Kilmer et al 1995]. Typically, individuals with FSHD become symptomatic in their teens, but age of onset is variable. More than 90% of affected individuals demonstrate findings by age 20 years. Individuals with severe infantile FSHD have muscle weakness at birth. In contrast, some individuals remain asymptomatic throughout their lives. Progression is usually slow and continuous; however, many affected individuals describe a stuttering course with periods of disease inactivity followed by periods of rapid deterioration. Eventually 20% of affected individuals require a wheelchair.
Scapular winging is the most common initial finding; preferential weakness of the lower trapezius muscle results in characteristic upward movement of the scapula when attempting to flex or abduct the arms. The shoulders tend to slope forward with straight clavicles and pectoral muscle atrophy.
Affected individuals show facial weakness, more in the lower facial muscles than the upper. Some affected individuals recall having facial weakness before the onset of shoulder weakness. Earliest signs are often difficulty whistling or sleeping with eyes partially open in childhood. They are unable to purse their lips, turn up the corners of their mouth when smiling, or bury their eyelashes when attempting to close their eyelids tightly. Extraocular, eyelid, and bulbar muscles are spared.
The deltoids remain minimally affected until late in the disease; however, the biceps and triceps are selectively involved, resulting in atrophy of the upper arm and sparing of the forearm muscles. The latter results in the appearance of ‘Popeye arms.’
Abdominal muscle weakness results in protuberance of the abdomen and exaggerated lumbar lordosis. The lower abdominal muscles are selectively involved, resulting in Beevor's sign, which is upward displacement of the umbilicus upon flexion of the neck in a supine position.
The legs are variably involved, with peroneal muscle weakness with or without weakness of the hip girdle muscles, resulting in foot drop.
Sensation is preserved; reflexes are often diminished.
Respiratory function is usually normal [Tawil & Griggs 1997] but occasionally compromised [Kilmer et al 1995].
Other manifestations. Retinal vasculopathy consisting of telangiectasia and microaneurysms can be demonstrated by fluorescein angiography in 40%-60% of affected individuals [Padberg et al 1995]. Vision is usually unaffected; however, Coats disease has been described. Bindoff et al [2006] reported two sisters with infantile onset FSHD who had tortuous retinal vessels, small aneurysms, and yellow exudates.
Approximately 60% of individuals with FSHD have an abnormal audiogram with high-tone sensorineural hearing loss [Brouwer et al 1991, Padberg et al 1995].
A predilection for atrial tachyarrhythmias has been reported in about 5% of cases, but symptoms are rarely observed [Laforet et al 1998, Galetta et al 2005, Trevisan et al 2006].
Atypical presentations. Clinical variants of typical FSHD in individuals with a contraction mutation of the D4Z4 locus in the subtelomeric region of chromosome 4q35 include the following:
-
Scapulohumeral dystrophy with facial sparing
-
Slowly progressive FSHD with progressive external ophthalmoplegia [Krasnianski et al 2003]. This kindred presents a departure from previously described atypical FSHD kindreds. Given the complexity of interpreting FSHD molecular genetic test results, more comprehensive molecular testing of this kindred is necessary before progressive external ophthalmoplegia can be included with certainty in the clinical spectrum of FSHD.
-
Infantile onset with severe rapidly progressive disease and a large contraction mutation of D4Z4 (D4Z4 fragments in the 9-21 kb range) was observed in 4% of individuals studied [Klinge et al 2006]. Felice et al [2005] and Bindoff et al [2006] have also reported cases with infantile onset. Mild to moderate cognitive deficiency and possible epilepsy have been reported in early-onset cases often with associated deafness and retinopathy [Bindoff et al 2006, Hobson-Webb & Caress 2006, Quarantelli et al 2006].The affected parent often had mild disease and was mosaic for a contraction mutation of the D4Z4 locus.
Pregnancy. Outcome of 105 pregnancies in 38 women with FSHD was generally favorable [Ciafaloni et al 2006]. However, rates for low birth weight and total operative deliveries were higher than for the general population. Worsening of weakness occured in 24% of the pregnancies.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
A correlation has been reported between the degree of the contraction mutation of the D4Z4 locus and the age at onset of symptoms [Zatz et al 1995], age at loss of ambulation [Lunt et al 1995], and muscle strength as measured by quantitative isometric myometry [Tawil et al 1996], particularly in affected females [Tonini et al 2004a]. Individuals with a large contraction of the D4Z4 locus tend to have earlier-onset disease and more rapid progression than those with smaller contractions of the D4Z4 locus [Bindoff et al 2006, Hobson-Webb & Caress 2006, Klinge et al 2006]. However, others have not been able to confirm a correlation between disease severity and degree of D4Z4 contraction mutations [Butz et al 2003].
De novo mutations are associated with larger contraction mutations of D4Z4 (on average) compared to the degree of D4Z4 contraction mutations observed segregating in families; hence, individuals with de novo mutations tend to have findings at the more severe end of the phenotypic spectrum.
Zatz et al [1998] have reported reduced penetrance in females with large contraction mutations of D4Z4, compared to the penetrance in males with similar-sized contraction mutations; these results support their previous findings (see Penetrance).
Mosaicism. The phenotypic severity of individuals with mosaicism, which is typically less than that of individuals without mosaicism, may reflect the proportion of cells carrying the contracted mutated D4Z4 locus in addition to the degree of the contraction of the D4Z4 locus in those cells.
Compound heterozygosity. Two unrelated affected individuals homozygous for a D4Z4 contraction mutation were reported by Wohlgemuth et al [2003], suggesting that the presence of two FSHD-associated alleles can be compatible with life. However, both families demonstrated reduced penetrance for FSHD, leaving open the possibility that in other genetic/environmental settings, compound heterozygosity might be a lethal condition. In support of this possibility, the authors report a phenotypic dosage effect in both of the compound heterozygotes in comparison to other family members.
Homozygosity. Tonini et al [2004b] reported an individual homozygous for the contraction on two 4qA alleles whose clinical phenotype is not more severe than those of some of his heterozygous relatives. Within the same family, the authors also observed a large number of asymptomatic or minimally affected heterozygotes, reflecting the wide range of clinical variability that can occur in a given kindred.